Landlords continue to sell up - Owen Reilly Q3 2025 Report

Status
Not open for further replies.
The real smart ones....are calculating market value minus the debt outstanding over gross rent.....to get their underlying return on equity.
The even smarter ones are calculating the value of the house allowing for CGT due as well.

No point going off a market value of €500k if you only get €400k when you sell it.
 
Just out of interest, I came across this. In Catalonia they introduced a large landlord/small landlord categorisation (we have copied them it seems), their rules are very complicated and there are huge penalties for technical breaches. Guess what - massive sell off by landlords
 
Driving small landlords from the private rental market is a feature not a bug of this legislation, it appears to be driven as ever by NGOs in the housing sector, the other stakeholders, the property industry and ordinary tenants don't seem to have been consulted.

Landlord bashing is an ideological fetish for the corbynite left in the way that solar panels are kryptonite to MAGA.
 
The proposed legislation is going to say that if you hold a property in a company you will be operating under the large landlord rules- no 4 property threshold. That's going to surprise a lot of people.
 
Driving small landlords from the private rental market is a feature not a bug of this legislation, it appears to be driven as ever by NGOs in the housing sector, the other stakeholders, the property industry and ordinary tenants don't seem to have been consulted.
I can certainly see it being a deliberate tactic to support the redistribution of wealth from the ‘landlord class’ to everyone else, if the shinners and the likes had their say
 
I think the government are accepting to lose a certain number of landlords with the result being that those who remain are committed and possible more “professional” and tenants end up with long term rights.
 
@faketales yes, you are likely correct. This came up in the Housing Committee. The Department officials admitted that small landlord numbers are reducing, but seemed happy with the idea that these would be replaced by large landlords.

There are problems though. Is this new regime attractive enough for even very large landlords? We've seen the problems and they'll apply to large landlords at well. It's unlikely they'll be able to increase to market rent at year 6 (political interference and/or the tenant will fight it with the RTB on board), so they'll have to aim for tenancy churn. Market rent when a tenant leaves doesn't seem to be quite market rent after all, it seems to be what the RTB thinks is market rent. It is also a very complicated regime. Building apartments is very expensive here, so they'll need high and increasing rents to maintain yield. Will there be political interference there too ie. rent freezes or even reductions?

Plus there is a genuine need for rentals in rural areas, villages and small towns. Only small landlords or small 'large' landlords operate there. So if you need to rent in say Charleville, there may be nothing at all available at any price there in a couple of years time.

The Department officials admitted that we need many more tenancies than the 240k we have, will these new rules achieve that - a much larger PRS practically entirely comprised of very large landlords?
 
I can certainly see it being a deliberate tactic to support the redistribution of wealth from the ‘landlord class’ to everyone else,
That seems to be a feature of these new rules also - you'll have to pay your tenant to leave, so a redistribution of wealth. Also, if you are a large landlord trying to sell a three bed semi with a long term tenant in situ in a small town, there will likely be no takers. The tenant will retain a large landlord tenancy, so only large landlords (with cash) can buy, there won't be any takers in that category. So the only likely purchaser is the tenant himself at a very large discount.

I've heard of what happens in the Netherlands via a family connection there. They have permanent tenancies as well. The landlord wants to sell, the tenant won't budge for any money so the landlord has to sell to the tenant at a discount.

So, yes I can see a redistribution of wealth idea here
 
It’s simply wealth destruction / redistribution via stealth. Plus not worth the hassle of dealing with sub par tenant choice in these areas
 
Has it been specified as to what exactly constitutes ' a family member' with reference to impending changes from March 06,I am thinking relationship to owner(s),age of family member etc
 
Has it been specified as to what exactly constitutes ' a family member' with reference to impending changes from March 06,I am thinking relationship to owner(s),age of family member etc
yourself, your spouse or a child
 
Plus there is a genuine need for rentals in rural areas, villages and small towns. Only small landlords or small 'large' landlords operate there. So if you need to rent in say Charleville, there may be nothing at all available at any price there in a couple of years time.

Yep - this stuck me too.....the pivot to professional landlord class potentially works in GDA & other metros but completely falls apart in exburb or rural location the mom & pop operators leaving these locations will be badly felt
 

Interestingly, this is already how the process works. A tenant must ask the landlord for permission to assign their lease. If the landlord agrees, everything proceeds smoothly. However, if the landlord refuses, the tenant can still go ahead with the assignment because the landlord cannot unreasonably withhold consent. This limits the landlord’s control over who the next tenant will be.

This situation often arises when a tenant, having stayed only part of a fixed-term lease (for example, 5 months of a 12-month lease), wants their deposit back. As a landlord, it is usually better to return the deposit and start fresh rather than letting the departing tenant decide who takes over the tenancy especially given the current rental market conditions and regulations.
Yes at the moment the tenant can leave if the landlord refuses to assign the lease. Also they can request that a partner or friend who moves in with them go on the lease. The landlord doesnt have to agree to either situation. Its fine in the situation where the landlord is happy for the tenant to leave and go find their own tenant or sell when its empty. What I was suggesting will happening is in future a landlord will not be allowed to refuse another person being added to the lease at whatever point the tenant decides. Therefore never getting their property back vacant again.
 
in future a landlord will not be allowed to refuse another person being added to the lease at whatever point the tenant decides.
To be clear:

As I read your post, this is you speculating & not based in any actual or proposed legislation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top