E-Scooter Ban Needed

So it's easy to set up e-scooters so that they can be disabled by the Gardai.
How do you propose to retro fit these devices onto the thousands of scooters already bombing about the place by the less civic minded?
How much will this cost and how many hundreds extra Garda will be required?
Easy to say its easy but I suspect it will be far harder that typing out a sentence.

(Deeply suspicious of any adult who begins a sentence with So...pet hate)
 
How do you propose to retro fit these devices onto the thousands of scooters already bombing about the place by the less civic minded?
No retro-fitting is required. Straight out of the box the firmware on these vehicles is accessible from a phone or other electronic device unless it is disabled. One simple amendment is to enforce the electronic registration of these devices centrally by the vendor. Pursue those unregistered in this fashion with all due vigour and save injuries and possibly lives. I can tweak my own e-scooter in various ways using apps on my phone. I use it to go to the shops locally saving on petrol and parking spaces. I disable it electronically when parked up in public and chain it to the shopping trolley rack in the street, with permission from the shop-keeper.
 
Straight out of the box the firmware on these vehicles is accessible from a phone or other electronic device unless it is disabled
Surely as easily manipulated by the same guys who turn a simple scooter into a 90mph death trap?
 
How do you propose to retro fit these devices onto the thousands of scooters already bombing about the place by the less civic minded?
Good question, answered by @mathepac.
How much will this cost and how many hundreds extra Garda will be required?
No extra Gardai required. Some equipment and training.

Easy to say its easy but I suspect it will be far harder that typing out a sentence.
Most things are harder to do that they are to say.
(Deeply suspicious of any adult who begins a sentence with So...pet hate)
How do you feel about people who start sentences with "deeply suspicious" rather than "I am deeply suspicious"? What is it that you suspect they person of? (before you comment it's okay to finish a sentence with "of" as this in English, not Latin).
 
I find it funny that the same people who want to ban scooters will complain about congestion when an extra 60,000 or more people are using cars and Public Transport each day.

The "ban the lot of them" brigade is like an alliance between Reverent Lovejoy's Wife and Victor Meldrew.
 
How are they to be chipped or whatever this entails?
Pursue those unregistered in this fashion with all due vigour and save injuries and possibly lives
Owners/users of unregistered e-scooters to be given the option of:

(a) Voluntary retrospective registration within a time-frame, say 90 days from enactment of the requirement

(b) Enforced retrospective registration if detected in use. If it is to legal specs, they get the e-scooter back after paying a fine, otherwise, if illegal, it gets destroyed and an additional, much higher fine is levied. For legal e-scooters where the fine remains unpaid after 30 days, the scooter is auctioned to defray costs.
 
When all else fails resort to insults. School yard behaviour.

Not engaging further with you.
I was more referring to the general media comments and the pearl clutching of the chattering classes but if your feeing are hurt...

We now live in a media environment where every problem is a crisis and every accident is a disaster.
 
No retro-fitting is required. Straight out of the box the firmware on these vehicles is accessible from a phone or other electronic device unless it is disabled.
What you're proposing isn't out of the box and would require significant changes. Pairing must be initiated on the device itself, anything else is a security and privacy nightmare. Scooters generally do not implement Bluetooth multipoint, and so are limited to a single device connection at a time. There is also a limit in the total number of devices that can be configured with access and the user has the ability to remove any they don't want.

Anything that would be accessible by Gardai to remotely deactivate a vehicle would be accessible to anyone else who wanted. Those intent on breaking the law would be well capable of disabling remote access. Even simply shielding the antenna would be enough.

Manufacturers are never going to support a central registration system on behalf of a state. They don't do it for cars, no way Ireland convinces hundreds of manufacturers to take on that cost just to satisfy a small market. Data protection would also be a nightmare.

There are EU proposals long in the works for mandating technology in cars that would allow for the safe termination of high speed chases, but there is strong debate around that centred on the fear that it's unlikely they could prevent bad actors from exploiting the system.
 
I disable it electronically when parked up in public and chain it to the shopping trolley rack in the street, with permission from the shop-keeper.
Make sure it is well locked, there are instructions and tools available online on how to factory reset or bypass the app lock on many common scooters.
 
(Deeply suspicious of any adult who begins a sentence with So...pet hate)
Ditto and I also find the Ahmurikanizm "Hey" as a pre-fix to spoken sentences very annoying; bewilderingly, it's now finding its way into written communications too.
 
Affectations, thus not having opinions worth reading or listening to as they in turn are likely to be the parroted utterances of others; the echo-chamber of lower-infant schools.
 
The conversation is getting out of hand. There is a small minority abusing the use of e-scooters. The vast majority of e-scooter users obey the laws and are careful drivers. @Purple is right. Why should people who behave respectfully on their e-scooters be banned because of those who are not respectful?

In Cork, nobody but Mrs Lep and me (and some L drivers) use our car indicators on roundabouts. Should all drivers be banned now because of the small minority of abusers?
 
In Cork, nobody but Mrs Lep and me (and some L drivers) use our car indicators on roundabouts.
Hardly analogous though @Leper . Are there serious injuries to children where failure by some drivers (even a majority) to indicate is the documented root cause?
 
Tell you what @mathepac go to the Fingerpost Roundabout (two lane) near Dunnes Stores/Rochestown Road in Cork which I do a couple of times a day. Hardly any motorist uses the car's indicators while driving there. And many of those who do, use them incorrectly. My guess is 92% of motorists don't use indicators and 100% of cyclists there (although few cyclists use that roundabout), Rochestown being an expensive suburb.
 
Back
Top