Every time Enoch Burke goes before a court judge, that judge clearly feels:
(1) constrained to uphold the law;
and
(2) personally affected by the clear non-criminality of Burke - an otherwise model citizen, professional and, to borrow a phrase of Turgenev's, a thoroughly well-washed young man - and the fact that incarceration is the last place people like him should be experiencing.
I daresay so would the rest of us.
What we have here is a non-political challenge to the authority of the Irish courts. Burke isn't refusing to recognise the court, he's solely - though not insignificantly - trying to overrule it on a matter of personal conscience upon which he has strong beliefs. To my knowledge nobody has tried such a thing with the Irish courts before. Unlike the 20s, 30s, 40s, 50s and 70s, today's Irish prisoners of conscience seldom if ever go on hunger strike. I don't think we should rule such an eventuality out here.
There is a disquieting aspect to this that goes beyond the mere matter at hand in this case, i.e. the use of a neutral pronoun for addressing transgender people in a classroom. It's about the rights of people to make genuine decisions of conscience in many other matters, past, current and impending.
Would it be a no-no to suggest that all sides take a blow here ?
Would it be inappropriate that say an SC or retired (but still vigorous) judge would be asked to form a citizen's forum to discuss this kind of issue so that the High Court doesn't become a de facto battlefield for interpretation of hastily prepared regulations of the type that has Burke in prison when he should be enjoying a well-remunerated Leaving Cert exam-correction period followed by his summer vacation ?
While I strongly disapprove of what Burke is doing - and moreover his approach of it - I would like to think that the Irish state has moved on from driving its principled opponents into prison or into exile a la the 1920s. This thing needs resolution not just because it makes this country a laughing stock with the media abroad. We also need to provide time-pressed legislators with a solid and broad-consensus resource to turn to when new laws are needed to reflect changes in our society.
(1) constrained to uphold the law;
and
(2) personally affected by the clear non-criminality of Burke - an otherwise model citizen, professional and, to borrow a phrase of Turgenev's, a thoroughly well-washed young man - and the fact that incarceration is the last place people like him should be experiencing.
I daresay so would the rest of us.
What we have here is a non-political challenge to the authority of the Irish courts. Burke isn't refusing to recognise the court, he's solely - though not insignificantly - trying to overrule it on a matter of personal conscience upon which he has strong beliefs. To my knowledge nobody has tried such a thing with the Irish courts before. Unlike the 20s, 30s, 40s, 50s and 70s, today's Irish prisoners of conscience seldom if ever go on hunger strike. I don't think we should rule such an eventuality out here.
There is a disquieting aspect to this that goes beyond the mere matter at hand in this case, i.e. the use of a neutral pronoun for addressing transgender people in a classroom. It's about the rights of people to make genuine decisions of conscience in many other matters, past, current and impending.
Would it be a no-no to suggest that all sides take a blow here ?
Would it be inappropriate that say an SC or retired (but still vigorous) judge would be asked to form a citizen's forum to discuss this kind of issue so that the High Court doesn't become a de facto battlefield for interpretation of hastily prepared regulations of the type that has Burke in prison when he should be enjoying a well-remunerated Leaving Cert exam-correction period followed by his summer vacation ?
While I strongly disapprove of what Burke is doing - and moreover his approach of it - I would like to think that the Irish state has moved on from driving its principled opponents into prison or into exile a la the 1920s. This thing needs resolution not just because it makes this country a laughing stock with the media abroad. We also need to provide time-pressed legislators with a solid and broad-consensus resource to turn to when new laws are needed to reflect changes in our society.
Last edited: