School Secretaries and Caretakers' Strike.

The private enterprises who own and run the schools. They are not on the payroll of any branch of the public service
ALL 2,500
Who pays the teachers and SNAs 2500 looking to be treated same as SNAs and teachers,in the same schools,
 
Last edited:
If someone wants to be treated like a teacher, they should become a teacher. Hey, I'd love to have the perks that the traders and fund managers in the company I work for enjoy, but I applied for my job with the full knowledge of what the package associated with my role would be, no one forced me to take the job, no one is forcing me to stay. I was talking to our local school secretary recently, it's funny how she was so happy in the job for 15 years until someone told her she shouldn't be.
 
the key element which gets lost is you and the person who posted in the first place have a slight problem understand, the are only looking for the same pension entitlements as people working in the same schools ie Special Need Assistants, (SNAs)
Do you think that cleaners in hospitals should have the same pension entitlement as surgeons?
Do you think that cabin crew should be treated the same as pilots?
Why do you think that geographic proximity is a sufficient ground for equalisation of employment entitlements?
 
Last edited:
Do you think that cleaners in hospitals should have the same pension entitlement as surgeons?
Do you think that cabin crew should be treated the same as pilots?
Why do you think that geographic proximity is a sufficient ground for equalisation of employment entitlements?
Well every Company I know of in the private sector who have a long term interest in the betterment of there Company, have close to the same pension arrangements in place for all of there employees,
When you think about You will realize the people who are pilots and surgeons spent away longer on strikes or refused to do there jobs until they got what the wanted
Don't ever forget Cleaners in Hospitals do there Job as well if not better than Surgeon's, so treat then with respect,
I find most people who have a narrow perspective and refuse to take the time to consider the caretakers point of view only focus on there limited experiences and lack of empathy for others less well off than themselves,
 
Well every Company I know of in the private sector who have a long term interest in the betterment of there Company, have close to the same pension arrangements in place for all of there employees,
I'm not aware of any company that doesn't have an interest in the long term betterment of the company. Most of the ones I know offer what the State obliges them to offer; access to a pension fund.
When you think about You will realize the people who are pilots and surgeons spent away longer on strikes or refused to do there jobs until they got what the wanted
That's a completely subjective view.
Don't ever forget Cleaners in Hospitals do there Job as well if not better than Surgeon's,
Do they? By what measure and using what data do you come to that conclusion? I'm not saying you are wrong, but I've never seen data to substantiate that view.
so treat then with respect,
I treat everyone with respect.
I find most people who have a narrow perspective and refuse to take the time to consider the caretakers point of view only focus on there limited experiences and lack of empathy for others less well off than themselves,
Empathy is not a good way of establishing appropriate pay and conditions. It is the opposite of taking a broader perspective. An employer has no moral or societal responsibility to pay anything other than what the market will stand and what is mandated by law. If there is a moral responsibility to provide an income which meets the needs or requirements of an individual then that obligation is on the State.
 
Empathy is not a good way of establishing appropriate pay and conditions.

Ah, but that's partly what the Public Service Unions are for: to force "empathy" on the taxpayer!

It works like this:

"Hey wage slave did you know that if you pay us a small portion of your meagre wages every week, then we'll bully your employer into giving you more, whether or not you're entitled to receive it. Oh, and don't worry your pretty little heads about where the extra money will come from because that's the employer's problem! Now comrades, let's all join hands together and pray that Catherine Connolly wins the Presidential election!"
 
Last edited:
Ah, but that's partly what the Public Service Unions are for: to force "empathy" on the taxpayer!

It works like this:

"Hey wage slave di you know that if you pay us a small portion of your meagre wages every week, then we'll bully your employer into giving you more, whether or not you're entitled to receive it. Oh, and don't worry your pretty little heads about where the extra money will come from because that's the employer's problem! Now comrades, let's all join hands together and pray that Catherine Connolly wins the Presidential election!
First off this Thread Is About School Secretaries And Caretakers Strike Which You Started
How You Mix Catherine Connolly Up with the above short lived Strike Which You Said Forsa will be facing a Large Bill< I will let you read back on the rest you posted on post no1 in your own time,
The only thing I can say to you 100% of the supporters who called to my door on behalf of FG and FF were paying Members in a union,
I expect many supporters from FF and FG will be calling over the next few weeks looking for votes for Heather and Jim will be payed up members of a union,
If any or all of the 3 Candidates gets asked about the School Secretaries and Caretakers Strike none will agree with your position,
So No Matter Who You Vote For You Will Be wasted your Vote And Will Be Indirectly Supporting Forsa,
t's very clear that the "Official Side" is completely opposed to this and won't roll over easily, so Forsa will be facing a large bill for strike pay with little chance of achieving a positive outcome. I wonder what face-saving arrangement they'll ultimately manage to cobble together
Yours,
 
Last edited:
If any or all of the 3 Candidates gets asked about the School Secretaries and Caretakers Strike none will agree with your position
Of course they will. Jim is a career Public Servant. Heather worked in the bank and the Credit Union, both unionised protected sector jobs. Catherine worked as a Clinical Phycologist for the HSE but, ironically, as she also worked as a Barrister she's probably spent more time self employed than the other two. I'm sure all three will endorse the strike as that's the populist thing to do and you can't upset anyone who works in a school or hospital as they are collectively emotionally fragile and need the constant validation of strangers.
 
Of course they will. Jim is a career Public Servant. Heather worked in the bank and the Credit Union, both unionised protected sector jobs. Catherine worked as a Clinical Phycologist for the HSE but, ironically, as she also worked as a Barrister she's probably spent more time self employed than the other two. I'm sure all three will endorse the strike as that's the populist thing to do and you can't upset anyone who works in a school or hospital as they are collectively emotionally fragile and need the constant validation of strangers.
The problem I have is the amount of Brainwashed private sector workers/employers who vote for a party and never take a good look at what the candidate the support/vote is really like,
What I find and to be honest I supported FG most of my life is Union members tend to be more politically active and are very effective at getting out the vote for there chosen left wing candidate from there left wing base in my local FG constituency known full well if the put a false center/right/left hat on there candidate the purples and bkeen of this world will vote left wing muttering something like we vote for who will do the least damage pushing FG and FF further to the left,

what I find is the Candidate that I expect to be left of FG is actually to the right of the FG Candidate for the most part,
Granted we do not have any extreme left wing candidate running more left than FG of FF,

It is the brainwashed Private workers and Employers who vote left and think of themselves as Center-Right/Left who use the excuse I vote for the party that will do the least damage when the real reason is because there policies primarily benefit them short term and to hell with the long term damage they cause to the generation that comes after them,
 
Last edited:
First off this Thread Is About School Secretaries And Caretakers Strike Which You Started

I deeply resent your suggestion that I started that strike. Indeed I regard it as potentially defamatory and will be consulting my lawyers.

Brendan takes a dim view of libellous statements and I suspect that unless you withdraw, he may put you across his knee and chastise you appropriately. You have been warned. :(
 
The problem I have is the amount of Brainwashed private sector workers/employers who vote for a party and never take a good look at what the candidate the support/vote is really like,
What I find and to be honest I supported FG most of my life is Union members tend to be more politically active and are very effective at getting out the vote for there chosen left wing candidate from there left wing base in my local FG constituency known full well if the put a false center/right/left hat on there candidate the purples and bkeen of this world will vote left wing muttering something like we vote for who will do the least damage pushing FG and FF further to the left,...
I don't understand the point you are trying to make.
 
I walked past a school in Dundrum last week. The street-side windows were populated by posters (presumably drawn by primary students) highlighting support for the school secretaries.

Whatever about the merits of the claim, I find it appalling that young children should be drawn into the debate and made to create posters in support of an issue, the nuances of which they couldn’t possibly understand.
 
Whatever about the merits of the claim, I find it appalling that young children should be drawn into the debate and made to create posters in support of an issue, the nuances of which they couldn’t possibly understand.
My daughter's teacher is a strong supporter of the Palestinian Arabs. That's fine but she won't allow the students in her care to refer to Israel as Israel. I've a meeting with the year head this Friday. I'll be insisting that she not indoctrinate her students in that way.
 
My daughter's teacher is a strong supporter of the Palestinian Arabs. That's fine but she won't allow the students in her care to refer to Israel as Israel. I've a meeting with the year head this Friday. I'll be insisting that she not indoctrinate her students in that way.
It would be interesting to hear of that's teacher's opinion of Hamas executing its own people
 
Getting children to make posters about a pension dispute is inappropriate but hardly appalling.
Well I find it appalling that supposedly intelligent adults would get young children to do their bidding. Let them be kids for as long as possible.

I know they’re not exactly getting them to carry drugs in their school bags but it’s extremely bad form in my opinion.
 
Well I find it appalling that supposedly intelligent adults would get young children to do their bidding. Let them be kids for as long as possible.

I couldn't agree more. But we should probably reserve such a strong label for what they hear about in religion class and at church services.

For all we know the parents gave approval for them to take part in producing the propaganda.
 
Back
Top