E-Scooter Ban Needed

Persia

Registered User
Messages
851
RTE news: Six children on life support at Temple St after e-scooter injuries.

Surgeons are at their wits end with the level of brain injuries amongst Children.

Once you aquire a brain injury, it will have a lasting impression on your life and will limit any future these kids would have.

They are calling for an outright ban.

 
Last edited:
What will it take for an outright ban...are we going to have to wait for more and more people to be killed or badly injured before it is warranted...
 
I was actually going to start a thread on e-scooters and e-bikes - both of which have become a menace on the streets and in parks. It's completely out of control at this stage with daily stories of tragedy, injury and criminality.




Will post more on this - but just one recent experience from last week: I was standing at a bus-stop and stepped out from the wall I was leaning against to see if the bus was coming up the hill. A micro-second after I stepped back into the shade, an e-bike with those big fat wheels came barreling at speed down the hill - on the footpath - barely missing me. (For those who know the area - it was the bus-stop opposite Carrickmines Luas Station on Glenamuck Rd North, where there's a narrow path but with cycle-lanes on both sides of the road.)

*Edit: I hadn't read the full story in the OP - I didn't realise that the six children on life support cases happened in the last two weeks! Truly shocking and it can only get worse. This is a public health emergency and should be treated as such.
 
Last edited:
Is emergency legislation immediately banning their (e-scooters, e-bikes, scramblers) use in public places a step too far? Ban their sale from anywhere except properly licensed dealers (like firearms) and sell only [EDIT] to buyers with proper id or licence. If the vehicle is involved in an injury incident or is operated by someone other than the purchaser, immediate seizure of the vehicle and substantial on-the-spot fine for the registered purchaser.
 
Last edited:
Is emergency legislation immediately banning their (e-scooters, e-bikes, scramblers) use in public places a step too far?
I would say no - it isn't a step too far - and it should probably be done. Barring that a complete ban on e-scooters - and licensing, insurance, registration etc required for e-bikes. Many of the so-called e-bikes I see out there are essentially motorbikes and scramblers in disguise.

We're gone way beyond the likes of more enforcement, public awareness campaigns and regulation at this stage. It hasn't worked - just look at the amount of e-bikes, scooters and scramblers seized so far this year. (And those six children currently on life support were injured after this report was published.)



Oh look it's another crackdown.

 
Last edited:
Ban their sale from anywhere except properly licensed dealers (like firearms) and sell only buyers with proper id or licence. I
Can see a quango being required and significant ongoing cost involved even before we waste Garda time policing this in an ongoing basis.

These registered machines will inevitably be stolen and be used by the very kids a ban would protect.

Complete ban required.
 
Of course it's not just an Irish problem and we could all post endless daily news stories about the menace of e-bikes and e-scooters around the world. But the truly depressing thing is, there are few solutions that don't involve massive Government/Garda/Local Authority intervention that would be hugely costly to regulate and enforce.


E-bikes are a menace. They are not allowed to operate in the city centre, they are required to get off and walk their e-bike," Councillor McNicholas said. "However, we have far too many incidents, not just in the city centre, but across the city. And it's something that we have to deal with."

"So the department itself is addressing these matters expeditiously."

Reform councillor Marcus Lapsa also asked what was being done to combat the illegal riding of off-road motorbikes, e-bikes and e-scooters in the city's parks, where children are playing.
 
Bicycles and pedal assist electric bikes; Cycle Lanes.
Electric bikes which don't need to be pedalled should be treated the same as motorbikes.
E-Scooters should be restricted to 20Kmph and owning or operating one which does not comply should be a criminal offence. If stopped they should be confiscated and destroyed.
Scramblers used in a public location should also be confiscated and destroyed. There should be no possibility of ever getting them back.

The Gardai should be allowed, without any restriction, to use any force they deem necessary to stop anyone using a scrambler, scooter, bike, e-bike e-scooter etc. In other words if someone operating any of those vehicles refuses to stop the Gardai should be able to use their car or anything else they have to hand, to knock them off the bike/scooter etc. If that results in the serious injury or death of the vehicle operator then tough luck, they should have stopped. No consideration should be given to the age of the person involved.

Give it a few weeks and most of the antisocial element of this problem would be sorted out.

As for kids using illegal e-scooters? Don't let your kids have illegal e-scooters. If they get killed or cause death or serious injury then prosecute the parents (and the young person if they survive).

Control for Darwin's Law and we're probably down to the same sort of statistical risk as other road users.

Don't ban useful things which are not innately dangerous because some people use them irresponsibly.
 
It's truly depressing and I've zero confidence that there'll be any meaningful action taken anytime soon. We've had the usual reactive political response - new laws, regulations, reviews, clampdowns/crack-downs/Garda-days-of-action etc. It's going to get a lot worse before it even begins to get better - or even less worse.




 
Last edited:
I don't have an issue with people killing themselves on illegal e-scooters. If people want to put themselves in harms way then that's their own business. I do have an issue with them injuring and killing other people and generally disrupting other people going about their business.
 
Last edited:
Looks increasingly like a complete ban could be imminent. I'm guessing the Gardai top brass informed the Government that there's no practical or logistical way of policing and enforcing the laws in relation to these cursed things. But the cynic in me thinks it'll be very difficult to bring in such a ban and there'll be pressure coming in the other direction from various quarters.

E-bikes will be next - quite likely requiring insurance, registration and licensing etc.



Edit: I've just heard the 5pm news. Apparently the so-called band on scramblers following the heartbreaking death of Grace isn't being enforced and they're still running amok all over the place. It'd make you weary.

 
Last edited:
Edit: I've just heard the 5pm news. Apparently the so-called band on scramblers following the heartbreaking death of Grace isn't being enforced and they're still running amok all over the place. It'd make you weary.
Until the Gardai have the power to use their car to knock people who refuse to stop, or are looking for a chase, off their e-scooters and Scramblers then this will continue. As they now can in London the police should be allowed to use their vehicle to stop these people. If the driver gets killed or seriously injured in the process then that's on them. They or their family should have zero legal recourse.
 
Last edited:
They should be banned 100%. Only last Saturday night /Sunday morning approx 12.40 am I was in my car waiting to pick up someone, I had the window down because of the heat when an e scooter passed going very fast along one of the main streets in town. There was no light, he ,I think, was dressed in all dark clothes. This after so many accidents involving these ' death traps' . These vehicles are some of the problem but the people using them are the biggest problem.. in my opinion.
 
They should be banned 100%. Only last Saturday night /Sunday morning approx 12.40 am I was in my car waiting to pick up someone, I had the window down because of the heat when an e scooter passed going very fast along one of the main streets in town. There was no light, he ,I think, was dressed in all dark clothes. This after so many accidents involving these ' death traps' . These vehicles are some of the problem but the people using them are the biggest problem.. in my opinion.
Why is that a reason to ban them? The driver should have lights. If they don't and they get killed I have no sympathy for them. Penalise the people who misuse them. We're not talking about banning electric bicycles because some people don't use them properly.
 
Why is that a reason to ban them? The driver should have lights. If they don't and they get killed I have no sympathy for them. Penalise the people who misuse them. We're not talking about banning electric bicycles because some people don't use them properly.
Agreed, creating yet another law does nothing to address those who flout the current legislation without consequence.
 
I know it's the people on these who are the problem...but I have yet to see one been driven properly....and the laws should have been clear from the start about the use of these ....age limits , insurance of some kind, lights helmets ....surely it has to be agreed that these basic requirements should have been implemented from the word go don't you think..
 
Last edited:
Back
Top