School Secretaries and Caretakers' Strike.

So, peeling away the blather, what bkenn is saying is that that he's happy for his kids and grandkids to foot the bills for everyone's pension for ever and ever, amen.

I'm not, although the 2% socialist in my big toe applauds his magnaminity with other people's money.
 
My Dear Purple
What you are really saying but don't realize it for whatever reason? ,
take for example the Company you work in has a very good pension scheme for people on higher wages,
but you don't want for some reason to have a good pension scheme for people on lower wages in the same Company,
We pay people well and they can choose to put some of their income into a pension scheme if they so wish. The same rules apply to everyone. We don't expect the tax payer to fund our employee pensions. I agree that it would be unfair if one group took more of the available resourced to fund their pension and left none for lower paid employees. The obvious conclusion of what you are saying is that the existing and future pensions of teachers should be cut slightly in order to fund the pensions of secretaries and caretakers. In that case I agree with you.
More than likely it is the work of people on lower wages that pay your wages but you don't realize it,
I'm well aware that the people who work for me earn my wages. I've said it many times.
A very old and a trough saying The Dog in the Manger in this case it refers to people who have a good pension but would like to prevent others workers in the same Company from having the same, in others words they like to have there Snout In The Trough but prevent others from having the same benefits if at all possible, ;)
Like State employees did to new entrants after the financial crash? Yes, that was disgraceful and made a complete mockery of union membership solidarity.
 
So, peeling away the blather, what bkenn is saying is that that he's happy for his kids and grandkids to foot the bills for everyone's pension for ever and ever, amen.
Not what i said, You know that,
Well you have been proved wrong in your first post about timing, Timing was perfect less than 3 Months To AE in Jan 2026
You were wrong again about the return in Investment a few days strike appears to have got the department to engage (Sorry to say it took mild strike action to get there,
I'm not, although the 2% socialist in my big toe applauds his magnaminity with other people's money.
The other 98% is the problem my dear friend, No Socialist Government would ever get away with giving into Union demands /
Unions Love Your 98% your 98% type will always return a Centrist coalition to power and you will be a little unhappy to hear you support will ensure your kids and your grandkids will pay a heavy price for that 98% you were on about,
 
No Socialist Government would ever get away with giving into Union demands
We have a socialist government. They have increased welfare rates and the minimum wage ahead of inflation. They have vastly increase spending on public health and education and a quarter of the workforce doesn't pay any income tax. Only from a far left perspective could any Irish government in the last 20 years be described as anything other than socialist. I'm not saying that's a bad thing, just pointing it out.
 
We have a socialist government. They have increased welfare rates and the minimum wage ahead of inflation. They have vastly increase spending on public health and education and a quarter of the workforce doesn't pay any income tax. Only from a far left perspective could any Irish government in the last 20 years be described as anything other than socialist. I'm not saying that's a bad thing, just pointing it out.
This is the problem, Most people on line who were against giving school secretaries and caretakers a pension have a blind spot despite having the capacity to understand and acknowledge one group of workers have a pension scheme and another group have no pension and look to be treated all the same,
most strikers vote support and belong to the same political parties as the people who are close to getting a heart attack most strikers only joined a union in 2019 to be treated the same as people in a union in the same building,

Having to join a union to be treated the same as other workers in the same building by the same Employer speaks for itself,
 
This is the problem, Most people on line who were against giving school secretaries and caretakers a pension have a blind spot despite having the capacity to understand and acknowledge one group of workers have a pension scheme and another group have no pension and look to be treated all the same
If they were looking for a more equitable distribution of the existing funds then I'd have no problem with that. The problem is that they are not looking for the existing resources to be distributed more equally. They are looking for money to be taken from other people in order to fund their pensions.
Having to join a union to be treated the same as other workers in the same building by the same Employer speaks for itself,
Unions taking more and more money from other people rather than a more equitable distribution of the existing funds, or tough as you put it, speaks for itself. It's like the pigs in Animal Farm.

The Secretaries and Caretakers want a metaphorical seat at the metaphorical pigs table and it looks like they are getting it. Once the head is in the trough and the backside is in the air they stop seeing those who can't get near the trough. That's Unions for you; protecting the haves from the have-not's.
 
If they were looking for a more equitable distribution of the existing funds then I'd have no problem with that. The problem is that they are not looking for the existing resources to be distributed more equally. They are looking for money to be taken from other people in order to fund their pensions.
no that is not correct,
Any interaction i seen the want to be treated the same as other employees in the same building by the same employer,
It is up to the Employer how they go about financing the inbalance the created,
Unions taking more and more money from other people rather than a more equitable distribution of the existing funds, or tough as you put it, speaks for itself. It's like the pigs in Animal Farm.
not correct again
Trade union have a subscription/membership fee which only members pay,
it is not uncommon to find people who were anti-union most of there life live to regret not been in a union when things went wrong,
The Secretaries and Caretakers want a metaphorical seat at the metaphorical pigs table and it looks like they are getting it. Once the head is in the trough and the backside is in the air they stop seeing those who can't get near the trough. That's Unions for you; protecting the haves from the have-not's.
not correct again
I had to deal with unions all of my life in the private sector,
I know employers who felt there would not be able to deal with unions, All Got Found Out In The end Business all went under and no union to blame,
Most finished up putting away to much food in the trough:eek:
 
Last edited:
Well you have been proved wrong in your first post about timing, Timing was perfect less than 3 Months To AE in Jan 2026
You were wrong again about the return in Investment a few days strike appears to have got the department to engage (Sorry to say it took mild strike action to get there,

:D

Engaging is relatively easy (unless your name is Putin).

The fun will begin when the Official Side explains slowly - using words that even a Trade Unionist can understand - what the word "contributory" means.
 
Engaging is relatively easy (unless your name is Putin).

The fun will begin when the Official Side explains slowly - using words that even a Trade Unionist can understand - what the word "contributory" means.
Na
If you check and it was a mild strike by all accounts Government Ministers and backbenchers Broke ranks on the very first day of the strike not looking good from the employers side,
I suspect the will be asking the unions to define contributory which will be defined benefit for those who do not understand
The Department of Education is not A Simi-State Company you know,:)
 
Last edited:
Employer how they go about financing the inbalance the created,
That's the crux of it; the unions want to take more money from other people and give it to their members. Then they'll complain about child poverty and cuts to services etc. Hypocrites and charlatans the lot of them, protecting the haves from the have-not's.
 
That's the crux of it; the unions want to take more money from other people and give it to their members. Then they'll complain about child poverty and cuts to services etc. Hypocrites and charlatans the lot of them, protecting the haves from the have-not's.
In the private sector I have very little time for people who think like this,
 
In the private sector I have very little time for people who think like this,
Do you mean that you have very little time for the self interest and hypocrisy of Unions or that you have very little time for people who call it out?

Unions represent well educated middle income and upper middle income employees in the protected sector. They are a long way from where they started. Remember when they are Trade Unions? Now they are Protected Sector Unions (State and Semi-State Sectors and others not open to international competition). Orwell was right; read the last chapter of Animal Farm.
 
They are a long way from where they started. Remember when they are Trade Unions? Now they are Protected Sector Unions (State and Semi-State Sectors and others not open to
Well in this case we had a state sector who only look after you if you are in a union,;)
 
Well in this case we had a state sector who only look after you if you are in a union,
No, they look after themselves first and after that they look after the people they are paid to look after. That's why, for example, one of the best funded health services in the world is so deficient in so many ways.
I remember after the crash the teachers refused to take the required pay cut so special needs assistants were cut and vulnerable children suffered.

That's what unions do; they are a vested interest group which seeks to further the interests of their members to the detriment of society at large. They are parasitical at a societal level. They, due to the waste they cause and perpetuate, are a large part of the reason people die on trolleys in hospitals and children can't get scoliosis operations.
 
I can understand where secretaries and caretakers are coming from...their fellow workers, with the same employer, are on better terms and they would like the same. The fact of the matter though, is that they are different jobs

In yesterday's Independent, it was reported that hospital consultants who sign up to Slaintecare public only contacts can get a 500,000 pension boost. Would other workers in Slaintecare expect the same pension?

 
No, they look after themselves first and after that they look after the people they are paid to look after. That's why, for example, one of the best funded health services in the world is so deficient in so many ways.
I remember after the crash the teachers refused to take the required pay cut so special needs assistants were cut and vulnerable children suffered.

That's what unions do; they are a vested interest group which seeks to further the interests of their members to the detriment of society at large. They are parasitical at a societal level. They, due to the waste they cause and perpetuate, are a large part of the reason people die on trolleys in hospitals and children can't get scoliosis operations.
A load of rubbish,
I would say The cause of most the Above can be traced to the practice of hiring individuals who were previously employed in private companies into the health sector by the Government of the day, almost all tried to fix things that were not broken and soon found themselves away in over there head resulting in the above,
 
I can understand where secretaries and caretakers are coming from...their fellow workers, with the same employer, are on better terms and they would like the same.
Variations in terms across very different roles is common in the workplace. Just look to the HSE and its member hospitals for an organisation crippled by myriad variations with all attempts to harmonise torpedoed by the unions.

Many employers in the private sector use variations in terms to attract highly qualified people to fill demanding roles, sometimes with very significant bonus or share opportunities tied to the financial performance of the company.
 
I can understand where secretaries and caretakers are coming from...their fellow workers, with the same employer, are on better terms and they would like the same. The fact of the matter though, is that they are different jobs

In yesterday's Independent, it was reported that hospital consultants who sign up to Slaintecare public only contacts can get a 500,000 pension boost. Would other workers in Slaintecare expect the same pension?
Hope you will be happy when the negotiations between the Dept and the Secretaries and Caretakers reach agreement on there contract , :)once the Hospital Consultants on public only contracts are happy with there contract all will be well
Once Other health care workers are happy with there contract all will be well
Once the Secretaries and Caretakers in different Jobs in the department of Education are happy all will be well,

all of the above contracts were the results of Negotiations, some had more leverage than others when it came to Negotiations
the Secretaries and caretakers went on a mild strike for more leverage,
on the first day of the mild strike you had present Government ministers and backbenchers siding with them which speaks for it self,
 
Variations in terms across very different roles is common in the workplace. Just look to the HSE and its member hospitals for an organisation crippled by myriad variations with all attempts to harmonise torpedoed by the unions
well the union in this case would be very happy to harmonise pensions if the Dept would agree to it in this case,
 
Back
Top