Interestingly, this is already how the process works. A tenant must ask the landlord for permission to assign their lease. If the landlord agrees, everything proceeds smoothly. However, if the landlord refuses, the tenant can still go ahead with the assignment because the landlord cannot unreasonably withhold consent. This limits the landlord’s control over who the next tenant will be.
This situation often arises when a tenant, having stayed only part of a fixed-term lease (for example, 5 months of a 12-month lease), wants their deposit back. As a landlord, it is usually better to return the deposit and start fresh rather than letting the departing tenant decide who takes over the tenancy especially given the current rental market conditions and regulations.