Landlords continue to sell up - Owen Reilly Q3 2025 Report

Status
Not open for further replies.
Regarding the increase in landlord numbers reported by the RTB, I've wondered if the changes under the Residential Tenancies (Amendment) Act 2021 have affected things. This commenced in April 2022 and since then any joint landlords, e.g. husband and wife, must have both their names appear on the registration. You need to have done this correctly to claim tax relief.
 
This reflects a broader pattern of disregard toward accommodation providers. While sitting tenants benefit from legally enforced real-term rent reductions (with nominal rent increases capped at the lower of inflation or 2%) landlords must continue to absorb all operating costs at full market rates.
I think this is the key point and the real danger with the permanent rent controls we will have post March (I've no faith in landlords getting a market value increase after 6 years) - the rent you get is actually decreasing in real terms due to inflation while your operating costs increase at a rate above 2%. You'll end up with a liability on your hands and you won't be able to sell it either.
 
You will always be able to sell,
I wonder - how much would the following combination go for:

1. Permanent tenants, a large landlord is selling
2. These tenants are low income, so you won't be able to increase the rent significantly ever. Either the government will stop you or the tenants will complain to a supportive RTB. They won't ever leave either.
3. Older largish house starting to need work
4. In a small town, a village or a rural area.

You'll only be able to sell to another landlord and I can't imagine too many (it'll be confined to cash buyers only) being in the market. I'd say a house like that is pretty much unsaleable.

Even if it is an apartment in a city, if you're a large landlord and the tenants are low income, I can't imagine there being too many takers either. You will eventually find someone to take it off your hands, but at a very significant discount.
 
Nonetheless, you will find a buyer
I wonder, because eventually if the rent continues to decrease in real terms and costs continue to rise in real terms, even with a low purchase price, the purchaser will eventually end up under water as well.

It's greater fool theory - you'd have to find a fool to buy it. It'll be cash buyers only, so well off and unlikely to be a fool.

I think there is a risk that an older, large property in rural/small town location with a forever tenant just won't be unsaleable. Also, tenants children become tenants themselves at 18.
 
I think the key issue is being able to evict for sale.

No matter how bad things get, landlords can still leave. If you find you don't like it, you can sell the property and leave the profession. This is a key safety value to set a floor on how bad things can get.

Allowing rent to return to market rent is nice, but it requires the tenant to voluntarily leave. It is exactly the tenants who are below market rent who are unlikely to leave voluntarily (and who would blame them).

This is an essentially useless benefit in exchange for the loss of right to exit the market.

Currently, you can evict for sale for all existing tenancies. Its slow but it can be done.

The government are looking to block the final exit for landlords with new 2026 type leases.
  • large landlords will not be able to leave
  • small landlords will only be able to leave once every 6 years (maybe)
This is trapping the asset value in the rental market. You have to sell to a large or small landlord.

Small landlords will (eventually) be able to sell, so they will get market price less the costs, delays, and hassle of actually evicting the tenant. They can sell to an owner occupier and get vacant possession price for the sale.

Large landlords can never get their property back unless the tenant leaves voluntarily. The property value will be irrelevant, the rental stream is the only value that the new owner actually gets.

It is clear that closing the door even for small landlords is the next step after 2026. All houses that have tenants in them at that point will be near permanently locked in the rental market.

The value of those properties will be locked to the rental income and thus grow at most 2% per year, or inflation, whichever is lower.
 
Last edited:
This is an essentially useless benefit in exchange for the loss of right to exit the market.
100% correct

It is clear that closing the door even for small landlords it the next step after 2026. All houses that have tenants in them at that point will be near permanently locked in the rental market.
100% correct also.

Based on what has happened over the past 9 years, the trajectory is clear - more and more restrictions until you can't exit at all.
 
Based on what has happened over the past 9 years, the trajectory is clear - more and more restrictions until you can't exit at all.

I pity any future executors if the family home was rented. With the recent changes to the Fair Deal rule exempting rental income, there are probably many people in nursing homes who rented out their home to get some income which is not subject to Fair Deal's 80% contribution.

I guess they will just sell with tenants in situ and get whatever residual price they can. The beneficiaries will complain, but what can they do.
 
If a landlord has more than 3 tenancies in existence prior to March 1st - does he or she only become a large landlord upon signing more than 3 new leases  after March 1st? I currently have 5 tenancies and certainly want to get back to 3 or fewer under the new system. But I don't really want to have to evict tenants to reach this status, as I expect they'll eventually move out anyway at which point I'll then sell the surplus properties. Is this strategy feasible?
 
If a landlord has more than 3 tenancies in existence prior to March 1st - does he or she only become a large landlord upon signing more than 3 new leases  after March 1st?
There are few details on how this will actually work, but I would imagine that if you have 5 tenancies prior to March and these continue after March, then you are a large landlord and the next tenancy you grant will be a permanent one.
 
Thank you for the response. My dilemma now is do I immediately give notice to 2 of the tenancies and thus obtain vacant possession, in case I can no longer do so after March 1. Not a course of action I want to take, but I'll have no option if there is no route obtain vacant possession to sell (to an owner occupier) after March 1.
 
It seems that a pre-March tenancy will continue under the old rules, so for as long your current tenancies continue, you can give evict as you can now for those pre-March tenancies. However, it seems that if one of your tenancies ends after March and you grant a new tenancy afterwards, then you will be a large landlord for that new tenancy and you'll won't be able to get vacant possession to sell. So if you don't want to evict, you could just sell as the tenants leave of their own accord and leave yourself with three properties.

There is no sign of the legislation, so this is educated guesswork on my part and I may be wrong in this.
 
Thanks Greenbook, that is also my interpretation, but I can't afford to get this wrong, particularly given the rents are well below market and exiting the market looks increasingly attractive!
 
Thanks Greenbook, that is also my interpretation, but I can't afford to get this wrong, particularly given the rents are well below market and exiting the market looks increasingly attractive!
That is my interpretation as well. I had the same dilemma due to owning 4 properties, however thankfully the tenants in one of them voluntarily moved out recently and we are currently in the process of selling that apartment rather then reletting, mostly to avoid becoming a ‘large landlord’. Like you, we will probably sell the remaining properties if and when the remaining tenants decide to leave.
 
Then why take the risk? As your rents are below market rate, they can never increase beyond 2% for as long as the current tenancies continue. If your tenants leave of their own accord and you grant new tenancies, you can increase to market rent, but the tenants will be permanent. You won't be able to increase that rent for another six years and I think that political interference or the RTB will scupper further rent increases beyond 2%.

There are other threads on here about how a being a landlord is now a risky and loss making proposition. If your gut is to get out, then I think you should be doing that. Keep in mind also, it may not always be as easy to sell a property for a good price as it is now.
 
Definitely a valid approach. In reality it is probably very unlikely the tenants will leave of their own accord while the rent is below market, unless they have to relocate for any reason. But if I evict then I'd be limited to selling to an owner occupier, which narrows the market somewhat.
 
@Karmann You are in a bind alright, but what are you going to do? Do you plan to rent forever to your tenants at rents which are decreasing in real terms while your costs increase in real terms? Eventually you'll be paying them to live in your properties.

There is a good market for owner occupiers now, if you are limited to them. That will not always be the case.

More government interference mayfurther limit your sale options in the future. You are exactly the type of landlord they want to keep in the market as you'll be providing cheap and permanent housing at a cost to yourself and not to the government!
 
Definitely a valid approach. In reality it is probably very unlikely the tenants will leave of their own accord while the rent is below market, unless they have to relocate for any reason. But if I evict then I'd be limited to selling to an owner occupier, which narrows the market somewhat.

I think the owner occupier market is likely to get you most of the value of the property. They get full use of it when they buy it. If they live there for 2 years, they even get the RPZ caps removed.

Depending on how below market rates the rent is, it might even be worth leaving it vacant for 2 years. Resetting the rent gets you more rent and makes it more likely that the tenant will leave on their own.

Unmarried landlords with 4 properties might be well advised to advised to cycle them. You could live in 1 while renting out the other 3. This would clear the RPZ rent on the one you are living in after 2 years.

See table below, the progress in the right to evict for sale has been only going one way.

Tenacy StartedTypeNo Fault Evict For SaleNo Fault Evict Without Reason
before 10 June 2022YESEnd of 6 year cycle
10 June 2022 - 28 Feb 2026*YESNO
starting 1 March 2026Small LandlordEnd of 6 year cycleNO
starting 1 March 2026Large LandlordNONO
 
If they live there for 2 years, they even get the RPZ caps removed.
There has been no clarification if the exemption from RPZ rules for a property that has not been rented for two years before the new tenancy start date will exist after 1March26 (even for existing properties). Reps for the Dept of Housing were asked specifically, and could not confirm one way or the other.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top