E-Scooter Ban Needed

I'd love to believe that. But as far as I know a very high percentage of e-scooters exceed the maximum speeds permitted by law. Which would mean they're not obeying the laws
I don't know any driver, including me, who doesn't break the speed limit in their car.
 
Are there serious injuries to children where failure by some drivers (even a majority) to indicate is the documented root cause?
Those injured children are the drivers/riders of the e-scooters. It is already against the law for those under 16 to use an e-scooter. Those over 16 who injure themselves are the authors of their own harm. Tough luck to them.
 
Hardly analogous though @Leper .
Dangerous drivers kill and injure other people. Dangerous e-scooter drivers almost always injure themselves. That's the difference. If someone wants to hurt themselves that's their own business as long as they don't hurt others in the process.
 
Dangerous e-scooter drivers almost always injure themselves. That's the difference. If someone wants to hurt themselves that's their own business as long as they don't hurt others in the process.
Until you or a family member are about to go for a scheduled surgery and find that the surgery team have to attend an emergency situation where an e-scooter rider has injured themselves.

The surgery team then tell the person due for the scheduled surgery that it has to be postponed due to the emergency admission.

"We'll try and fit you in withing the next 6 months for a reschedule"
 
Until you or a family member are about to go for a scheduled surgery and find that the surgery team have to attend an emergency situation where an e-scooter rider has injured themselves.

The surgery team then tell the person due for the scheduled surgery that it has to be postponed due to the emergency admission.

"We'll try and fit you in withing the next 6 months for a reschedule"
Most delays to elective procedures caused by A&E related needs are linked to alcohol. In other words drunk people ending up in A&E cause way more delays to elective surgery than the odd e-scooter related injury.

Is that a sufficient reason to ban alcohol?

e-scooter have a real utility value for many people. I've never used one and I don't like them. I don't want my children to use them. That doesn't mean they should be banned.
 
Until you or a family member are about to go for a scheduled surgery and find that the surgery team have to attend an emergency situation where an e-scooter rider has injured themselves.
What do you think the chances are of @Purple being admitted to Temple Street? We're also talking 18 cases over the past year, a fraction of the neurosurgery caseload that is still dominates by cases simply caused by falls. There hasn't been any significant change in overall case numbers in recent years since the post-Covid bounce as kids got out to mix and play again.

"We'll try and fit you in withing the next 6 months for a reschedule"
What neurological cases do you think get pushed out 6 months?
 
Affectations, thus not having opinions worth reading or listening to as they in turn are likely to be the parroted utterances of others; the echo-chamber of lower-infant schools.
That's a bit of a leap. What lead you to make that connection and therefore form that opinion?
 
Affectations, thus not having opinions worth reading or listening to as they in turn are likely to be the parroted utterances of others; the echo-chamber of lower-infant schools.
You've just dismissed Albert Einstein as not worth listening to!

Oh, while traditional grammar only allowed and, but, or, and, yet, it has been a long time since so, for, and nor, were included as valid coordinating conjunctions and so perfectly acceptable at the start of a sentence. So was the most recent addition circa 1970. Modern guides suggest the FANBOYS acronym to aid remembering them all.
 
Last edited:
There's a lot of pearl-clutching in the media about this topic. I understand why people don't like e-scooters, or more particularly the cut and paste teenaged boy in the grey tracksuit, a bubble jacket and ankle socks, with a blow-dried side parting, zooming around the place with his mouth open, no helmet or high-vis, up and down off pavements and through lights of all colours. I get that.

That's not a reason to ban e-scooters.
 
e-scooter have a real utility value for many people. I've never used one and I don't like them. I don't want my children to use them. That doesn't mean they should be banned
I absolutely agree they should not be banned. But the situation that a 12 year old child is bought one by a totally irresponsible parent has to change.

Over 18's with relevant safety gear is the minimum standard that should have been applied from day one. Many/most countries got this wrong.

Registration and insurance - that's debatable and may be more hassle than its worth and might eb worth leaving this aside until they see how the 18+ and safety gear regulations work

It was a consultant in CHI that said he's had to make last minute postponements on scheduled surgery to attend e-scooter injuries and said its heartbreaking telling a family a surgery will have to be rescheduled.
 
It was a consultant in CHI that said he's had to make last minute postponements on scheduled surgery to attend e-scooter injuries and said its heartbreaking telling a family a surgery will have to be rescheduled.
What did he say about alcohol related injuries (where a child is knocked down by a motorist under the influence of alcohol) that he had to attend? I am happy to postulate that such incidents are more common.

We don't seek to ban cars as they have a massive utility value. We criminalise the misuse of cars.
 
Oh, while traditional grammar only allowed and, but, or, and, yet, it has been a long time since so, for, and nor, were included as valid coordinating conjunctions and so perfectly acceptable at the start of a sentence. So was the most recent addition circa 1970. Modern guides suggest the FANBOYS acronym to aid remembering them all.
I'm deeply suspicious of people who hold onto outmoded and outdated grammatical norms. ;)
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Leo
Not all of them; some bystanders/pedestrians injured too.
83% of incidents are reported as single user, after that, the majority of multi-vehicle incidents involve other vehicles striking the e scooter. Incidents involving injury to other pedestrians seem surprisingly rare given how many scooter riders admit to breaking the law and riding on footpaths. There have been a few high profile cases though, this fatality for example.
 
83% of incidents are reported as single user, after that, the majority of multi-vehicle incidents involve other vehicles striking the e scooter. Incidents involving injury to other pedestrians seem surprisingly rare given how many scooter riders admit to breaking the law and riding on footpaths. There have been a few high profile cases though, this fatality for example.
I was nearly hit by a women on an e-scooter last year. I was walking out of Glasnevin Cemetery and she was travelling on the footpath at high speed. Luckily she missed me by inches and had quite a nasty crash as a consequence.
 
Last edited:
I'd be grateful if you'd let me know when and where his next talk is and I'll make sure to miss it.
I'd strongly advise not limiting yourself to only acquiring knowledge from people you can see in person. It would be a shame to limit yourself to such a minuscule fraction of human knowledge.

I'm also curious as to why you now feel you need to see and hear someone speak in person while discussing your choosing to disparage the writing style of others.
 
Back
Top