RTB no teeth ?

but the key issue here is that the landlord did not show up, so they have no grounds for complaint. And the RTB should not be criticised for making a decision on the unchallenged evidence in front of them.
Two assumptions in there, and neither survives the report.

First, that they knew to show up. The report doesn't say when or how they were told. s.104 requires written notice of the hearing; the only record here is that the chair "confirmed with the case officer" that they were on notice. Compare TR0223-005989. The tenant didn't appear, the chair adjourned to ask how she'd been notified, and the answer was "by email only", which wasn't a lawful method of service at the time. The hearing was put back five weeks so she could be served by recorded post. That chair asked. This one took the case officer's word for it. In TR0001757 the RTB ran an adjudication without telling the landlords and never held the rehearing it promised; in TR0001325 it failed to notify the tenant of her own hearing. "They didn't turn up" is a reason to check the service of notice by the RTB, not a reason to automatically assume they couldn't be bothered. And it isn't a one-off. Add TR0001354, TR0001510 and TR0001281, where the notice arrived but the case files didn't and the hearing had to be adjourned on the day. (Let me know if you want more examples.). It doesn't stop at hearings either. In the Doonbeg rent review case from this month (TR0001627), the landlord, Councillor Rita McInerney, "first heard of RTB decision in the newspapers", according to the Clare Champion's headline of 15 October.

(Since we're on 005989: a landlord owed €48,797 lost both his notices because the warning letter said €50,259. The Tribunal did the sums itself. Nobody was in the room for the tenant either.)

Second, "the RTB should not be criticised for making a decision on the unchallenged evidence in front of them". I'd agree, if that's what it had done. The evidence in front of it was that the agent said the flat was near UCD. The finding was that the tenants were "told that she required the dwelling as she was due to commence studying in UCD". There was no evidence she was a student. Nobody said it. Not the agent, not the tenants, not the notice, not a document on the file. That sentence doesn't come from the evidence. It comes from the Tribunal. It then went to LinkedIn to disprove the thing it had written itself, and called the result an ulterior motive. That isn't deciding on unchallenged evidence. It's supplying the evidence and then deciding on it. An absent landlord is entitled to have the case against him stated as it was given, and the one thing an empty chair guarantees is that nobody is there to say "that's not what he said". That's the reason to be careful, not the excuse for not being.

And why shouldn't the RTB be criticised for finding something the Act doesn't ask it to find? s.56 asks whether the daughter moved in. It got the answer, and the €837.90 follows. Then it went on to find bad faith, on hearsay it had rewritten, against two people who weren't there, in a public report with their names on it. The Act didn't call for that. The tenants didn't ask for it. The Tribunal did it anyway. That is exactly what a tribunal should be criticised for.



https://rtb.ie/disputes/dispute-outcomes-and-orders/adjudication-and-tribunal-orders/?_search=TR0001645 https://rtb.ie/disputes/dispute-outcomes-and-orders/adjudication-and-tribunal-orders/?_search=TR0001757https://rtb.ie/disputes/dispute-outcomes-and-orders/adjudication-and-tribunal-orders/?_search=TR0001325https://rtb.ie/disputes/dispute-outcomes-and-orders/adjudication-and-tribunal-orders/?_search=TR0001354https://rtb.ie/disputes/dispute-outcomes-and-orders/adjudication-and-tribunal-orders/?_search=TR0001510https://rtb.ie/disputes/dispute-outcomes-and-orders/adjudication-and-tribunal-orders/?_search=TR0001281
 
Last edited:
but the key issue here is that the landlord did not show up, so they have no grounds for complaint.
The landlord is not complaining. I’d imagine they are delighted with the result.


But in the RTB case the agent or landlord spoke to the tenant.
The agent is alleged to have spoken to a different tenant. Of a different flat. That is according to the tenant at the Tribunal. Neither that other tenant nor the agent were at the tribunal.
The landlord could have challenged it had they shown up.
They don’t have to show up. Tenants and Landlords frequently do not show up. The RTB should be fair to those who do not show up. That would mean not relying on information that it is hearsay. There was zero evidence that the notice of termination

- property needed for daughter

Was untrue. In fact the tenant, who was there, had his Private Investigator there. Who confirmed that nobody had moved into the flat when the tenants left up to the official end of notice period. February. The notice was valid.

What do you think the landlord did incorrectly?
 
There are two possibilities here. Firstly, the landlords and tenants got into a fight over the dog and the landlords issued a fake NoT. That would explain the landlords not turning up at the Tribunal. They wouldn't be able to explain themselves. That could well have happened.

The other possibility is that the NoT was genuine, the landlords weren't told of the hearing or missed an email notification (that does appear to happen) and the case has been found against them based on the Tribunal doing its own investigations, relying on hearsay evidence and putting 2 and 2 together to make 5.

The problem is there is so much bias in the Tribunal and so much sloppiness it is impossible to work out what happened.

The other odd point is that as the Tribunal clearly believes that this was a fake eviction, why is the compensation so low? The tenants' new flat is €400 per month more expensive and they had all the hassle of moving. The 80 year old widow in the other case did intend to sell, there was a change of mind when her husband died, yet she had to pay €20k or so compensation for not offering the property back. The compensation levels should be swapped if anything.
 
They don’t have to show up. Tenants and Landlords frequently do not show up. The RTB should be fair to those who do not show up. That would mean not relying on information that it is hearsay. There was zero evidence that the notice of termination

If I am taking or defending a case, I would show up.

Are you suggesting that I should be able to have the case adjourned simply by not showing up?

This should be the same for both. The evidence of the person showing up should be accepted if not challenged.
 
The evidence of the person showing up should be accepted if not challenged.
Accepted as given, yes. The agent said "near UCD". The Tribunal wrote down "due to commence studying in UCD", disproved its own version on LinkedIn, and called it bad faith. That isn't accepting evidence. It's making it up. No one in the evidence section said she was a student. Would you agree?

So, straight question: are you saying a tribunal has carte blanche when the landlord isn't present?

And "the same for both"? Take a look at TR0001584: landlord present, evidence of hand delivery rejected as "an assertion of practice rather than proof of delivery" because the deliverer wasn't called. Present, and still rejected. Here the landlords were absent, and the evidence was embellished against them.
 
One more thing. The chair opened by saying all evidence would be "recorded by the official stenographer present". So there is a verbatim record. The Tribunal's own evidence section, written from it, says "proximity to UCD". The reasons section of the same report says "due to commence studying in UCD". With a stenographer in the room and the transcript to hand, the Tribunal still rested its finding on words nobody said. On a s.123 appeal the High Court reads the report; it doesn't rehear the witnesses. That contradiction is the appeal, and the RTB's own stenographer is the proof.

Nobody will take it. High Court, 21 days, point of law, costs if you lose. Nobody spends five figures to overturn €837.90. So the bad-faith finding stays on the public register, with their names on it, because the appeal costs more than the fine.
 
The Tribunal wrote down "due to commence studying in UCD", disproved its own version on LinkedIn, and called it bad faith. That isn't accepting evidence. It's making it up. No one in the evidence section said she was a student. Would you agree?
Well, there is this passage in the Tribunal's judgment:
The evidence before the Tribunal, while hearsay, is that the Applicant Tenants were told that she required the dwelling as she was due to commence studying in UCD . . .
Who gave that evidence? We can't be absolutely sure without reading the transcript, which we don't have, but it's not difficult to deduce that. The applicant tenants were present at the hearing, and both gave evidence. So any evidence about what they were told almost certainly came from them. One or both of them said words to the effect that "we were told that the landlord's daughter wanted to live in the flat because she was starting a course in UCD, and the flat is convenient to UCD".

[There are two other possiblities:
  • Nobody said anything of the kind and the Tribunal simply made it up. I discount this as an unlikely speculation for which there is no evidence.
  • The written notice of termination actually stated that the daughter was to start in UCD, but the summary of it in the Tribunal's judgment doesn't mention this detail. I discount this also, because if that was the case I don't think the Tribunal would call that "hearsay".]
Is the evidence hearsay? It's hearsay evidence that the daughter was due to start a course at UCD, but that's not the issue. It's direct evidence that the tenants were told this. But I think the Tribunal's use of the word is explained when we look at what they said in full:
The evidence before the Tribunal, while hearsay, is that the Applicant Tenants were told that she required the dwelling as she was due to commence studying in UCD, but also that the person in question had graduated university and commenced a new job around the time of the notice in this case.
It's the second bit that was hearsay. Neither the landlord nor his daughter gave evidence at the tribunal, and there is no suggestion that the tenants or their investigator had ever directly observed the daughter in her employment. Evidence about where and when she was working came from one of the tenants testifying as to what he had seen on e.g. the daughter's LinkedIn and other social media accounts about her job. That's hearsay.
 
One more thing. The chair opened by saying all evidence would be "recorded by the official stenographer present". So there is a verbatim record. The Tribunal's own evidence section, written from it, says "proximity to UCD". The reasons section of the same report says "due to commence studying in UCD". With a stenographer in the room and the transcript to hand, the Tribunal still rested its finding on words nobody said. On a s.123 appeal the High Court reads the report; it doesn't rehear the witnesses. That contradiction is the appeal, and the RTB's own stenographer is the proof.

Nobody will take it. High Court, 21 days, point of law, costs if you lose. Nobody spends five figures to overturn €837.90. So the bad-faith finding stays on the public register, with their names on it, because the appeal costs more than the fine.
This is so messed up, what a system.. how could you have any faith in such a system
 
One or both of them said words to the effect that "we were told that the landlord's daughter wanted to live in the flat because she was starting a course in UCD, and the flat is convenient to UCD".
That's a fair reading and I can't exclude it. But we do have something better than deduction. The evidence section of the report is the Tribunal's own record of what each witness said, and it's not thin. For Mr Murray it records the CAO timing, the dog emails, the Google search, the Leaving Cert and graduation years, the LinkedIn job, the screenshots, the horse breeding, the father's cancer treatment, the two vans, the cleaners, the deposit timing and the garden.

On the agent's call it records one thing: that the daughter "would need the dwelling due to its proximity to UCD". For Ms Judge, who took the call, it records only that the agent "outlined the issue with the Respondent Landlords' daughter". No course. No studying. Not in either account.

So the choice is between two readings. Either a Tribunal that wrote down the garden and the vans left out the one phrase its motive finding turns on, or it inferred "student" from "CAO offers" plus "proximity to UCD" and wrote the inference into the reasons as something the tenants were told. I think the second is the likelier. But take the first if you prefer. The report is the record the High Court reads on appeal. If the evidence section is missing the decisive words, that's a defect in the Tribunal's own document, and the finding still rests on words that appear nowhere in its own account of the evidence. Either way the problem sits with the author of the report. And that's where it would be found. On a s.123 appeal the High Court reads the whole report, not the reasons alone. It isn't going to skip section 5 and take section 7's word for what the evidence was. It will read the Tribunal's own account of the evidence, find "proximity to UCD", read the reasons, find "due to commence studying in UCD", and ask where the student came from. The Tribunal has no answer to that in its own document.

On the hearsay point we agree. The LinkedIn material is the second-hand part, and it's the part that does the work: "graduated university and commenced a new job" is what the Tribunal set against the agent's remark to find an ulterior motive. That's a finding s.56 never asked for, built on the one piece of evidence that was hearsay in the full sense, in a case where nobody was there to say what the daughter's job has to do with where she wants to live.

"Making it up" was a shorter phrase than the point deserved. "Found in the reasons what it hadn't recorded in the evidence" is exact.
 
christ above you dont need anymore evidence that this housing situation is fubar when you have a tenant hiring Micky Spillane to watch an empty apartment that nothing happens in and thatis the evidence for a payout.

whats the movie going to be called "death on the 46A"
 
For Mr Murray it records the CAO timing, the dog emails, the Google search, the Leaving Cert and graduation years, the LinkedIn job, the screenshots, the horse breeding, the father's cancer treatment, the two vans, the cleaners, the deposit timing and the garden.

And for all that, no proof that the flat was occupied prior to the date of termination of the notice.

Honestly the invasion of privacy in this case beggars belief. The landlord being a horse breeder is relevant how, his cancer treatment how, incredible stuff. Valid notice was served. Nobody was in occupation during the time of the notice. But hearsay about a daughter who might or might go to college was pivotal in the award.

What did the landlord actually do wrong.
 
for all that, no proof that the flat was occupied prior to the date of termination of the notice.
Is the landlord (or the family member who is about to move into the property) prohibited from accessing the property until the final termination date? Eg if the notice runs to 31st Dec but the tenant moves out on 8th Dec, the property must stay empty until the 31st? Is it because the tenant still has a right to be there until 31st? What if the tenant wants to leave early, do they need to inform the landlord in writing that they are vacating on x date.

If they don’t, presumably they can move back in until the final date. Does that mean any estate agents, workmen etc can’t be there either?

Everything is so complicated..
 
Last edited:
And for all that, no proof that the flat was occupied prior to the date of termination of the notice.
That's the point, Bronte. The grounds for termination was asserted to be the need for a family member to occupy the flat. But the evidence points to no family member occupying the flat.
Honestly the invasion of privacy in this case beggars belief. The landlord being a horse breeder is relevant how, his cancer treatment how . . .
Nitpick: The cancer was in the tenants' family, not the landlord's. They put it in evidence.
But hearsay about a daughter who might or might go to college was pivotal in the award.
No, it's central to our picking over the entrails of the case, but it wasn't actually central to the case. Whether the daughter was said to require the property because she was going to college, or for a different reason, or for no stated reason, doesn't really matter. The point was that the notice to terminate was predicated on her need to occupy the premises, but she didn't occupy the premises, which calls into question whether the grounds of termination were genuine or not.
Is the landlord (or the family member who is about to move into the property) prohibited from accessing the property until the final termination date? Eg if the notice runs to 31st Dec but the tenant moves out on 8th Dec, the property must stay empty until the 31st? Is it because the tenant still has a right to be there until 31st?
In this case, the tenants were given notice to quit that would have expired in February 2026. But a relative was coming to live with them while he had cancer treatment, and they didn't want to have to move house in the middle of that, so they chose to move immediately, before that cancer treatment would start. So the tenancy was in fact terminated (by agreement, presumably) in mid-September 2025. From that point on there was no tenant; the landlord was free to enter the property.
 
So the tenancy was in fact terminated (by agreement, presumably)
But does the tenant have to inform the landlord in writing that they are leaving early? Otherwise it’s he-said-she-said. If a landlord started working on a property before the final date, they could be in a right mess.
 
Tenant is liable for rent until the tenancy terminates; also can't seek to get their deposit back until then. So tenants are highly motivated to let the landlord know if they want the tenancy to end earlier than it has to, and landlords are normally delighted to agree, since they get the property back sooner, and can proceed with whatever it is they want to do with it.

Simply leaving your property does not terminate the tenancy, and you remain liable for rent, etc, until the tenancy is terminated.

In this case the tenant accepted that the tenancy expired on 15 September 2025 and that "appeared uncontroversial to the Tribunal" — meaning the Tribunal thought that if the landlord had turned up it would not have argued to the contrary. The deposit was returned when the tenancy was terminated, which can only mean that the landlord accepted and agreed to the early termination, which presumably is why the Tribunal thought that the landlord would not have disputed that the tenance terminated on 15 September 2025.
 
That's the point, Bronte. The grounds for termination was asserted to be the need for a family member to occupy the flat. But the evidence points to no family member occupying the flat.
The termination date was February, so therefore the landlord didn't need it until February. We have no idea if anyone was in in from February, but we have the private investigator's confirmation that no one was in it prior to February. The tribunal wanted to know if the PI knew from February.

The landlord could change their mind about the daughter, then they would have to offer the place back to the tenant. Not sure how that works since the tenant then gave notice thenselves.

BTW the tenant's notice was 2 weeks, which is wrong as it's too short, but I don't know how that plays out with the rules where the landlord has given notice.

( In my life any time a tenant said they were leaving we never had it in writing, and honestly did not care if it was tomorrow or a week from now. )

No, it's central to our picking over the entrails of the case, but it wasn't actually central to the case. Whether the daughter was said to require the property because she was going to college, or for a different reason, or for no stated reason, doesn't really matter. The point was that the notice to terminate was predicated on her need to occupy the premises, but she didn't occupy the premises, which calls into question whether the grounds of termination were genuine or not.
The reason for the daughter is not relevant, the reason is needed for family member. We do not know if she occupied the premises. But we do know the termination end date was February. If she did not occupy it in February than the notice would have been invalid, or their would be repercussions.

That's now superceded by the tenants leaving before their notice period. Plus the tenants stated they didn't want to return.

The logical conclusion is the landlord put nobody in their from when the tenants left until February. If they had, and it was not the daughter, they would have been in hot water. If they decided after the tenant left, that they no longer needed it for the daughter, the landlord would have had to offered the place back to the tenants.

Further Picking

What happens if the landlord decided in February to sell it? (are they allowed change their minds)
What happens if the landlord decides to let it to someone else in March?

Do they have to offer it back to the tenants.
 
The termination date was February, so therefore the landlord didn't need it until February.
I think the termination dated stated in the notice to quit was February because the tenants were entitled to six months' notice, and if the landlord had served notice purporting to terminate any earlier it would have been invalid.
The landlord could change their mind about the daughter, then they would have to offer the place back to the tenant. Not sure how that works since the tenant then gave notice thenselves.
I don't think the tenants give notice; they accepted the landlord's notice and then negotiated an earlier termination date. I don't know this for sure, but that's how this would usually play out; the tenants wouldn't "counter-serve" their own notice of termination specifying an earlier date.
 
I think the termination dated stated in the notice to quit was February because the tenants were entitled to six months' notice, and if the landlord had served notice purporting to terminate any earlier it would have been invalid.
The Tribunal seem to have been influenced by the idea that the NoT was issued because the daughter was going to college. There are mentions of September, the CAO results being out and the daughter having a job and being too old for college. But if the termination date was February, that college starts in September is irrelevant. Had the landlords required it for their daughter for college, surely they would have issued the NoT in March to guarantee vacant possession in September.

Absent the transcript and evidence from the landlords, it is very diffcult to make out what was going on.
 
If they decided after the tenant left, that they no longer needed it for the daughter, the landlord would have had to offered the place back to the tenants
Just curious but does the 12 months offer-back period start on the final date of the termination notice or in this case would it be 12 months from when the tenant moved out?
 
notice to quit that would have expired in February 2026.....tenancy was in fact terminated (by agreement, presumably) in mid-September 2025.
Hang on though:

NoT issued with the expectation of property being vacant Feb 2026.

It would be reasonable for offspring to make their arrangements accordingly - i.e. expecting to occupy property from Feb 26, offspring sells / hands in notice / books removal van / flights / whatever with that date in mind.

Tenant leaves 4 months earlier than NoT date, which they are perfectly entitled to do, don't imagine owner had any major issue with this.

But offspring can't be expected to just jump, change all their plans/ flights / removal van/ job notice (**) when they had made plans for a Feb 26 move in.

**these are by way of example
 
Back
Top