School Secretaries and Caretakers' Strike.

If you park the pension side of things, in fairness, a lot of what the secretaries and caretakers are asking for is not unreasonable in this day and age, including a sick pay scheme, a centralised contract and to no longer be dependent on a grant to a school to pay their wages. They often have to sign on over the summer (teachers don't) and Leo Varadker said 5 years ago he was going to regularise their positions which has not really happened.

Not a fan of unions, sat on the opposite side of a desk from their professional reps often enough to know what they can be like and how it is often about optics rather then detailed change but I do think on this occassion, the secretaries may have a point.
 
Last edited:
If caretakers and secretaries only join the SPSPS from a current date, that be of little benefit to any existing members with longish service. The SPSPS would be ok for new or recently recruited staff who would have years to work to accumulate service and to pay contributions.

But is it known what is being sought by the union for members with say 25/30 years’ service? there would have to be special provisions for those people .

I was listening to a caretaker being interviewed, due to retire in the next year or so, who said that he would be only entitled to the state pension and would be hoping to get an occupational pension. He is not going to get much/any benefit from the SPSPS and neither will many of his colleagues with long service, unless additional arrangements are put in place for such people eg in the form of credit for years worked or favourable terms of buy-back of service etc. And that will be difficult to achieve.

It’s a complex one and further complicated as the SPSPS did not exist pre 2013.
Presumably they'll also be enrolled in the new AE scheme so will be getting the government top up.
That’s an interesting question – how future AE benefits would compare to the SPSPS. The SPSPS is not a great scheme compared to its predecessors, but works well where people progress in their career, particularly early on.
That would not be the case for these workers who have limited opportunity to progress from their existing salary scales.
They often have to sign on over the summer
So those periods would not be reckonable as pensionable service?
 
The IT editorial describes the strikers case as with considerable merit and only costing buttons. But the fear is the knock on effect to other parties looking for a piece of the action. Anybody know what they are referring to?
 
The IT editorial describes the strikers case as with considerable merit and only costing buttons

This was the part of the editorial that surprised me: "....... to collect on the promise Varadkar made at the time to regularise their employment terms and conditions, and pension rights...." Could it be that, although never a Minister either for Finance or Education, Leo of the Loose Lips may have written a blank cheque that someone else will need to sign?
 
I support a pension scheme for these staff going forward.

I don’t support a retrospective awarding of a pension.

It would be impossible to administer. School records around historical employment and pay will be very patchy.
 
It’s looking increasingly promising for the Union , the school secretaries and caretakers in terms of their demands being met .
Hugely supportive editorials in both the Irish Times and Irish Independent, strong public support and importantly from teaching colleagues who are refusing to cover their work .
A number of TD’s have voiced support for their demands including TD’s from Government parties.
Allied to the fact that their action has caused some classes to be cancelled and caused major health and security issues and post remaining unanswered and SNA’s becoming increasingly disaffected I can see the Government returning to the table soon .
Stay strong , another week or less on strike with the benefit of strike pay could force the Government to accede to the demands .
 
Would they also get paid during the summer?
Think teachers take their salary at reduced level during term time and this allows salaries to be paid over holiday months?

Can't see why this can't be done for secretaries and Janitors.
 
Just wondering how come this has all blown up now - surely the secretaries and maintenance staff have been in this position for years and nothing was ever done about it or protested against it....For decades its all been about teachers pay & conditions ?
 
Just wondering how come this has all blown up now - surely the secretaries and maintenance staff have been in this position for years and nothing was ever done about it or protested against it....For decades its all been about teachers pay & conditions ?
They've been protesting for years, some changes were made and Leo said he's sort the rest of it 5 years ago but failed to do so
 
Strike suspended , Forsa confirm that an agreement has been reached at the WRC the key element of which is “ a government commitment to negotiate comparable pension entitlements for school secretaries and caretakers “
Great news and congratulations to all parties involved.
 
Think teachers take their salary at reduced level during term time and this allows salaries to be paid over holiday months?
That's just semantics. They get paid during the summer holidays.
Can't see why this can't be done for secretaries and Janitors.
If their existing monthly pay is reduced pro-rata then I've no problem with that. If their income is increased in order to pay them for the summer holidays then that's a different matter.
 
Yee-haw! Yet another open-ended bill for the Irish taxpayer to pick up when the good times come to an end.
How dare you be logical about this! Everyone on a low income deserves everything they ask for. You must hate children (or something equally emotive and equally irrationally groundless).

My friends wife works as a school secretary. It's a part time job to keep her busy and give her a social outlet as their kids are all grown up (her words). She can stop losing sleep about her pension now. Her fears of starving to death in her dotage have been alleviated. The wolf is no longer at the door. She is crying tears of joy and relief this morning. She no longer faces a future of picking sticks out of the ditches to sell as kindling or going on the game to make ends meet.


Her husband earns €200,000 a year and we've an extremely generous welfare and State pension system as it is so there's a strong possibility that she would have been okay either way... but that's not the point! Think about the children!
 
Last edited:
My Dear Purple
What you are really saying but don't realize it for whatever reason? ,
take for example the Company you work in has a very good pension scheme for people on higher wages,
but you don't want for some reason to have a good pension scheme for people on lower wages in the same Company,
More than likely it is the work of people on lower wages that pay your wages but you don't realize it,

A very old and a trough saying The Dog in the Manger in this case it refers to people who have a good pension but would like to prevent others workers in the same Company from having the same, in others words they like to have there Snout In The Trough but prevent others from having the same benefits if at all possible, ;)
 
Back
Top