Performance Update for Colm Fagan's ARF

and it seems to imply that Nvidia will still be used for training.
Others, such as Amazon, are developing their own specialist training and inference chips/hardware which may eventually compete with or at least reduce demand for Nvidia offerings.
 
I believe that some of the models used to forecast the likely future progress of share prices overstate the risk of poor long-term outcomes.
An example from my own experience illustrates the point.
Renishaw, a UK engineering company, is my longest-standing investment. I've held it continuously for the last 30 years, inside or outside my pension fund.
My first purchase, in 1996, was at £4.05 a share. At close of business on Friday last, 23 October 2026, the price was £51.60 a share. Allowing for dividends of just under 2% a year on average, the return (in sterling) over the last 30 years was 11% a year on average. Not bad.
The excellent long-term return has come at a cost in the form of high short-term volatility: the price fell almost 50% between end 2005 and end 2008; it fell by more than 60% between January 2021 and April 2025 and by 14% in the last three weeks.

What is the range of likely returns on my Renishaw investment over the next (say) ten years (if I’m around that long)? How likely is it that the price ten years from now could be less than the current price?
There are at least two ways of tackling the problem. One is to derive the mean and standard deviation of historic returns (actually, the mean of their logarithms) and apply statistical tests to estimate the likelihood of different outcomes. The graph on the right below shows price changes since January 2024. Given the share's volatility, the likely conclusion is that there is is a significant risk that the price ten years from now could be lower than today’s.

I prefer to work instead from the graph on the left. That shows earnings and dividends for the last 15 years. Renishaw operates in a cyclical industry, so earnings fluctuate from year to year. The Board of Directors has mediated the cyclicality by declaring dividends that equate to a stable percentage of earnings through the cycle (between 40% and 50%). The result is that dividends (the blue line) show a nice steady progression (except during COVID). In the 15 years 2011 to 2026, dividends grew by an average 5.8% a year. (There was also a special once-off dividend in 2026, not shown in the graph).

In trying to estimate Renishaw's share price ten years from now, I would probably assume that dividends grow by inflation plus 1% or 2% a year, with a small risk of a lower growth rate. I would then look at a range of possible dividend yields at the end to estimate the likely range of share prices at that time. The result will be a much narrower range of possible outcomes and a much lower risk of the price ten years from now being less than the current price than would be derived under the first approach.

View image
 
Last edited:
I posted a couple of weeks ago ( https://www.askaboutmoney.com/threa...r-colm-fagans-arf.234034/page-34#post-2017359) that I was getting nervous about the stock market. I was right to be nervous: during October, Meta’s share price fell by 15%, Alphabet’s fell by 19%, Intel’s fell by a whopping 44%. Naturally, therefore, I wasn’t looking forward to discovering how my pension fund performed in the month.

I needn’t have worried. Instead of falling, the fund’s value (ignoring the pension withdrawal) increased by 2.5% in the month.

There were a number of reasons for the increase.

Firstly, none of the aforementioned - Meta, Alphabet or Intel - are in the portfolio; however, I didn’t fully escape the AI bloodbath: the price of Nvidia, my second largest holding, fell by 11.4%. The fall in euro terms, at 9.1%, was less, because the dollar strengthened against the euro. I still believe that Nvidia will deliver in the long-term, so I’m sticking with my current holding (16% of total fund).

A more important contributor to the good result was the decision to increase my exposure to Standard Life and L&G. Standard Life’s price increased by 4.4%; sterling’s strength against the euro added another 2.3% to the return. The icing on the cake was that the extra shares bought during the month delivered an even better return because they were bought on the dip: their price increased by 6.5%. It was a similar story for L&G. At end October, combined holdings in these two companies accounted for 32.2% of the fund, up from 26.9% at end September.

My old friend Goodwin also delivered. As noted in same post of 17 October, I used the proceeds from the AerCap sale to increase my holding in Goodwin, believing that the downside was limited. My confidence was rewarded – in the short-term, at least. Goodwin’s share price increased by 10% in the month; including the currency effect, the gain was 12.8%. Goodwin now accounts for over 9% of the fund.

All in all, not a bad result. I doubt if I’ll ever be as lucky again.
 
Do any of your investments have heavy exposure to AI stocks? It seems like most investment funds are being carried by AI valuations and this may indicate a bubble in the making.
@Colm Fagan Looks like there's a market correction related to AI stocks now. How has your ARF been affected?

 
How has your ARF been affected?
Checking one's pension on a daily basis isn't really a good way to manage things. In fact, I'm not even sure that @Colm Fagan's updates on a monthly or multiple monthly basis are a good idea as it may give others bad ideas/habits on managing long term investments. It's arguably comparable to how a day trader deals with things. But obviously it's @Colm Fagan's prerogative to post what he wants and how often he wants about his own pension. :)
 
Thats true. Just curious about he and others feel about it. I wouldn't expect anyone to change or panic about their investments.
 
I check the value of my portfolio regularly, but I don't let that influence buying or selling decisions
I think it gets me used to seeing fluctuations up and down in the various components and so learning that volatility is normal and not to be worried about on a day to day basis

It instructive to see if the changes are based on new information - eg news release - or just market noise
 
I check mine probably more often than most but to be honest i don’t think that’s a bad thing. It has really helped me to get used to the volatility of the markets and the wild swings that can happen over the years. Just checked it there and it is down around 2%. I’m not overly bothered and I know not to take any action based on that. I wouldn’t be obsessing about it though.

g
 
Pride cometh before the fall. Last week, I boasted that my pension fund added 2.5% in October despite the market having a hissy fit (https://www.askaboutmoney.com/threa...r-colm-fagans-arf.234034/page-35#post-2019407 ). It’s a very different story today, at the end of the first week of November. The bluenami that followed Tuesday’s US elections caused my pension fund to turn red. It fell 1.8% in just a week.

Nvidia, which accounted for 16% of the fund at end October, fell 8.5%. That on its own caused quite a dent in the fund’s performance. This weekend’s news that Jensen Huang, Nvidia’s boss, is being investigated for a possible romantic relationship with a Chinese spy won’t help sentiment towards the share. The forthcoming announcement on 17 November of results for the quarter to end October should give some clarity on the financial impact of recent events, if not on the boss’s romantic entanglements.

Nvidia wasn’t my fund’s biggest faller in percentage terms. That dubious honour belongs to Renishaw, whose price fell more than 11% in the week. The fall in Renishaw’s share price looks like the market trying to prove I was right when I wrote recently that volatility is the admission price for the company's excellent long-term investment return. It’s a price I’m happy to pay. Renishaw’s recent weakness doesn’t worry me.

Redemption, albeit partial, came from an unexpected source. Despite the bomb scares, Ryanair’s share price increased 12.2% in the week, moving it up to being my third-largest holding (after Standard Life and Nvidia). Ryanair’s ascent was helped by my decision to reduce my holdings in Standard Life, L&G and Goodwin in order to make way for a new addition to the portfolio, which brings the number of holdings from eleven to twelve. More about the new addition to my harem (we can all dream) at a later date.
1794074834954.webp
 
Last edited:
It was only when I tried to post the link to my recent post about the volatility of Renishaw's share price (see third paragraph above) that I realised that I hadn't posted it on AAM. Here it is, with my apologies for the omission:
I believe that some of the models used to forecast the likely future progress of share prices overstate the risk of poor long-term outcomes.
An example from my own experience illustrates the point.
Renishaw, a UK engineering company, is my longest-standing investment. I've held it continuously for the last 30 years, inside or outside my pension fund.
My first purchase, in 1996, was at £4.05 a share. At close of business on Friday last, 23 October 2026, the price was £51.60 a share. Allowing for dividends of just under 2% a year on average, the return (in sterling) for the last 30 years averaged 11% a year. Not bad.

The excellent long-term return has come at a cost in the form of high short-term volatility: the price fell by almost 50% between end 2005 and end 2008; it fell more than 60% between January 2021 and April 2025 and by 14% in the three weeks to Friday last.

What is the range of likely returns on my Renishaw investment over the next (say) ten years (if I’m around that long)? How likely is it that the price ten years from now could be less than the current price?

There are at least two ways of tackling the problem. One is to derive the mean and standard deviation of historic returns (actually, the mean of their logarithms) and apply statistical tests to estimate the likelihood of different outcomes. The graph on the right below shows price changes since January 2024. Given the share's volatility, the likely conclusion is that there is is a significant risk that the share price ten years from now could be lower than today’s.

I prefer to work instead from the graph on the left. That shows earnings and dividends for the last 15 years. Renishaw operates in a cyclical industry, so earnings fluctuate from year to year. The Board of Directors has mediated the cyclicality by declaring dividends that equate to a stable percentage of earnings through the cycle (between 40% and 50%). The result is that dividends (the blue line) show steady progress (except during COVID). In the 15 years 2011 to 2026, dividends grew by an average 5.8% a year. (There was also a special once-off dividend in 2026, not shown on the graph).

In trying to estimate Renishaw's share price ten years from now, I would probably assume that dividends grow by inflation plus 1% or 2% a year, with a small risk of a lower growth rate. I would then look at a range of possible dividend yields at the end to estimate the likely range of share prices at that time. The result will be a much narrower range of possible outcomes and a much lower risk of the price ten years from now being less than the current price than would be derived under the first approach.

1794073936476.webp
 
My friend and fellow retired actuary Brian Woods and I occasionally mount campaigns to warn small investors of the dangers of dodgy financial products. (An example is a campaign we launched against a product devised by BNP Paribas. Some AAM readers will be familiar with that campaign. As far as we know, no regulator ever censured BNP Paribas for that product).

One of our mantras is " If it looks too good to be true, it probably is”. I never thought I'd have to reproach myself for falling for a “too good to be true” investment. I am now doing just that.

A few weeks ago, I did a back-of-a-fag-packet analysis of NVIDIA and concluded that it was a steal at its closing price of $220.65 a share on 31 August (https://www.askaboutmoney.com/threa...r-colm-fagans-arf.234034/page-30#post-2010131). Last evening (12 November), it closed at $166.19 a share, down 25% since 31 August.

I should have listened to my inner sceptic. A little digging would have alerted me to the risk. That was brought home to me on Wednesday of this week when I met two friends for a pub lunch. One of them told me that, months ago, he had read a short seller’s report warning of what might happen. I wanted to grab him warmly by the throat but limited myself to asking why he didn’t tell me of the report after reading my piece on LinkedIn. “You never asked me”, he said. He’s right. I didn’t. Next time, “friend”, let me know before I ask.

PS: My reference to a harem in last week's post about NVIDIA was intended as a joke! (https://www.askaboutmoney.com/threa...r-colm-fagans-arf.234034/page-35#post-2020170)
 
Thanks for the update Colm

Some observations from me.

As I am sure you know Your portfolio is more likely to suffer such setbacks because it’s so concentrated, but probably the same goes for the upside.

Personally i am too much of a sceptic to buy a share like Nvidia. Of course I wish I bought it years ago but I wouldn’t chase what I consider a stock market darling, most exciting industry with a charismatic CEO and some potentially circular financing deals.

however the ceo needed to step back at some point and the most recent events have accelerated this. At least the transition to a new leader and more traditional governance structure has begun.

On the positive side at least the ride has been exciting.
 
Back
Top