Landlords continue to sell up - Owen Reilly Q3 2025 Report

Status
Not open for further replies.
This whole rent control thing has been one disaster after another. I think this is the final nail in the coffin.
We were discussing what kind of tenant you would want to be rent to today.
We decided it would be a one bed apartment rented to a single student from another country who would be very likely to leave Ireland after graduating.
The reasons obviously were to find the least likely person to stay.
If you have a one bed apartment and only let it to one person and do not allow anyone else on the lease or even to move in with them then they are probably going to leave when they get into a serious relationship at some point. So a young foreign student would be the most likely to be moving on off their own steam.

But you know it wouldnt surprise me if the next legislation change, and im sure there will be many in a short space of time after March, is that a tenant can assign the lease to whoever they like, WITHOUT the landlord having a say in it. Then you will never see your property again.

The more I talk about this with other people and dive into the consequences on the horizon, the more I assume anyone who doesnt sell now must be mentally challenged in some way. It really is a dire situation to put yourself in, when you have one last opportunity to get out of the hole before the lid is nailed on.
 
That's like saying that after I pay my electricity bill or for a meal in a restaurant I've nothing to show for my mone
It's totally different IMO in that the tenant has been living in the same house for 6 or 7 years at this, not the same as going out for the odd restaurant meal

Could add more context e.g. someone who has been renting the same apartment for 6 or 7 years is kinda settled, the particular tentant has had the same job in the same company which is. Within walking distance of saud apartment

So it's not exactly a temporary arrangement on their part
 
At a press conference on August 12th, 1986, US President Ronald Reagan said, “The nine most terrifying words in the English language are ‘I’m from the government and I’m here to help.’”

He was bang on the money.
 
I assume anyone who doesnt sell now must be mentally challenged in some way
I have currently decided to keep my rental as in 2 years my eldest will finish university and will probably need some kind of accommodation. I sometimes wonder if it's insane.
I have chosen renters on their ability to leave promptly for the past 4 years. It has been working up to now.
 
The reasons obviously were to find the least likely person to stay.
The purposes of the new rental rules are to create more tenancies and create longer term stable tenancies. It is doing exactly the opposite because as a landlord you have two choices:

1. Sell, or
2. Ensure you rent to someone who will only stay short term

I also think that @jamieb is right, as the market contracts further and rents increase as a result, expect more stringent rules to keep those landlords remaining in the market there and to reduce rents. The odds may be shortening on another eviction ban.
 
1763930086854.webp

When was that?
My err, 82% in 2004 and then a dramatic decline for best part of 2 decades.

I remember the commentary at the time. How Irish people were "obsessed" with home ownership.
 
But you know it wouldnt surprise me if the next legislation change, and im sure there will be many in a short space of time after March, is that a tenant can assign the lease to whoever they like, WITHOUT the landlord having a say in it. Then you will never see your property again.
Interestingly, this is already how the process works. A tenant must ask the landlord for permission to assign their lease. If the landlord agrees, everything proceeds smoothly. However, if the landlord refuses, the tenant can still go ahead with the assignment because the landlord cannot unreasonably withhold consent. This limits the landlord’s control over who the next tenant will be.

This situation often arises when a tenant, having stayed only part of a fixed-term lease (for example, 5 months of a 12-month lease), wants their deposit back. As a landlord, it is usually better to return the deposit and start fresh rather than letting the departing tenant decide who takes over the tenancy especially given the current rental market conditions and regulations.
 
I've no idea why the government would think all these provisions to increase tenant rights would stimulate supply. Hopefully they see sense.
Why do you think this is their aim?
I doubt they really care about it, all they are looking for is votes / support, I doubt they think further ahead than that!
 
Spoke with our solicitor today, he had advised us to sell one of our properties to get down to 3 properties. He said the amount of landlords doing the same is huge , just not worth the hassle any more and done great prices at the moment for properties in that price bracket , so a no brainer to get out. What to do with excess cash though is an issue , but a portfolio of stable relatively high yielding shares or land might be an option, land going great price too at the moment - a lot of liquidity around
 
Would the idea of linking rents to property tax valuation ever be considered?

Basically the center of the band is picked and an annual “fair rate” set, say 4.5%.

That would mean an annual rent of 22,500k on a property worth 500k (or 1,875 per month).

What to do with that? Well for a start if a tenant is paying well below that I don’t think they should get the renter credit. Same regarding the credit for landlords if rent is well above.

But it could also be used in setting the rent, this would align rent increases to property price increases which are somewhat tied to wage growth.

Sure it doesn’t allow landlords to chase max return but it also sets a market rate for properties that are clearly way under market value often because the landlord was once generous. If the rent is not allowed to increase to market perhaps the landlord could get a tax break.

Sure property valuations are less than perfect but there is a lot of data there.
 
Basically the center of the band is picked and an annual “fair rate” set, say 4.5%
Basically, you want to impose a "fair rate" yield of 4.5 per cent gross. Then, one would need to consider the expenses, before even any mortgage (for an apartment maintenance fees, insurance, not deductable property tax, basic repairs, servicing of appliances, rtb registration, and saying 1000 for refurbishment and furnishing). A week no rent between tenancies because there are always repairs and issues and tenants just don't leave only when it's convenient. For a 300k apartment with a 1700 service, you get a gross yield of 3.25 before tax of perhaps 52 per cent without any mortgage and interest... And before considering any risks link to this type of investment. One will say that property price increase with time, I would agree that it's generally the case. That very much depends on when one is buying and at what price. And at the same time, when you look at high property prices, that might mean that your yield has diminished over time. You might have started with a good 8-10 per cent yield, that has become 3.25 with increased price of property. To invest and stay in the property market, one considers all these. If one's property is now valued at 300k, one considers how to invest as best as possible these 300k today, not the fact that they perhaps paid 200k for it at some point.
 
Last edited:
Basically, you want to impose a "fair rate" yield of 4.5 per cent gros

It’s the concept I was throwing out there not the exact rate. I think you could have a slightly higher rate for apartments to reflect a higher operating cost in the favour of owner vs tenant.
 
I think you could have a slightly higher rate for apartments to reflect a higher operating cost in the favour of owner vs tenant.
My example didn't consider any borrowing at all. If you had to borrow even only €150k for that 300K investment over 30 years at 5.5%, you would add about 150k of cost/expenses over the period.
 
My example didn't consider any borrowing at all.

I’m not sure paying the loan is an expense. Perhaps the interest is.

Regardless my point was more about linking rent to the property valuation to some degree.

At the moment there are people who for no real reason are receiving a very low percentage of the valuation and others who just enter the market being in a position to achieve free market rates due to supply problems.
 
not sure paying the loan is an expense. Perhaps the interest is.
150K would be for the interest only, the other 150k would be repayment of the capital. The interest is an expense. What else could it be? It pays the bank.
 
You might have started with a good 8-10 per cent yield, that has become 3.25 with increased price of property.

You bet.....and the mom and pop landlords out there (the smart ones) are doing that math exactly.....market value of the unit relative to the net rent.

The real smart ones....are calculating market value minus the debt outstanding over gross rent.....to get their underlying return on equity.

The demographics of the mom and pop landlord in Ireland 50 or 60+....means most likely the properties they own have low or no mortgages on them.....the dirty secret of property investing is all the high return on equity years are really when the property is sitting at 80% or 90% LTV......as the years roll on the RoE comes down as the loan amortises and equity increases....

To put it more succinctly if comparing property investing to the other types of investments out there......I think a whole bunch of mom and pop investors could and should sell their properties as the 3-4% yields they get now can be achieved elsewhere with a whole lot more diversification, liquidity and less risk (tenant & sovereign).
 
More evidence from the Housing Committee last Tuesday that landlords are selling up due to the new rules

Thomas Gould said

Based on what I am getting in my office, a wave of evictions is coming in the new year
Conor Sheehan said

I have noticed an uplift in notices to quit but also in landlords looking to leave the market before these rules come in.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top