E-Scooter Ban Needed

I'm also curious as to why you now feel you need to see and hear someone speak in person while discussing your choosing to disparage the writing style of others.
I genuinely do not understand what you have said?
 
I genuinely do not understand what you have said?
Mathepac agreed that he too was suspicious of people who start sentences with so, saying he suspected them of 'not having opinions worth reading or listening to'.

I pointed out Einstein as just one example of someone who did so who had opinions most would certainly consider as worth reading or listening to.

Mathepac response to that was to ask when they'd next be speaking! My follow up was an attempt to make sense of that.
 
Major League Baseball, players, owners, & escooters

"MLB players love their scooters. Their teams wish they didn’t"

"Eleven months before the San Francisco Giants punished Harrison Bader for his usage of a scooter, the Atlanta Braves celebrated Michael Harris II’s affection for his own vehicle. When the Braves commissioned bobbleheads for Harris last September, the commemorative item featured the outfielder on the scooter he often rides around Truist Park.

That is really the only place, he was quick to clarify recently, he uses the thing.

“I don’t ride mine on the street,” Harris said. “I would park at the field, and then take it out of the car and then ride to the clubhouse.”

Long a source of anxiety for team executives, the subject of scooters has become an uneasy one for players in the wake of Bader’s crash. The Giants suspended payment of Bader’s salary after he was injured when his scooter collided with a fire truck in the early morning of July 26. Inactive since late May as he dealt with plantar fasciitis in his left foot, Bader may not return to the field in 2026, and the Giants could try to terminate the $10.25 million remaining on his contract for next season
."

From The New York Times, may be paywalled.

Riding an escooter may be added to contract-ending activities like wrestling, motor-cycle racing, etc
 
18 deaths from battery fires show hidden danger of UK's e-bike boom

"Eighteen people have died and nearly 700 have been injured in fires caused by e-bikes and e-scooters, new data shows.
Fatalities recorded by fire and rescue services across the UK from these fires include cases where people became trapped inside burning homes, died while trying to escape from a fire out of a high window, or from inhaling toxic smoke.
More than 2,000 fires were started by e-bikes, e-scooters or their batteries between 2019 and 2025, Freedom of Information requests made by BBC Verify show.
The number of incidents has risen year-on-year and nearly half the fires started in homes or garages, the data shows.
"

The linked report from BBC Verify indicates that e-bikes and e-scooters that are sold 2nd hand, or which have been modified using upgrade kits bought online, or are grey imports, can pose fire risks. Is this further justification for tighter regulation or for an outright ban as it seems they pose dangers even when not in use on the road?

"BBC Verify sent Freedom of Information requests to all 49 fire and rescue services in the UK, asking for data on fires where the source of ignition was recorded as an e-bike or e-scooter, including associated batteries. Forty-one provided comparable responses. Greater Manchester and West Sussex were unable to provide data on casualties, fatalities, and the number of fires that happened in dwellings."
 
The sale of e-scooters and e-bikes with no CE mark is of course illegal but it is common and a real problem. That said your date is for a 6 year period so that's 3 deaths a year is a population of 70 million people. Between 700 and 1000 people a year in the UK die by falling down stairs.

The UK fire service attended 1760 fires caused by Lithium-ion batteries in 2025 alone. I presume most of those are not e-scooters or e-bikes.

I have no problem if people want to kill themselves on an e-scooter as long as they don't harm other people so I'm in favour of enforcing existing regulation on battery safety and imprisoning those who sell, and possibly those who buy, non CE marked devices.
 
They are not my data; I've named and linked to the external sources.

"The number of fires caused by e-bike and e-scooter batteries has increased dramatically from 32 in 2019 to 605 in 2025, according to the data gathered by BBC Verify."

6,000 fires, 18 deaths and almost 700 injuries in the 6 years studied, all caused by e-bikes and e-scooters, all preventable simply by taking the products off the market. I can't establish the monetary cost but the cost in human terms seems excessive to me, given that they're preventable.
 
They are not my data; I've named and linked to the external sources.

"The number of fires caused by e-bike and e-scooter batteries has increased dramatically from 32 in 2019 to 605 in 2025, according to the data gathered by BBC Verify."

6,000 fires, 18 deaths and almost 700 injuries in the 6 years studied, all caused by e-bikes and e-scooters, all preventable simply by taking the products off the market. I can't establish the monetary cost but the cost in human terms seems excessive to me, given that they're preventable.

A deeper dive into the data is required. We don't know what proportion of the fires happened in scooters and bikes with illegal batteries.
We don't know if the increase in fires correlates with the increase in total units owned. There are over a million e-bikes in the UK and around the same number of e-scooters. Does the sales graph match the fires graph?

We also don't know the opportunity cost; if they removed those bikes and scooters and instead there were say a million more cars on the road how many more car related deaths would there be?
 
Sadly yet more serious injuries reported today. Nothing will change unfortunately.


A man aged in his late teens is in a critical condition following a road crash involving an e-scooter in Co Longford.

The incident happened on the Battery Road in Longford Town at around 10.40pm last night.

The man was brought to Regional Hospital Mullingar with serious injuries.

He has since been transferred to Beaumont Hospital in Dublin where he is said to be in a critical condition.

A teenager, a passenger believed to be in her teens, was also brought to hospital in Mullingar. Her injuries are believed to be non-life threatening.
 
I'm generally against banning things that are useful and cars are very useful.
I agree. I consider e-bikes and e-scooters very useful. I don't use either. I have a bicycle which I use most of the time to commute. I cross through Dublin city centre on that commute and see lots of people using e-biked and e-scooters, almost always in a safe manner. Ditto for cars.

I would make it a criminal offence to fail to stop for Gardai and I would allow them to use any means necessary to stop someone in or on any vehicle from truck to bicycle and everything in between. I would legislate so that the person who failed to stop has no legal recourse for any injuries caused in the process of stopping them. I other words if you fail to stop for the Gardai they can run you off the road, taser you, or shoot you if they see fit, and there's nothing you or your surviving kin can do about it.

I find the idea outrageous that we should punish law abiding people in a futile attempt to stop criminals breaking the law.
 
Last edited:
Another "e-bike" death

"A boy on an e-bike was killed in a hit-and-run on Friday night.

Gardaí are seeking witnesses following the fatal incident in Cloonlara, on the Clare-Limerick border, shortly after 11pm.
"

Tragic, his poor family, but no age given as yet. I don't know about "Cloonlara" though. The place I know is Clonlara on the L3050, roughly between Castleconnell and Ardnacrusha, near where the road crosses the Ardnacrusha power-station head-race.
 
Unfortunately there'll be little change to the current situation - and it's likely to get a whole lot worse given the explosion in sales of e-bikes, e-scooters and the various hybrid incarnations of both. I would also expect pedestrian injuries to increase given the near complete lack of any sanctions for wrongdoers. The new laws are meaningless and the Gardai have indicated that there's no chance of any effective enforcement

https://www.rte.ie/news/ireland/2026/0903/1590173-new-e-scooter-laws/

Speaking on RTÉ's Morning Ireland, Detective Garda Niall Hodgins said the new laws will be easy to enforce with those people who are compliant.

However, they probably will not be "any use whatsoever" against those determined to ignore the laws.

"Enforcement on these laws is likely to be weak, for a multiplicity of reasons," he said.

"Without registration of these vehicles, we really can't do anything with the user who speeds away or leaves a scene," he said.

"There's a clear intention here to police this issue, like they do motor vehicles. But without registration, we're really at nothing with regards to the user who speeds away, who rides on a footpath, who's non-compliant or is involved in an incident and leaves the scene, so this... creates a major enforcement gap," he said.

Asked what happens if gardaí try to stop someone not wearing a helmet or hi-vis and they do not stop, Det Gda Hodgins said gardaí are not trained to intervene when there is non-compliance.
 
Back
Top