RTB sanctions fail to deter landlords
Friday's letters page in the Irish Times carries a reader's response to Tuesday's article: the "sanction" was "€837.90 in moving costs and €500 in damages", so the RTB doesn't deter landlords. Four things wrong in two sentences.
The tenants asked for it. They told the Tribunal in terms that they were not seeking substantial damages. They wanted their moving costs and an acknowledgment; Mr Murray said if he had to choose, he'd take the acknowledgment. The Tribunal said the losses "would normally be reflected in an award of substantial damages", then gave them what they'd asked for. The €837.90 measures two forgiving tenants, not a soft regulator. And it isn't a "sanction" at all; it's damages under s.56. Sanctions are a different process.
"Chose not to attend" is the newspaper's phrase. The report records no date, no method and no address for the hearing notice, just a failed phone call and the case officer's word.
On the RTB's 2026 reports, one absent party in twenty-six wasn't told the hearing was on, and those are only the ones who later surfaced. These two never did.
The figure. The receipts were €337.90. The €500 is inside the €837.90. The total order is €837.90, and the report says so three times. The newspaper added €500 to a figure that already contained it, hasn't corrected it, and its readers are now writing in about a number that doesn't exist.
The motive finding wasn't the Tribunal's to make. A s.56 complaint asks one question: did the daughter move in. Motive belongs in a validity dispute (s.56(6)(b)), which the tenants never brought. A statutory tribunal answered a question it wasn't given, on LinkedIn evidence, against two people who weren't there, and the paper reported it as routine. In the published reports I can find exactly one finding of bad motive the decision didn't need, against an absent party, and it's this one.
And the case the letter doesn't mention. Same subparagraph, same section, this year: an 80-year-old widow with a genuine notice paid €19,522.50 (TR0001469). Her husband died in May 2025 and her plans fell through. The tenant's loss was counted from the day he died: the difference to his bigger, dearer flat, running into the following year, plus €2,500 for his inconvenience, more than he'd claimed under that heading. Her mistake was not offering the flat back while she buried her husband. Both cases made the Irish Times. One drew a letter saying the RTB is too soft. It wasn't hers.
If the RTB doesn't deter landlords, as the Irish Times reader says, it isn't for want of trying on the 80 year old widow.
https://rtb.ie/disputes/dispute-outcomes-and-orders/adjudication-and-tribunal-orders/?_search=TR0001469
Residential Tenancies Board efforts to pursue cases of wrongful eviction are welcome, but its sanctions are not sufficient
www.irishtimes.com