E-Scooter Ban Needed

Sadly Gardai cannot even properly manage simple enforcement of existing road traffic laws.

You see it at every traffic light junction, vehicles blasting through red lights 5 heartbeats into a red.

They barely have any visibility as it is so I don't think they are fit for purpose as it is let alone adding to stuff they don't even do now.
 
Last edited:
Yes, it'll make little or no difference to the current situation.

There'll be plenty of high visibility "days of action" in the coming weeks, mainly done for social media purposes to give the impression of a "crackdown."

But there's little chance of any effective ongoing enforcement. Sigh.

(Just saw Geraldine Herbert, motoring editor at the Sunday Independent tweeting the following: "So you can drive a car at 17 but you are too young to use an e-scooter...")
 
Last edited:
So you can drive a car at 17 but you are too young to use an e-scooter.
Maybe she could try hitting a brick wall at 70kph (with no helmet) headfirst and after the crainiotomy and 6 months recovery, she could try it in a car with seatbelt and airbags, if she still remembers how to drive

Perhaps that would explain the difference
 
Last edited:
she could try hitting a brick wall at 70kph (with no helmet) headfirst

But e-scooters only do a maximum of 20kmph - apparently! So it's not a valid comparison.

The Government and the Gardai are on top of this; I heard Mr Harris himself saying very, very clearly, "let me be clear...."

Anyway, the Greens aren't happy at all. It's "collective punishment." (Did O'Gorman really say that high-viz vests were a form of punishment? Yes he did!)


“Requiring licensing, registration and high viz vests for e-scooters under 20kph that are currently legal and slower than bicycles amounts to collective punishment. It would make it prohibitively difficult to use them, especially people on low incomes who rely on them for work.
 
You really cannot help stupid people. Sadly O'Gorman is in my constituency. He blitzed the area recently.

A young canvassers rang the bell and asked breathlessly, if I'd like to speak to the great man himself

Mindful of this young mans age and having taken dogs abuse myself while canvassing in the mid 80s. I politely declined.

There are no words for the contempt I hold the greens in or their "leaders".
 
Banning things because we are unable to enforce reasonable and moderate existing laws is not a good thing in a democracy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Leo
Requiring high-viz is just pandering to bad drivers who don't pay sufficient attention to their surroundings and get a fright when they see other more vulnerable road users at the last minute. They make little sense when the vast majority in incidents are rider caused and don't involve other vehicles.

It's a slippy slope towards registration, licensing, and mandatory helmets and high-viz for cyclists which has only proven to discourage their use elsewhere. As someone who commutes exclusively by car, the more people taken out of cars and onto bicycles and scooters the better for me.
 
Do you really thing that's a valid counterargument? That's just hyperbole.
Perhaps head into the Childrens Hospital and tell that to a brain surgeon, who has just spent 4 hours performing a crainiotomy on a 12 year old with multiple skull fractures and brain bleeds and will experience learning and memory difficulties throughout their lives.

He or she will no doubt be delighted to engage in a debate about hyperbole ;)
 
Perhaps head into the Childrens Hospital and tell that to a brain surgeon, who has just spent 4 hours performing a crainiotomy on a 12 year old
Are you claiming that most or all of these cases involve kids travelling at 70km/h and colliding head-first into a brick wall? If not hyperbole we should really be looking at why so many survive an impact that is considered by medical science to carry a virtually absolute likelihood of death.
 
Perhaps head into the Childrens Hospital and tell that to a brain surgeon, who has just spent 4 hours performing a crainiotomy on a 12 year old with multiple skull fractures and brain bleeds and will experience learning and memory difficulties throughout their lives.

He or she will no doubt be delighted to engage in a debate about hyperbole ;)
That's just more hyperbole. Hard cases make bad laws. That's a truism.
 
Are you claiming that most or all of these cases involve kids travelling at 70km/h and colliding head-first into a brick wall?
I collided face first with a road off a bike when I was 17. It resulted in a fractured skull and a very badly broken clavicle (collarbone). I was doing about 10Kmph at the time. I think the you'd be having the conversation with a pathologist rather than the surgeon.
 
Listened to Simon Harris on Newstalk earlier. Predictably there was plenty of tough talking, strong words and the usual Govspeak:

"The direction of travel is clear," "I'm not ruling out X or Y", "Everything is on the table."

Talking to David McCullough on RTE he stated that "e-scooters would have to be registered."

"With who?
asked McCullough. "We've still to work that one out, said Harris!!
 
So it's easy to set up e-scooters so that they can be disabled by the Gardai.
It's also easy to legislate so that they are classified as motorised vehicles and so fall within the existing structures and laws which govern cars and motorbikes.
 
A currently serving Detective Garda speaks bluntly about the near impossibility of enforcement in today's Irish Times:


Privately, each member will be working out the risk/reward ratio in their heads and an increasing number will conclude that doing their duty simply isn’t worth the aggravation.

All must be regulated by a police force that is inhibited from doing so in a robust and consistent manner. Enforcement tools such as driver training, updated tactical instructions and thorough legal protection are not there.

These motorised urban “terrorists” can act with impunity because – to be clear – not one member of An Garda Síochána is trained to pursue them. Not one.

Whatever is decided, however, must acknowledge that thousands of these machines are already on our roads and footpaths. If they are declared illegal there will be yet further expectation on frontline gardaí to intervene. That drags us straight back to the balance between the personal risk of intervening and the duty to intervene. Every new prohibition, regulation or legislative provision that sends untrained gardaí into fast‑moving encounters with e-scooters and scramblers makes that balance all the more precarious.
 
This should have been properly regulated when they first came out. A bit like vapes.
That's a bit of a misconception in that they were 100% illegal to use in public until May 2024 when certain models of lower powered scooters were permitted subject to conditions laid out in the Road Traffic Acts.

They were in broad use publicly before that legislation and falling prices and little enforcement means that there was significant increase in the use of scooters that do not comply with current regs. Nothing will really change without enforcement.
 
Back
Top