School Secretaries and Caretakers' Strike.

Hope you will be happy when the negotiations between the Dept and the Secretaries and Caretakers reach agreement on there contract , :)once the Hospital Consultants on public only contracts are happy with there contract all will be well
I think you might be missing my point. Secretaries and Caretakers are negotiating based on the terms enjoyed by workers doing a different job.
 
One thing that strikes me on this thread is the amount of non union members advising paid up union members about unions.
It's like people who don't smoke talking about people who do smoke. The non smokers have to pay for the damage smoking does to the health of the smokers in the same way that non union members have to pay for the damage unions do to the health of the nation. The people dying on trolleys in hospitals due to the waste caused by unions are like the non smokers who get cancer from passive smoking.
 
I think you might be missing my point. Secretaries and Caretakers are negotiating based on the terms enjoyed by workers doing a different job
Nothing unusual or out of the ordinary I would say quite common in negotiations in both the public and private sectors in union and non union negotiations,
 
once the Hospital Consultants on public only contracts are happy with there contract all will be well
Once Other health care workers are happy with there contract all will be well
Unless your a sick person who needs access to our public health system.
 
One thing that strikes me on this thread is the amount of non union members advising paid up union members about unions.
Ex Union member here who left the union many years ago after the geniuses in the union managed to negotitiate a short term improvement for a long term loss for its members but who "sold" the deal as the greatest thing since sliced bread. I've also sat opposite the unions and negotiated deals on many an occassion and found you had the "optics" of the meetings in front of local shop-stewards/reps and then the coffee and bun 10 miles away with the senior union people where the real deal was done. Hence, from my past experience, I am skeptical on any union. They're a business, and the full time staffs wages are paid for by their customers (ie members)

Having said that, where they have been great for me in the past is in putting manners on their own members by telling them that their "case" has no basis, legal or otherwise, and also stopping inexperienced/useless managers from making a bad situation worst by, for example, asking the "have you thought about" question.
 
Having said that, where they have been great for me in the past is in putting manners on their own members by telling them that their "case" has no basis, legal or otherwise, and also stopping inexperienced/useless managers from making a bad situation worst by, for example, asking the "have you thought about" question
Yes above would be normal enough from dealing with Unions,
After the crash in 2008/9 the unions around where I live switched Branch secretaries around putting the private sector rep into the public sector
and the public sector rep into the private sector, I can say the former public sector rep was pretty good at seeing both points of view in any dealings we had,
 
well the union in this case would be very happy to harmonise pensions if the Dept would agree to it in this case,
Of course they would. They want us taxpayers to fork out more money to their members for zero additional output.
 
Foras , depending on how the talks go will hopefully meet their mandate to improve the terms and conditions of their members .
Of course the secretaries and caretakers know that contributions will be asked of them in terms of part funding pensions , obviously the Government as employers will make a somewhat similar contribution .
Presumably as the salaries have been linked to the clerical officer grade it makes sense that pensions would be similarly linked to.
There should be interesting conversations held on the question of backdating entitlements !
Let’s be honest the only reason the secretaries and caretakers have been successful is because they had the foresight to join a Union .
Fair play to the Government in compromising after a brief standoff as I believe they hadn’t a leg to stand on , the claim of knock on claims was a spurious one .
If a claim has validity then that should be the only criterion
 
Last edited:
Respectfully, secretaries and caretakers are taxpayers too
I see this as a Form of spitefully trying to prevent others from having something which they enjoy themselves already,o_O
I think I already said Dog In The Manger, being Diplomatic ,
 
Last edited:
I see this as a Form of spitefully trying to prevent others from having something which they enjoy themselves already
Very few people in the wealth creating sectors of the economy enjoy the kind of pensions that teachers and others in the protected sector enjoy.
 
I said it before, and I’ll say it again - @Purple is the greatest recruitment tool a trades union could have. Keep it up Purple.
Yes, if you want to join a vested interest group which exploits the weak and vulnerable in order to feather the nest of its members then join a union. They are utterly shameless and really good at it. You'll need a strong stomach and a weak conscience though.
 
I said it before, and I’ll say it again - @Purple is the greatest recruitment tool a trades union could have. Keep it up Purple.
thinking is related It is a kind of Herd Behavior thinking A Union is more powerful verson where people come together to achieve a common goal,

on the other hand you can have negative consequences when it comes to herd behavior when individuals find a larger group who often disregarding ignore information and judgements to stay in this group,
Think Make America Great Again,
 
I see this as a Form of spitefully trying to prevent others from having something which they enjoy themselves already
It's nothing whatsoever to do with what I have myself, and there is no spite directed at the individuals involved, I mean, who doesn't want more pay for doing the same job!

What I have an issue with is a union pushing the logic that all employed in a setting should be treated equally, but only in certain very specific aspects that suit their own agenda. In this case secretaries and caretakers wanted parity with teachers on a select set of aspects, but I didn't hear anyone suggesting they should be required to attain similar levels of education or qualification in order to justify improved remuneration?

I have a big problem with equality of outcome, it leads to mediocrity at best. Differentiating pay and terms is important to motivate capable people to achieve more and deliver better value for whoever is footing the bill.

No one put a gun to these people's heads to take these jobs, or even stay in them, there are many other opportunities out there for them in the market. Yet most of them you hear from were very happy in their employment until someone else told them they were hard done by.
 
Back
Top