School Secretaries and Caretakers' Strike.

Marsupial

Registered User
Messages
1,820
Pick your battles carefully! This seems to me to be a very bad move by Forsa.

Their members pay PRSI so will be eligible for the State Pension. Presumably they'll also be enrolled in the new AE scheme so will be getting the government top up. So why do they want to join a pension scheme to which they haven't ever contributed, so will have zero entitlements?

It's very clear that the "Official Side" is completely opposed to this and won't roll over easily, so Forsa will be facing a large bill for strike pay with little chance of achieving a positive outcome. I wonder what face-saving arrangement they'll ultimately manage to cobble together.
 
I don’t know the full story regarding this action. There was a time when I would. Therefore, my comments would be without foundation. But from my experience in the civil/public service nobody goes on strike willingly, it’s the last resort. I have participated in strikes many years ago and I can say it does little or no good to the strikers. Did someone mention strike pay? What strike pay? There’ll be none.
 
It all depends will SNAs pass the picket line,if the don't I expect they will not get paid, Lots of SNAs are looking after close family members in school, it is a double edged sword support Forsa or support there own families, Mind you the Independents in Government will need to be very careful how they play this one,Boxer paid the price for not supporting the Defence Forces Campaign in 2020,
 
Last edited:
I have participated in strikes many years ago and I can say it does little or no good to the strikers.

Yep. I suspect that Forsa may have been busily recruiting these workers in recent times and are now expected to deliver the undeliverable.

As for strike pay; I'm shocked to hear that any intelligent person would willingly opt to participate in an all-out indefinite strike without having the reassurance of receiving some strike pay in return.
 
When you withdraw labour:-
1. You do not get paid.
2. You don’t receive any credit towards your pension. The total number of days you are on nil rate of pay is deducted from your service.
3. When you return to work you must complete arrears from strike.
4. No striker wants to be on strike in the first instance.
5. When you are involved in a lengthy strike you can be sure that the financial institutions will chase you to repay what you’ve borrowed - that’s your only certainty.
6. When you feel you’ve lost nearly everything and public opinion is against you, you dig in because when you have nothing, you feel it can’t get any worse. You couldn’t give a whit if the sun never shone again.
7. All goodwill is put on hold.
8. And then there are the strike breakers . . .

Again, I’m in Italy and I don’t know the full facts of the dispute. I’m just writing down my own feelings of being on a lengthy strike. I would also say that all trades unions in Ireland are losing members by the hour exponentially. Why do you vote to go on strike? Because all other avenues have been tried and you’ve reached the end of your tether. When a lengthy strike ends you become a very different person. I know, I was there.
 
Why do you vote to go on strike? Because all other avenues have been tried and you’ve reached the end of your tether. When a lengthy strike ends you become a very different person. I know, I was there.

Or, because you believe the promises from your Union rep that you can have free bread and jam, "because you're entitled to it" or "because the employer will roll over".
 
Last edited:
No @Marsupial, I have never come on the type of promises you mentioned from any trades unions. How did you come up with such? Or did you just make it up?
 
Last edited:
Have you, in your extensive progress through life, ever encountered the word "speculation"?

Because that's what my comment was - indeed, come to think about it, that's what many of my comments are.

Because, my dear Leper, not being a psychic, when I see people doing irrational things - like our dear friend Jim Gavin! - I can really only speculate as to their motives!
 
I was thinking about Forsa and strikers when I read this interesting book review in yesterday's Examiner. (I'm looking forward to reading the book)


and when I read this equally interesting interview:-

WE DESERVE EQUALITY
 
was thinking about Forsa and striktimeers when I read this interesting book review in yesterday's Examiner. (I'm looking forward to reading the book)
I would say you have a better chance of figuring out Forsa and the strikers from reading your 1st post,
I would say this strike at this time is all about picking your battle before MFF comes in,
I don't see any bitterness seeing it is billed as an Indefinitely strike for an unspecified time,
 
Forsa, (based on a quick online search and not confirmed BTW) have revenue of €20m per annum and a fund of €50m for strike pay/legal disputes etc. I'd imagine, as part of their claim to get the state pension, they would want some element of this back-dated based on service

I'm aware of one special needs school in the South East where teaching staff refused to cross the picket and it generated a bit of a backlash on line, so that may make the union more cautious.
 
Whenever an employer seeks to change the terms and conditions of employment the unions involved don't hesitate to demand a payment in exchange for the proposed changes.

Me being (as bkenn14 has shrewdy observed above) reasonably intelligent, I assume that Forsa are currently in the process of drawing up a financial offer to submit to the employer in exchange for the improved terms and conditions of employment that they are seeking for their members!

Yet I heard a (presumably reasonably intelligent) Forsa representative on the RTE this morning complaining that THEY haven't received any proposals from the employer! :eek: (I suspect that the employer is calculating how much Forsa will need to pay the Irish taxpayer in order to contrinute to the cost of the improved work conditions that they are looking for!) :)

I have ordered a large carton of popcorn and am looking forward to developments.
 
Last edited:
What seems unusual about this dispute is that so little is known about the demands of the secretaries and caretakers. Amongst other things, they are seeking pension parity with teachers. But what would that mean? Teachers have 3 or 4 different schemes and there isn’t even parity amongst them.

Would a pre ‘95 secretary expect parity with a pre ’95 teacher; would a post 2013 secretary want to join the Single Public Service Scheme? But those post 2013 teachers have been contributing since they joined. So would parity include paying back-contributions.

Pension parity means nothing unless there is some detail.

Media analysis is really poor and a lot of the coverage is little more than a few Principals expressing support!

I imagine secretaries may have a difficult enough job unless teachers and management have administrative skills themselves.

What are secretaries/caretakers entitled to – state pension? do they get same holidays as teachers? do they work teachers’ hours or longer days? Do they have parity in some areas already?
A bit more detail in the public domain would help understand the dispute better.
 
These are two relatively unskilled jobs.
A part time administrator is not equivalent to a teacher. Either is someone who can cut the grass, lock a door, unblock a sink and paint a wall.
If those roles are on par with being a teacher then teaching must be far easier and less skilled than teachers lead us to believe.

The strike is a case of arm chancing at its finest.
 
What seems unusual about this dispute is that so little is known about the demands of the secretaries and caretakers. Amongst other things, they are
seeking pension parity with teachers. But what would that mean? Teachers have 3 or 4 different schemes and there isn’t even parity amongst them.
Are you making the above up,

I never ever worked in the public service But I have worked and had to deal with unions in the private sector for most of my working life now retired,

My take on people Who badmouth unions is the would make very bad managers in the private sector most have closed minds on how unions in the private sector for the most part operate
I have yet to meet a union that wanted to put the income from Members subscriptions in danger,

I have seen and read over and over again the want to be in the single pension scheme,

If you are looking to check it out Just go back to post no 11 your post was post 15 Just click on we deserve Equality,

Go down to where it says ( How Did It Come To This?) it is there for you to read

If I was looking for information on the strike I would Go to The Union Web Site and see there take on the strike

I would then see what the employer take on the strike is so I have both sides views ,
 
Last edited:
I've always been a big fan of Unions, all the benefits we have now were hard won over the decades.

I worked at one point in a plant where there was an industrial dispute which ended up with pickets on the plant. Saw it coming and booked a few days holidays.

Would not cross a picket line.You have to work with these lads afterward, that bad feeling can follow you round for years after the dispute is long forgotten.

I expect this will become a dilemma for many teachers.
 
Last edited:
Got a message on school app today saying they support their colleagues. This is not the purpose of the school app.
Totally inappropriate.
 
Back
Top