School Secretaries and Caretakers' Strike.

and also stopping inexperienced/useless managers from making a bad situation worst by, for example, asking the "have you thought about" question.
I suspect most think the are the best managers in the world hard to put listening to them,
 
Looks like you're missing the rest of the sentence there. However, what I posted is based on FORSA press releases, if you think they are misleading you should take it up with them,
I left that bit out to force you to admit you had already read post 71 when you posted post 78 :) o_O
 
I don't understand that post.
What I have always found is when you sit down with union reps, they want and are interested to hear what both sides have to say and want to make a sound well informed decision after all they have to go back and sound well informed when they go back to there members,

Sorry to say all too often you will find ill informed Managers who haven't done there homework and finish up making statements which doean't involve the truth and finish up making an Ill informed Decision which goes against them, These kind of Managers finish up blaming the Union which is Hard to listen to,
When the present dispute Gets settled you will see the Union Will come out on top ,
You only have to read the post hear to see some are not interested in making a sound well informed decision (End Off)
 
When the present dispute Gets settled you will see the Union Will come out on top ,
Of course they will, it's the State sector. They are holding the education sector to ransom and the Government will pay the ransom with other people's money. The people on both sides of the table are unionised and neither side is accountable for the money they spend or the consequences of that expenditure on other parts of the economy or society.
 
The discussions to find a settlement on the pensions question will be interesting.

There is
“ a government commitment to negotiate comparable pension entitlements for school secretaries and caretakers “
but that probably means different things to different people.
I presume they want all exisiting and new staff to join the SPSPS from here onwards.
This would be seem reasonable enough. But of course, there would be very little for some of the people who were on strike.

I support a pension scheme for these staff going forward.

I don’t support a retrospective awarding of a pension.
That seems very sensible also.

So what could the union want for their members in repsect of previous service?
The Government aren't simply going to say that all previous service is pensionable.
Is there be a possibility that staff pay retrospective contributions back to the introduction of the scheme in 2013 or when they joined after 2013, as if they were in the scheme from those dates and let them make back contributions either now or on retirement.

It’s hard to think that any service before the scheme started (pre 2013) would be allowed.

The IT editorial describes the strikers case as with considerable merit and only costing buttons. But the fear is the knock on effect to other parties looking for a piece of the action. Anybody know what they are referring to?


Presumably they'll also be enrolled in the new AE scheme
If these staff are workers, who are a natural fit for the AE scheme, and if they joined AE, then credit for previous service would not be an issue in AE (I presume).
So, possibly, the Government are worried about claims for retrospective service elsewhere in future, in the event that Forsa members get something on past service.
There could be other groups for whom AE is intended, who could see this a precedent (I know very little about AE).


There may be a bit to go to resolve the pensions issue and I wonder what benefits long serving staff will get as regards pensions.

We don't really have much idea of the detail of the union demands or the Departments' response.
If I was looking for information on the strike I would Go to The Union Web Site and see there take on the strike

I would then see what the employer take on the strike is so I have both sides views ,
That approach doesn't really help much on the detail!
 
You only have to read the post hear to see some are not interested in making a sound well informed decision (End Off)

Well said! After all, why bother to think for oneself when one's Trade Union has already done all of the thinking necessary! :D
 
It’s one thing thinking for oneself but I think in this case we can agree that it took a Trade Union acting that progressed the relevant demands.
Perhaps the school secretaries & caretakers thought process involved joining a Trade Union .
A wise course of action
 
Your extensive knowledge of the workings of Industrial Relations is very impressive, Waterford man. I expect you to go far in your chosen profession. At the moment those wise Trade Unionists are down a weeks' wages, plus their Trade Union fees. I wonder how long it will take them to break even.
 
Hopefully a minuscule loss for a major gain.
I’m sure if canvassed the school secretaries and caretakers would gladly agree that the loss of a week’s wages ( less strike pay ) is more than compensated by gaining a pension .
 
I’m sure if canvassed the school secretaries and caretakers would gladly agree that the loss of a week’s wages ( less strike pay ) is more than compensated by gaining a pension .

As long as it isn't retrospective, I have no great objection to them being allowed to join the Single PS Pension Scheme.

It's the "free lunch" aspect of their Union's demands that I find unacceptable. (Of course most Unions will demand the sun moon and stars in the expectation that they'll end up with a packet of sparklers and a box of birthday candles.)
 
The negotiations on the pension scheme are, to say the least , going to be difficult and no doubt will contain a demand/request for retrospection from Forsa who may well feel t they have the whip hand at this juncture.
I do believe that in the recent impasse between the Government and Forsa that it was the former who sought the sun , moon & stars as they sought to defend their indefensible position as most people realised the provision of a pension scheme was inevitable.
Always good to debate with a Rovers supporter , spent a lot of time on the Milltown terraces during my early days in Dublin.
Still a season ticket holder with the Blues and can proudly boast that my Grandfather played in the first Waterford team to play in the League of Ireland.
 
Back before the WRC today,
he negotiations on the pension scheme are, to say the least , going to be difficult and no doubt will contain a demand/request for retrospection from Forsa who may well feel t they have the whip hand at this juncture.
When you consider a total of 15% of payroll goes into the PRSI fund and close on 20% before USC came in,for School Secretaries and Caretakers
Add to this the public service pension for people on low wages all or most will be coming out of the PRSI Fund anyway I Don't see what the big fuss is about retrospection,
After all the are not employed in the private sector,
 
After all the are not employed in the private sector,
Isn't that the thing though, many of them are. While the state provides the significant bulk of funding to schools, the majority of them are privately owned and managed.
 
Isn't that the thing though, many of them are. While the state provides the significant bulk of funding to schools, the majority of them are privately owned and managed
Who pays them
the key element which gets lost is you and the person who posted in the first place have a slight problem understand, the are only looking for the same pension entitlements as people working in the same schools ie Special Need Assistants, (SNAs)
Up until now it was a way for the state to get labour on the cheap, ,one rule for one lot of workers and another rule for another lot of workers, taking advantage of the fact they were not in a union,
(who are they negotiating with, the private sector)
Shame on the state,
 
Last edited:
Back
Top