I think the key issue is being able to evict for sale.
No matter how bad things get, landlords can still leave. If you find you don't like it, you can sell the property and leave the profession. This is a key safety value to set a floor on how bad things can get.
Allowing rent to return to market rent is nice, but it requires the tenant to voluntarily leave. It is exactly the tenants who are below market rent who are unlikely to leave voluntarily (and who would blame them).
This is an essentially useless benefit in exchange for the loss of right to exit the market.
Currently, you can evict for sale for all existing tenancies. Its slow but it can be done.
The government are looking to block the final exit for landlords with new 2026 type leases.
- large landlords will not be able to leave
- small landlords will only be able to leave once every 6 years (maybe)
This is trapping the asset value in the rental market. You have to sell to a large or small landlord.
Small landlords will (eventually) be able to sell, so they will get market price less the costs, delays, and hassle of actually evicting the tenant. They can sell to an owner occupier and get vacant possession price for the sale.
Large landlords can never get their property back unless the tenant leaves voluntarily. The property value will be irrelevant, the rental stream is the only value that the new owner actually gets.
It is clear that closing the door even for small landlords is the next step after 2026. All houses that have tenants in them at that point will be near permanently locked in the rental market.
The value of those properties will be locked to the rental income and thus grow at most 2% per year, or inflation, whichever is lower.