Resolving The Burke Enigma . . .

Status
Not open for further replies.
The bad press Ireland is getting over it is growing.
The only interest of the media outside of Ireland are from far right media who will jump on any bandwagon anywhere in the world to titilate their band of cheerleaders

The regular media consumed by 99%+ of the world's population have zero interest in this nutter.

The injunction is against him trespassing on the school grounds. There is no issue if he protests outside the school gates. But he is intent on continued disruption to the education of the many children going to the school and thus the injunction was a very valid one put in place to protect others. It also meant he had a band of sheep-like supporters who also disrupted the school by attending outside.

For most of us, he's a bad comedy act.
 
The point I'm making is that a course on critical thinking without integral creative thinking content - or else a parallel creative thinking course - is going to lead to the elevation of knockers to jobs - like leading management jobs - that they just won't be able to do.
People who are unable to do a job rarely end up doing it for any length of time. I don't think educating people is a bad thing in any scenario.
You gotta have both perspectives for managing a business or even just an R&D project.
That is aa different matter and. In my experience there is very little correlation between the ability to manage a business and education level.

Surely be to Moses you don't believe that Irish people have an intrinsic sufficiency of creativity, do you ?
I don't think Irish people are intrinsically different to any other people. There's no scientific basis for race or racial behaviour. Our behaviour patterns are down to culture and education.


Purple, at times you leave me purple in the bloody face :oops:
It's working then :D
 
People who are unable to do a job rarely end up doing it for any length of time.

Christ, they do - and only how painfully often have I seen it. In 6 universities in Ireland and UK, I saw more of these guys than of the rightly appointed ones. Lots of goofers in the private sector too. Making themselves an extension of their boss' alter ego was their modus operandi - kinda like the Bob Benson character in Mad Men.

That is a different matter and. In my experience there is very little correlation between the ability to manage a business and education level.

You mean formal education - the stuff at school or college. Don't say that self-education after working hours and employer-arranged courses, mentoring, etc doesn't promote people. There's lots of guys leaving the formal education system at 14 who ended up managing the factories that gave them a start. But they had to hit the oul books in their own time of course - though with concrete incentive always before them when working.

I don't think Irish people are intrinsically different to any other people. There's no scientific basis for race or racial behaviour.

I do. And there is. For example, actual psychometric studies of various ethnic groups show Ashkenazi Jews have a proven weakness (all relative, of course - look at Liebeskind's buildings for an outlier) at spatial reasoning. If you ever worked with Iranian scientists/engineers you'd notice how their way of looking at things is way different to the conventional western textbook way.
And I think it's fair to say that Paddies have a way with words, wouldn't you say ?
 
Christ, they do - and only how painfully often have I seen it. In 6 universities in Ireland and UK, I saw more of these guys than of the rightly appointed ones.
I can't speak for universities but as they are Unionised they are far from meritocratic.

Lots of goofers in the private sector too. Making themselves an extension of their boss' alter ego was their modus operandi - kinda like the Bob Benson character in Mad Men.
Not my experience, or at least they get found out and moved on quickly. I work in the internationally traded goods and services sector so we are open to real competition. There's no room for chancers and idiots.

You mean formal education - the stuff at school or college.
Yes, qualification rather than education.

Don't say that self-education after working hours and employer-arranged courses, mentoring, etc doesn't promote people. There's lots of guys leaving the formal education system at 14 who ended up managing the factories that gave them a start. But they had to hit the oul books in their own time of course - though with concrete incentive always before them when working.
To quote Shaw (out of context) "Those who can do, those who can't teach."
Most of what we learn in a few decades of work is done through problem solving and research, individually or in teams. If that's what you mean by hitting the books then I agree.

I do. And there is. For example, actual psychometric studies of various ethnic groups show Ashkenazi Jews have a proven weakness (all relative, of course - look at Liebeskind's buildings for an outlier) at spatial reasoning.
Yes, a reflection of inbreeding and nothing more. The Habsburgs had sinus issues for the same reason.

If you ever worked with Iranian scientists/engineers you'd notice how their way of looking at things is way different to the conventional western textbook way.
That's probably because they, along with the Indians, invented mathematics and much of modern Science. I'm a big fan of Al-Khwarizmi, who literally wrote the book on Algebra and gave us the concept of zero. Then there's Nasir al-Din al-Tusi who gave us Trigonometry and not forgetting Ibn Sina who gave us modern Medicine and Ibn al-Haytham who should be regarded as the father of the Scientific Method rather than Francis Bacon. Yes, that history and that deep scientific culture would present itself differently to how Western scientists view things. There's nothing genetic in it though.

And I think it's fair to say that Paddies have a way with words, wouldn't you say ?
Yes, due to our culture.
 
What a remarkable family.

Come on. Every family has a black sheep or two.

There may be delusions on religious beliefs and the right to impose them on others by the Burkes but no one has suggested that they are swindlers or fraudsters. All the siblings and parents of Enoch are well-qualified in their professions and working honestly.

And that is essentially the problem courts have in dealing with them. Despite their extreme views and actions, they are otherwise upright, law-abiding and productive citizens. Far more so than many brought before the District Court . . . or indeed working within it.
 
I'd just love to know about the student who was the centre of all of this. What are their thoughts on the matter, are they even still at the school?

Do they still use the pronouns they asked to be known by, one does wonder given all the fads these days?

For me, my thoughts are toe the party line in work to get paid. Get paid and then come 5pm go back to being your true self, everybody's a winner.
 
I'd just love to know about the student who was the centre of all of this. What are their thoughts on the matter, are they even still at the school?

Do they still use the pronouns they asked to be known by, one does wonder given all the fads these days?

I'd say they/them are keeping their head well down these times.

Mom and Dad's peace of mind has to be considered while they are living at home - which these days may last much longer than the Leaving Cert . . . :eek:

For me, my thoughts are toe the party line in work to get paid. Get paid and then come 5 pm go back to being your true self, everybody's a winner.

I get the sentiment. It leads to an "easy life" at work, so to speak. These days you're unlikely to be gazumped in the public morality auction by hardly anyone at work no matter if the issue is life-or-death pollution emissions from the company's chimneys, 'acquired' (stolen) property sales being invested with your company by a diocese's investment sub-committee or even a Vice-President of your multinational employer acting like a cherokee horseman with a secretary after hours in a corner of the plant.

Only trouble is it makes it so much harder to take down our own young Johnny's pants and beat him for stealing a swig of Nash's lemonade after Mom laid down the law last time. :confused:
 
You would have to feel sorry for anyone who gets upset over a point of grammar. Enoch and his admirers would be flabbergasted to learn that 1.4 billion people in China manage to survive using the same spoken word for both he and she.

Apart from your sexual partner or healthcare professional, who has any reason to ask about your sex/gender/pronouns?

The world would be a better place if folks spent less time thinking about the genitalia and genetics of other people, especially children.
 
Last edited:
The world would be a better place if folks spent less time thinking about the genitalia and genetics of other people, especially children.

Is that not as applicable to trans gender people too? Isn't that effectively what the trans-identify issue is about, the genetics and genitalia of people women in a mans body, vice-versa?

I don't think Burke has handled this issue well at all, but I do think he raises points about religious beliefs and rights etc.

I don't actually agree with using the pronouns "they/them" for a singular person. Those pronouns may not be gender specific but they are not gender nuetral either. They refer to a group of people, of more than one, and that group of people consists of all male, all female or a mixture of both male and female.
Someone (or should I say 'somethem'?) wanting to use "they/them" as a pronoun for their identify are in fact being asked to be identified as more than one person.
 
You would have to feel sorry for anyone who gets upset over a point of grammar.

If my son says that he is a woman, clearly he is delusional.

If my employer then obliges me to call my son a woman, I do object to that. The employer is affirming the delusion.

If the State forces me to refer to my son as a woman, I also object to that. Again, the State would be forcing people to lie.
 
If my son says that he is a woman, clearly he is delusional.
If your son becomes a priest and asks you to call him father is he also dillusional?

Objecting to transgenderism on the basis of questionable science is one thing.
Objecting to it on a basis of religion, a thing that has no basis in science at all and is objectively ridiculous, is quite another thing entirely.

If my employer then obliges me to call my son a woman, I do object to that. The employer is affirming the delusion.
If your son is a priest and you work for the Church should your employer be allowed to compel you to call him father?

If the State forces me to refer to my son as a woman, I also object to that. Again, the State would be forcing people to lie.
Yep, the State should not force people to call anyone anything.

To be clear about this: Enoch Burke was not compelled refer to a child using them/they pronouns. He were not suspended for refusing to refer to a child using them/they pronouns. Burke was suspended for causing ongoing disruption because other people were referring to the child using them/they pronouns.

He was he who was seeking to impose his views and his modes of language on other.
 
Last edited:
Is that not as applicable to trans gender people too? Isn't that effectively what the trans-identify issue is about, the genetics and genitalia of people women in a mans body, vice-versa?
Yes, that's what it is about. I'm a life and let live kind of person and a big believer is good manners so I refer to people in the way that they wish to be referred.

I don't think Burke has handled this issue well at all, but I do think he raises points about religious beliefs and rights etc.
He was seeking to impose his religious beliefs on others. I don't think that should be allowed.

I don't actually agree with using the pronouns "they/them" for a singular person. Those pronouns may not be gender specific but they are not gender nuetral either. They refer to a group of people, of more than one, and that group of people consists of all male, all female or a mixture of both male and female.
Someone (or should I say 'somethem'?) wanting to use "they/them" as a pronoun for their identify are in fact being asked to be identified as more than one person.
Words mean what people think they mean. We often hear about fulsome apologies. That now means complete and heartfelt. Until recently it means insincere and gushing. People misused to word so much that it came to mean something else. I don't think the policing of pronoun use is that important.

I've more of an issue with the misuse verb phrase "would have", as in "I would have been a supporter of Enoch Burke". That means that I wasn't a supporter but would have been except for some other event or circumstance. For many Irish people it means that they were a supporter or used to be a supporter.
That, for me, is a far bigger issue that gender pronouns but I don't seek to stop people misusing the phrase or disrupt my workplace because such misusage is tolerated.

Overly woke easily offended people annoy my but not as much as fundamentalists.
 
The point I'm making is that a course on critical thinking without integral creative thinking content - or else a parallel creative thinking course - is going to lead to the elevation of knockers to jobs - like leading management jobs - that they just won't be able to do.
With respect, what on earth are you talking about? You have a strong propensity to speak in riddles so what are you trying to say?

You seem to be implying that that Burke is a creative thinker that should be treated differently by the law/state

His stance is not based on either critical thinking or creative thinking. It is based solely on indoctrinated religious beliefs.
 
To be clear about this: Enoch Burke was not compelled refer to a child using them/they pronouns. They were not suspended for refusing to refer to a child using them/they pronouns. Burke was suspended for causing ongoing disruption because other people were referring to the child using them/they pronouns.

This is just legalistic talk and the synthetic categorizing of a technocrat to make decisions and administration easy.

Burke was essentially suspended and finally sacked on account of his using, and misusing, his teacher position to assert his own moral principles and to a significant degree impose them on others in his workplace. It's likely that, given his previous form, he would have found another topical moral issue and used his teaching job to assert it had the they/them issue not happened.

It's senseless to put people like Burke into prison repeatedly. He's not the criminal type. His issue seems to be the unreality of what he has been conditioned to during his upbringing by his mother (mostly) and father and how this then impacts with the reality of a life in harmony with others in society. Mrs Burke's teaching hadn't addressed that - or at least found any alternative to simply insisting on doing things her own way.

At its core, the issue here is the balancing of one's social obligation and one's own conscience. Liam Cosgrave and a few more conservatives crossed the floor to vote against a bill on family planning that his own government had introduced. There was laughter and ridicule, political pantomime and liberal despair. Yet no one really challenged the idea of voting according to conscience.

I wonder if Wilson's Hospital management had simply asked Burke to send them a letter from him requesting "conscientious release" from this single aspect of his employment and thereafter exempted him from teaching transgender pupils, would the present impasse have been skilfully avoided ? I doubt if many, if any, of Burke's fellow teachers would have followed suit on this matter and Burke would thus be denied the mushroom cloud of publicity and public emotion that his actions would otherwise - intentionally - engender.

It's worth noting that the Burkes' behaviour has never been simply a matter of personal conscience. There has nearly always been a political aspect to it. They want to change this or that existing practice/process for everyone in society, not just for themselves. This has been manifest in the way that others in the family have come in to support one family member, e.g. Ammi or Enoch, when a controversy arose with them. On their own, anyone taking a stand like that of Enoch Burke would be simply seen as an odd-ball - so the family is drafted in to repeat the mantra beside them. However, conscience has been the principle tool of the Burkes and indeed others who sought to undo societal changes adopted with social consensus. By enabling this conscientious release from specific tasks, we can take a share of the wind from the sails of those who seek to obstruct or disrupt the acceptance of social change.
 
I agree with all of that but;
I wonder if Wilson's Hospital management had simply asked Burke to send them a letter from him requesting "conscientious release" from this single aspect of his employment and thereafter exempted him from teaching transgender pupils, would the present impasse have been skilfully avoided ?
Burke never taught the child and the school didn't make a specific request that he use gender neutral pronouns for the child. When Burke got wind of the fact that the students wishes were being accommodated he reacted in a disruptive way. He was reprimanded for doing so but repeated his actions during an event lead for the CofI Archbishop, resulting in students walking out in protest against his actions. That caused a disciplinary process to start, one with he was contractually obliged to engage with. He refused to engage and was suspended as a result.
None of that was against the law and none of it resulted in his imprisonment. The school took an injunction out to keep him away from the school as he was turning up each day and causing disruption and distress. He refused to comply with the Court Order and that resulted in him being imprisoned for contempt of court. Legally he's no different from a man who keeps turning up at his Ex's house after she's got an injunction to keep him away.
 
Burke was essentially suspended and finally sacked on account of his using, and misusing, his teacher position to assert his own moral principles and to a significant degree impose them on others in his workplace
This has been done to death at this stage. That statement is clearly false, with evidence of same a matter of public record via the courts.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top