E-Scooter Ban Needed

I know it's the people on these who are the problem...but I have yet to see one been driven properly....and the laws should have been clear from the start about the use of these ....age limits , insurance of some kind, lights helmets ....surely it has to be agreed that these basic requirements should have been implemented from the word go don't you think..
I see plenty of responsible users, indeed I'm not sure the proportion of e-scooter riders who break the law on a regular basis is any greater than that of car or other vehicle drivers. The RSA Free Speed surveys show 78% of HGVs exceeding the speed limit on 100km/h roads as just one example.

The legislative position was clear from the outset, these were illegal to use on the roads until the 2023 Act made provision for their use. The Gardai, RSA, and others highlighted that they were illegal prior to that legislation coming into being, but there was little enforcement.
 
I think we need to make a distinction between vehicles which can be propelled only with the use of a motor (be it electric or ICE) and e-bikes which have pedal assist. Vehicles which don't require peddling should be treated like cars or motorbikes.
 
Like others I'm instinctively against banning things that can be useful for a lot of people when used correctly. But there's a such a high degree of wanton lawlessness around these things - partly due to the fact that the legislation currently in place was delayed for years creating a free-for-all grey area [as stated above by Joer]. That genie is long out of the bottle and it'll be nigh on impossible to put it back in.

One of the reasons it's in the headlines daily is down to the explosion in use of eBikes and eScooters in the last year or two. There were fewer problems earlier largely due to the lower numbers in use. But sales are now rocketing - with a high percentage of those coming with illegal speeds - and dangerous batteries which have been causing serious fires in the UK. Not to mention the criminality involved - see below.

The issue speaks to a much wider, fundamental problem with the way things are generally done in Ireland. Whether it's anti-social behavior in towns and cities, illegal dumping (and litter caused by the Re-Turn scheme), asylum/immigration issues and other current hot topics, we generally wait until things get completely out of hand before anything is done - remember the "head shops" that occupied Joe Duffy for months on end!

And then when the penny finally drops after years of denial, there tends to be an over-reaction or one that will be impossible to regulate and enforce.

I'm not hopeful of any real improvements in the short to medium term.


 
Last edited:
Even the Garda Commissioner is in favour of an all out ban on e scooters according to RTE news website today. He said ' it's not only people not wearing high visibility jackets or no lights but some very respectable people who do were these are using them badly ' he said.
Two garda were injured while targeting drug dealers using these recently...
 
Vehicles which don't require peddling should be treated like cars or motorbikes.
The law now states they are e-mopeds or e-motorcycles depending on the power. Full breakdown here, but the highlights are:

L1e-A E-Mopeds: Pedal or throttle-assisted with a motor up to 1,000W and max speed of 25 km/h. These require registration and motor tax. If weighing under 25kg, they do not require insurance or a driving licence. They are permitted in cycle and bus lanes. The assisted bit is important as the power assist is required to cut out once the rider stops pedalling, there are a load of conversion kits on the market that don't satisfy this requirement.

L1e-B E-Mopeds: Speeds up to 45 km/h and motor power between 1,000W and 4,000W. These must be registered, taxed, and insured. Riders must hold an AM driver's licence and wear a motorcycle helmet. They are NOT permitted to use cycle or bus lanes.

Anything with power in excess of 4,000W or has a design speed greater than 45 km/h, it is classified as a standard motorcycle.

The Gardai have portable dynamometers that can test the power output, and have been known to seize non-compliant bikes. If the bike belongs to a category requiring insurance, proof of insurance is supposed to be required to recover it, and that will not be tricky to impossible.
 
Last edited:
This new report from today paints an even starker picture of the injuries caused by e-scooters. (Heard a consultant from CHI on with Claire Byrne this morning and while he calmly laid out the extent of the damage caused to children, you could feel the frustration and anger coming through. He also stated that the ban on under 16s has had no effect whatsoever - and that the situation was getting worse.)



Since June, it is estimated that one to two children have been presenting at CHI emergency departments every day with e-scooter related injuries.

Injuries range from major trauma cases to fractures, head and neck injuries, facial injuries, concussions, and lacerations.

This has significantly increased the workload of medical teams both in the volume and complexity of cases, CHI said.

Some of the children are left with "permanent physical, sensory and cognitive disabilities", said Dr Irwin Gill, Consultant Paediatrician in Neurodisability at Children's Health Ireland.

"These are life-changing injuries that may require lifelong rehabilitation and ongoing support from their families and the State, and which in some cases can never be fully undone. Preventing these injuries must be a public health priority," he said.
 
Since June, it is estimated that one to two children have been presenting at CHI emergency departments every day with e-scooter related injuries.

Injuries range from major trauma cases to fractures, head and neck injuries, facial injuries, concussions, and lacerations.

This has significantly increased the workload of medical teams both in the volume and complexity of cases, CHI said.

Some of the children are left with "permanent physical, sensory and cognitive disabilities", said Dr Irwin Gill, Consultant Paediatrician in Neurodisability at Children's Health Ireland.

"These are life-changing injuries that may require lifelong rehabilitation and ongoing support from their families and the State, and which in some cases can never be fully undone. Preventing these injuries must be a public health priority," he said.
If the child is under 16 then the Gardai should be called and the parents should be arrested at the hospital.
 
the Gardai should be called and the parents should be arrested

In a perfect world - yes. But that ship has long sailed and the Gardai have made it crystal clear that they don't have the will, the resources or the training to carry out any meaningful or effective enforcement. (A huge chunk of Garda resources are taken up with Ireland's EU presidency at the moment as is a large cohort of the the Civil Service apparatus.)

On the second point - it's clear that the situation is far worse in so-called "working class" areas. Which means mostly single parent and "vulnerable" families, more out of control feral teenagers and higher criminality.

Just to add - eBikes are getting off lightly here. While they might be safer for the rider - they're more dangerous to pedestrians than standard push bikes. They're also used widely for criminal activity - lot of older teenagers already use then illegally. I can see more of them switching over if an escooter ban kicks in.

The Government needs this issue like a hole in the head right now.
 
Just to add - eBikes are getting off lightly here. While they might be safer for the rider - they're more dangerous to pedestrians than standard push bikes.
Let's not forget the legal ones pose only very marginally more danger, if at all. E-bikes tend to be ~10kg heavier than standard bikes, but riders tend to vary in weight by more. Important to note also is that similar to scooter incidents, it is the rider who comes off worst in most instances, and the hospitals aren't reporting any concerning injury trends where they have been talking for some time about the prevalence of e-scooters injuries.

In my youthful days I've hit 60km/h on a push bike,there's a lot more kinetic energy there than someone on a heavier e-bike where the assist cuts out at 25km/h.
 
Reading the Sunday papers today and listening to the radio over the last week, you get the strong feeling that there is no easy solution to reduce the injuries and the criminality. Apart that is from a complete ban, which would take an unprecedented level of enforcement in order to be a success.

But the Government will want to be seen to be doing something quickly, so we'll probably have some sort of compromise which'll please no-one and will have little affect whatsoever.

I wasn't aware that e-scooters for private use in public are banned in the UK (only rentals permitted.) Not sure if this applies in Northern Ireland - but if it does, it appears to make little difference as far as injures are concerned.



Dr Gail Davison, a paediatric emergency medicine consultant at the Royal Belfast Hospital, said the problem has become "a real epidemic".

She added that "it's only a matter of time before we have even more severe injuries that we're already having or increasing deaths".

"I've been treating children with major head injuries requiring surgical intervention, admission, and we're seeing major wounds as well from the e-bike where children are needing to go to theatre for exploration of those wounds and surgical intervention.

"And in the last few months also, we've seen an increasing number of bystander injuries.

"So not only are the children on the e-scooter being injured, now it's bystanders such as toddlers who are just walking on the pavement."
 
It seems from news broadcasts that some online sellers are responding by withdrawing products not in compliance with local laws from their stock and catalogue listings. To do this, they either (a) test for compliance or (b) take the published specs as gospel, so to speak. I wonder which it is and what their motivations might be. Is it (a) to prevent deaths and injuries or (b) to avoid legal actions in the event of death or injuries?

RTE News Website

An announcement to be welcomed, whatever the motivations.

"It comes as Amazon and AliExpress informed the Chair of the Oireachtas Transport Committee that they will not sell e-scooters that are not in compliance with Irish law."
 
RTE news: E-scooters set to be banned for under-18s, hi-vis vests and helmets to be mandatory


Kicking the can down the road. Pointless, never see Gardai anywhere. When I do spot one its almost a surprise...

This will do precisely nothing to move the dial on injuries and deaths relating to scooters.
 
A report on RTE radio this morning said that 160,000 adults use an e scooter every day as their main mode of transport. That's a lot of people discommoded because it's a hassle to enforce the current laws.
We have a problem with children getting hurt on e scooters. It's already illegal for children to use them.

I propose a licencing system which includes 3rd party insurance. A scannable 2D matrix could be laser etched into the frame of the scooter (simple cheap existing technology). The Gardai can scan the scooter and the rider has to carry ID to prove they are the licenced user.
If they are not insured/licenced the scooter is confiscated and destroyed.
If they don't have ID the scooter is confiscated and destroyed.
If they exceed 20Kmph the scooter is confiscated and destroyed.
If they use it on the footpath the scooter is confiscated and destroyed.
If it is used without lights at night or if the rider doesn't have a helmet the scooter is confiscated and destroyed.
If they fail to stop the Gardai can use any means necessary to stop them and the scooter is confiscated and destroyed. If the rider is injured or killed while being stopped they should have absolutely no recourse against the Gardai.

An alternative would be a built in RFID Tag with a 50 meter readable range (cheap existing technology) pre-installed into every scooter. The Gardai could be equipped with a reader so they just have to get close to the scooter to scan it. The same technology can be used to remotely shut off the power to the scooter. We could require all e scooters to have such a tag built in. If the Gardai scan a e scooter and don't see a tag then the scooter can be stopped and confiscated as above.
 
Back
Top