It was only when I tried to post the link to my recent post about the volatility of Renishaw's share price (see third paragraph above) that I realised that I hadn't posted it on AAM. Here it is, with my apologies for the omission:
I believe that some of the models used to forecast the likely future progress of share prices overstate the risk of poor long-term outcomes.
An example from my own experience illustrates the point.
Renishaw, a UK engineering company, is my longest-standing investment. I've held it continuously for the last 30 years, inside or outside my pension fund.
My first purchase, in 1996, was at £4.05 a share. At close of business on Friday last, 23 October 2026, the price was £51.60 a share. Allowing for dividends of just under 2% a year on average, the return (in sterling) for the last 30 years averaged 11% a year. Not bad.
The excellent long-term return has come at a cost in the form of high short-term volatility: the price fell by almost 50% between end 2005 and end 2008; it fell more than 60% between January 2021 and April 2025 and by 14% in the three weeks to Friday last.
What is the range of likely returns on my Renishaw investment over the next (say) ten years (if I’m around that long)? How likely is it that the price ten years from now could be less than the current price?
There are at least two ways of tackling the problem. One is to derive the mean and standard deviation of historic returns (actually, the mean of their logarithms) and apply statistical tests to estimate the likelihood of different outcomes. The graph on the right below shows price changes since January 2024. Given the share's volatility, the likely conclusion is that there is is a significant risk that the share price ten years from now could be lower than today’s.
I prefer to work instead from the graph on the left. That shows earnings and dividends for the last 15 years. Renishaw operates in a cyclical industry, so earnings fluctuate from year to year. The Board of Directors has mediated the cyclicality by declaring dividends that equate to a stable percentage of earnings through the cycle (between 40% and 50%). The result is that dividends (the blue line) show steady progress (except during COVID). In the 15 years 2011 to 2026, dividends grew by an average 5.8% a year. (There was also a special once-off dividend in 2026, not shown on the graph).
In trying to estimate Renishaw's share price ten years from now, I would probably assume that dividends grow by inflation plus 1% or 2% a year, with a small risk of a lower growth rate. I would then look at a range of possible dividend yields at the end to estimate the likely range of share prices at that time. The result will be a much narrower range of possible outcomes and a much lower risk of the price ten years from now being less than the current price than would be derived under the first approach.