Landlords continue to sell up - Owen Reilly Q3 2025 Report

Status
Not open for further replies.
That was then, this is now.

All businesses have to adapt & change as the market changes.
In a open market you are correct, however the rental market is far from open.

If those who make the rules can control the market then its not open. Remember supernormal profits encourage new entrants this is a fundamental basic of economics.
 
It would take a mass protest by landlords to make the politicians wake up and realise if they keep restricting landlord rights, they might find there are no landlords left.

What would happen if - as a protest - all 250k landlords across the country issued a NoT on a specific date for either family use or to sell? The RTB couldn’t cope with the paperwork, Threshold would be overwhelmed, tenants would be up in arms, local councils and homeless services would be inundated. Chaos.

Landlords provide a vital service in society but successive governments keep kicking the dog - maybe the dog needs to bite back. They should at least have a strong organisation to represent their interests, it seems they currently have no voice and are powerless to stop the onslaught whereas tenants have many organisations plus dozens of politicians who advocate for additional tenant rights which are always granted. I’ve been reading about constant restrictions on landlords rights for years now.

It results in a very bad situation for tenants because the pool of rentals continues to shrink as landlords leave the market - it seems they give up because all the changes make letting too risky and too difficult. Landlords need to start acting as a group imo, surely 250k together can have some influence on bad policy.

Edit: also think they should call themselves something other than landlords which has an awful historical stigma.
 
Last edited:
fight back needed to be much earlier like in 81

Rent control ‘unconstitutional’ (1981-82)​

Following a legal challenge by a number of landlords, the Supreme Court ruled in 1981 that rent control was unconstitutional.

Subsequent legislation drafted to protect tenants was also found by the Supreme Court a year later to violate the Constitution and was described as an “unjust attack on the property rights of landlords”.
 
What would happen if - as a protest - all 250k landlords across the country issued a NoT on a specific date for either family use or to sell?
It's a good idea to at least bring attention to all the issues with proposals (they are so bad for all parties). The idea of a mass protest like this was raised at the last meeting of IPOA members in Cork (held 2nd October). Margaret McCormick (IPOA Information Officer) said that they as an organisation are legally unable to make such a suggestion as it would be viewed as colluding by the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission (CCPC). Apparently they got in trouble with them a few years ago and the fear is the IPOA could be shut down.

I'm not sure how else accommodation providers could organise themselves?

Govt would bring in emergency legisation to prevent it.
I agree, but I guess the point is that the issue becomes front and center. I spoke with a FG TD a few weeks ago, and he openly said he didn't realise all the consequences.


You probably know more than me about how these things work but that sounds like an attack on a citizens / individuals property rights.
Even the proposals themselves are an infringement on property rights. IPOA said they would look to challenge them, but the there is still no legislation to challenge even though the new rules will be place in little over 3 months.
 
Smaller Landlords can sell if required for family member.If wife and husband seperate on temporary basis(no formal separation/divorce) and need the rental to live in,would this satisfy the requirements of new legislation?
If someone in rental accommodation buys a house with tennant in situ at knockdown price and subsequently needs a place to live can they serve notice to end tenancy within post March requirements?
 
I think that issuing NoTs to all tenants and frightening the life out of them in the process (tenants are pawns in this mess also) would be completely counter productive and it would only destroy any existing sympathy for landlords. It would not help our case.

I'm with @DannyBoyD - it is get out or adapt in some way
 
If someone in rental accommodation buys a house with tennant in situ at knockdown price and subsequently needs a place to live can they serve notice to end tenancy within post March requirements?
Yes, indeed they can.

And you can bet that speculators of various types will buy such properties at knock down prices and either bribe or force the tenants to leave. Then the property will be put back on the market at a much higher sum. Another unintended consequence.
 
I don't think it helps that most renters would probably like to own a place of their own. Landlords provide a service for those who need rented accommodation for short, medium term.
People would rent long-term if the rent wasn't as costly as a mortgage. The % of home-ownership has fallen dramatically to around 65%. I'd prefer to see it back up to 85%+.

We have a sophisticated mortgage lending system now with banks issuing €15bn a year in mortgages. There really is no need for so many landlords.
 
And you can bet that speculators of various types will buy such properties at knock down prices and either bribe or force the tenants to leave. Then the property will be put back on the market at a much higher sum. Another unintended consequence.
I was wondering about this myself. Also, say if selling a property with a tenant in situ meant a price reduction from market value of (for example) €100k, an owner might end up offering €50k to the tenant to leave ‘voluntarily’, in order to get vacant possession in order to sell at market value. Could be quite lucrative for some tenants!
 
selling a property with a tenant in situ meant a price reduction from market value of (for example) €100k, an owner might end up offering €50k to the tenant to leave
There's absolutely zero chance I'd go down the route of handing some randomer 50 % of the realisable value of my property just to get them out. ( understand its an example but 50%? I wouldn't give a tenner for it) :)

I'll wait them out and sell with vacant possession.
 
I'll wait them out and sell with vacant possession.
If you are a large landlord, you may be waiting decades and the tenant's children become tenants when they turn 18. In the meantime, you're responsible for all repairs, maintenance and upgrades to an aging property. Selling to some randomer at 50% discount would be an attractive deal in the circumstances.

Could be quite lucrative for some tenants!

In the Netherlands where you have permanent tenancies also, the system is that you pay the tenants to leave. The amounts involved can be significant, 20k or more. So if you are a landlord renting at 2k a month, that's about 12k per year after tax and costs, you'd lose about 2 year's rent to get the tenant out.

I'm sure they are aware of that here. It would be a vote getter as there are far more tenants than landlords.

At the end of the day I don't see a problem with landlords compensating tenants for having to move. The tenant often has to pay removal costs, take time out for viewings etc. It is costly and disruptive, but 20k plus is ridiculous. Nonetheless that is the Dutch system and it will come in here.
 
I don't think it helps that most renters would probably like to own a place of their own. Landlords provide a service for those who need rented accommodation for short, medium term.
People would rent long-term if the rent wasn't as costly as a mortgage. The % of home-ownership has fallen dramatically to around 65%. I'd prefer to see it back up to 85%+.

We have a sophisticated mortgage lending system now with banks issuing €15bn a year in mortgages. There really is no need for so many landlords.
I rent out and apartment and the same tenant has been in it for a good few years now, I'd be only delighted if he offered to buy it from me (although it wouldnt exactly suit me) as i feel the tentant is wasting their money on rent rather than having something at the end of it. The rent is on the low side but with a 10% deposit or so the mortgage repayments would probably be a bit lower that rent paid. The point is i don't thibk landlords should be providing long term housing needs for tentants who could most likely buy.

Conversely ii have another property that is essentially a mini care facility, on this one i feel i am offering a service, but maybe the HSE could provide instead.

I rented properties in london for a number of years and it suited my needs at the time as i wasnt sure what the long term plan was, again i think there should be properties available torent for this, same for student accommodation, it's a genuine service.
 
There really is no need for so many landlords.
Right now there's.
If there wasn't, prices would fall and LL would not be inundated by requests when they put an ad up
I'd prefer to see it back up to 85%+.
When was that? Home ownership never reached that level. It peaked at around 80 in 1991. Since then, society has changed a lot and while young people would like to buy at some point, I don't think it's their priority as young as before for multiple reasons. One is the price, availability, affordability. But life and expectations are also often very different than in the 1990s.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top