Resolving The Burke Enigma . . .

Status
Not open for further replies.

trajan

Registered User
Messages
372
Every time Enoch Burke goes before a court judge, that judge clearly feels:

(1) constrained to uphold the law;

and

(2) personally affected by the clear non-criminality of Burke - an otherwise model citizen, professional and, to borrow a phrase of Turgenev's, a thoroughly well-washed young man - and the fact that incarceration is the last place people like him should be experiencing.

I daresay so would the rest of us.

What we have here is a non-political challenge to the authority of the Irish courts. Burke isn't refusing to recognise the court, he's solely - though not insignificantly - trying to overrule it on a matter of personal conscience upon which he has strong beliefs. To my knowledge nobody has tried such a thing with the Irish courts before. Unlike the 20s, 30s, 40s, 50s and 70s, today's Irish prisoners of conscience seldom if ever go on hunger strike. I don't think we should rule such an eventuality out here.

There is a disquieting aspect to this that goes beyond the mere matter at hand in this case, i.e. the use of a neutral pronoun for addressing transgender people in a classroom. It's about the rights of people to make genuine decisions of conscience in many other matters, past, current and impending.

Would it be a no-no to suggest that all sides take a blow here ?

Would it be inappropriate that say an SC or retired (but still vigorous) judge would be asked to form a citizen's forum to discuss this kind of issue so that the High Court doesn't become a de facto battlefield for interpretation of hastily prepared regulations of the type that has Burke in prison when he should be enjoying a well-remunerated Leaving Cert exam-correction period followed by his summer vacation ?

While I strongly disapprove of what Burke is doing - and moreover his approach of it - I would like to think that the Irish state has moved on from driving its principled opponents into prison or into exile a la the 1920s. This thing needs resolution not just because it makes this country a laughing stock with the media abroad. We also need to provide time-pressed legislators with a solid and broad-consensus resource to turn to when new laws are needed to reflect changes in our society.
 
Last edited:
You know he wasn't jailed for his beliefs or opinions? He was jailed for repeatedly breaching an injunction that ordered him to stay away from the school.
 
I'm a bit conflicted about this issue.
I find it ridiculous that he has chosen such an inconsequential issue as the hill he is willing to die on.
At the same time I think it is a monumental waste of State resources pursuing the matter.
But given, as Leo points out, the issue causing his legal problems is his failure to abide by a Court Order, I don't see what alternative there is.

On a more general point while I don't understand Transgenderism I believe in trying to be well mannered and not causing needless offence so I'll call anyone them/they is they wish me to do so. It makes more sense than calling a man who is younger then me and to whom I have no biological relation "Father".
Oh, and Bronze Age tribal writings are not a valid counter argument to any scientific or sociological proposition. If someone wants to tell me why transgenderism does not have a valid basis in medicine or science and backs that up with peer reviewed scientific data then I'm all ears but if their counter argument is a religious text then I'm not interested. Dodgy science trumps magic men in the sky any day of the week.
 
Personally I admire this principled young man.
I don't. I think he's a fundamentalist nutter who should try to be a bit more humane and have some empathy. I don't think he should be in prison though.

I have never had any issue with someone obeying their own moral or ethical code and staying true to it.
Racial purity laws, religious violence, genocide and the imposition of utopian ideals have all been done by people who are "obeying their own moral or ethical code and (are) staying true to it". Moral certainty scares the daylights out of me.
 
@Purple

I guess we're all conflicted in some way about this.

However, it's hardly good form to shunt all our undecided issues into a siding that leads irrevocably to the High Court of Ireland. Judges there really have far more pressing - and more jurisprudential - issues to decide.
 
@Purple

I guess we're all conflicted in some way about this.

However, it's hardly good form to shunt all our undecided issues into a siding that leads irrevocably to the High Court of Ireland. Judges there really have far more pressing - and more jurisprudential - issues to decide.
But what undecided issue is the judge in question dealing with?
 
But what undecided issue is the judge in question dealing with?

How to justly deal with conscience-driven dissenters to a law of our current society. That should be part of the thinking going into the social legislation in my view.

When the new abortion bill was floated, no one expected that it would be enforced at the point of a bayonet or that doctors refusing would be dismissed from their jobs. Tolerance was shown. I accept that the objecting doctors constituted a much bigger minority than the people sharing Enoch Burke's views - possibly a majority? - but the principle of fair treatment to conscientious refusers to a law is essentially the same, albeit more administratively and politically pressing to provide it for the doctors.
 
Last edited:
On the salient point of my starting post in bold - do you agree or not ?
I think employers should work within the legislation as it stands, that applies to how they conduct their business, frame conditions of employment or codes of conduct, and any disciplinary procedures applying to those. I also think employees should be expected to adhere to the law and their employers' rules for conduct.
 
How to justly deal with conscience-driven dissenters to a law of our current society.
This isn't really the issue here. There are conscience-driven dissenters to many laws on our books. Three are valid mechanism for them to register such dissent or campaign for change. Dissension, regardless of motivation should not allow anyone to break the law.
 
Would it be inappropriate that say an SC or retired (but still vigorous) judge would be asked to form a citizen's forum to discuss this kind of issue so that the High Court doesn't become a de facto battlefield for interpretation of hastily prepared regulations of the type that has Burke in prison when he should be enjoying a well-remunerated Leaving Cert exam-correction period
Do not like these citizen forums.
 
Dissension, regardless of motivation should not allow anyone to break the law.

Yet it has long been the view of people battling unjust laws that they have a duty to break it and if necessary go to jail for doing so.

Sure 99.999% of people won't put morality ahead of their own everyday duty to put bread on the table for their dependents and go to jail against an unjust law.

But some will. And we have to be careful how we treat the most sensitive and high-minded of our citizens - even where we strongly disagree with them and the methods they adopt.
 
RTE have a reasonable piece on the background here, to suggest this is all down to some rushed legislation is to ignore years of evolving legislation and guidance on the matter.
 
Sure 99.999% of people won't put morality ahead of their own everyday duty to put bread on the table for their dependents and go to jail against an unjust law.
What do you think is unjust about the legislation he has jailed under?
 
What do you think is unjust about the legislation he has jailed under?

Nothing.

But Burke does think that there's something morally wrong with it. And I guess Burke's morality predicates his sense of what's just or not.

My personal concern is that we treat dissenters like Burke in a way that is not unfair to them, to their right to profitably exercise their vocational skills or deny them credit for so doing in a way that would injure their social life unduly. If we as a society do not do this, we create martyrs of extreme dissenters and role models for those young people impressed by their sacrifice.
 
It ain't that simple, man.

And damn well you know it.
It is that simple.

He is the subject of aa Court Order and he continues to breach that order. He has the right to protest in any public place but not on the private property specified in the Court Order.
This isn't about free speech or dissent. It is about where said free speech and dissent can be expressed and the right of children and teachers to receive and give an education free of disruption.
 
Yet it has long been the view of people battling unjust laws that they have a duty to break it and if necessary go to jail for doing so.
Again, what unjust law are you referring to?
He has the right to protest against what he sees as the suppression of his religious freedom (the irony in doing so seems to be lost on him), but he doesn't have the right to do so at his former place of work or disrupt the education of his former pupils.

Sure 99.999% of people won't put morality ahead of their own everyday duty to put bread on the table for their dependents and go to jail against an unjust law.
That very much depends on the law and the moral issue. I wouldn't put pronoun use in the same category as child slavery or human trafficking so, for example, I wouldn't work in Dubai or subcontract a mining operation to the DRC, but I wouldn't ruin my career because I didn't want to use a particular pronoun or, I don't know, wear a bicycle helmet.

But some will. And we have to be careful how we treat the most sensitive and high-minded of our citizens - even where we strongly disagree with them and the methods they adopt.
I don't regard religious bigotry as high mindedness.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top