Resolving The Burke Enigma . . .

Status
Not open for further replies.
If we as a society do not do this, we create martyrs of extreme dissenters and role models for those young people impressed by their sacrifice.
I agree with you there. I don't like the fact that he is in prison but he's doing all he can to put himself there.
 
The school itself handled the whole episode in an utterly cack handed manner. From start to finish. If they really wanted to put this to bed, then they could have reassigned teacher or student to another class, without fuss.

Given they didn't and went full on PC on it they then should have gone through the legal HR processes and let him stand outside the school for as long as he wanted without recourse to law. Any initial press coverage would have been mainly covered by the Westmeath Examiner or Midland Topic and dissappear after a few weeks.

Instead they once again went for the cack sack and made him into a national, if not at times, an international cause célèbre.
 
This isn't about free speech or dissent. It is about where said free speech and dissent can be expressed and the right of children and teachers to receive and give an education free of disruption

The dispute has been advancing onward and upward under this sort of mantra. The bad press Ireland is getting over it is growing. And the front line of this dispute is in the courts of Ireland - a place where it shouldn't be.

I think we all know which member of the Burke family is behind all this stuff. It's a great pity that the study of philosophy, sociology and psychology isn't freely available at least in colleges, if not in schools as it is in many South American states - in some of which countries these are core subjects. Being caught between parental obligation and common sense human relations is an awful mental place for a young adult to be. We should provide as much escape room as possible to them.
 
So he's in favour of trespassing and contempt?

I suppose Enoch would say that he's been forced to do so - in this particular case - though he'd be against such actions otherwise. But that's for him to explain.

In fact the whole Henry Kelly-like approach ("Sorry to our audience for being so outspoken but I do feel very strongly on this matter!") of all the Burkes is laden with an absence of the ethical equity. Enoch has read theology in college, it seems, so his ardour is reinforced by some lattice of dogma and he'll be harder to break.
 
The dispute has been advancing onward and upward under this sort of mantra. The bad press Ireland is getting over it is growing. And the front line of this dispute is in the courts of Ireland - a place where it shouldn't be.
I'm a big fan of freedom of speech and freedom of expression so I'm not on the side of Enoch in the matter of his contempt of Court.

I think we all know which member of the Burke family is behind all this stuff. It's a great pity that the study of philosophy, sociology and psychology isn't freely available at least in colleges, if not in schools as it is in many South American states - in some of which countries these are core subjects.
After English and quite basic Maths I think the next most important subject which should be taught in schools is critical thinking. Unfortunately I also think that most of the teachers would be unable to grasp the subject sufficiently to teach it.

Being caught between parental obligation and common sense human relations is an awful mental place for a young adult to be. We should provide as much escape room as possible to them.
The issue here is the fundamentalist religious beliefs of the Burke family. I wonder would they garner the same support from the right in this country if they were fundamentalist Muslims and their objection to pronoun use was based Koranic teachings.
 
I suppose Enoch would say that he's been forced to do so
If so he's an idiot. There's no third party here putting a gun to his head forcing him the break the law against his will.

Part of belonging to a civilised society means upholding the social contract, following the rules set by that society in order to gain from the benefits of membership. The majority of people likely disagree to varying extents with some or even many of those rules, but a democratic society offers means of putting those views forward to seek change within impinging on the rights of others.
 
Enoch has read theology in college, it seems, so his ardour is reinforced by some lattice of dogma and he'll be harder to break.
His ardour is based on religious fundamentalism, nothing as grandiose as a post-enlightenment education.
 
I have little interest in the Enoch Burke saga. The student in question probably has left the school years ago and is making an adult life for himself/herself elsewhere. Enoch Burke is still around, so are the other teachers and other school staff. This whole episode has grown way above its deserved level.

Some years ago I attended a public talk mooted by a gay and well known Cork TD. I was among the small minority of straight people in the “ loaded” audience. To the politician’s credit he hammered away at the Gay Intolerance of Transgender People. In other words he was saying that gay people should be more acceptable of another minority.

Enoch Burke like everybody else is not perfect. In my mid seventies I have never seen something so minor blown into such an undeserved huge issue. There is no country like Ireland for Sacred Cows.
 
There is no country like Ireland for Sacred Cows.
I take it you've never been it India? Any I'm not just talking the cows either... Some of the posts here would still see some of us being subjected to stoning in parts there!
 
After English and quite basic Maths I think the next most important subject which should be taught in schools is critical thinking.

I think a subject entitled Philosophy, Psychology & Sociology would cover much of what you want. I realise that such a course wouldn't offer 100% critical thinking since propositions, explanations of observed human/social behaviour would still need to be propounded and students may well prefer the speculative side of this. But defending such propositions/analyses before one's peers as well as a teacher would be the hard part and that cannot be achieved without exercising considerable - and sober - critical thinking beforehand.

A course of 100% critical thinking would elevate dodos, depressives and slackers to an academic status they'd have no claim to. I don't want to be dependent on a younger generation led by knockers of others' ideas.

Such study would also help young people understand the emotional currents underlying behaviour like Burke's. The influence of peers might be much stronger on socially intolerant behaviour than that of authorities or the older generation. I don't mean that Enochs will be swayed by the musings of nice girls or that Ammis can be sorted out by engagement with a Jimbo. I mean that the clearly expressed consensus view of peers is something none of us may easily ignore.
 
Last edited:
Ireland has spent more than a century building an industrial‑relations system designed to keep workers out of prison. From the Trade Union Acts of the 1870s through the Industrial Relations Acts of the mid‑20th century, public policy has consistently aimed to remove criminal sanctions from workplace disputes and replace them with negotiation, conciliation, and statutory mechanisms.

The Burke case represents a profound departure from that tradition. A school imposed a new condition of employment — compelled speech — that was (a) not required by any national legislation and (b) not related to the employee’s core duties as a teacher. Introducing a non‑work‑related term after employment has commenced is fundamentally at odds with established industrial‑relations norms. If compelled speech is genuinely a job requirement, it should be spelled out before hiring, not retrofitted into an existing contract.

Under any reasonable IR standard, employers should not be able to unilaterally impose new personal‑conduct obligations that fall outside the scope of the job. If the State believes compelled speech is necessary in certain circumstances, then national legislation should specify when and how such obligations arise, and what safeguards apply. That is how industrial‑relations systems normally handle new duties: through clear statutory frameworks, not ad‑hoc employer directives.

What is most troubling is the silence of the Irish Left and the trade union movement. A worker was injuncted and ultimately imprisoned for breaching an order arising from a non‑work‑related dispute — even though no crime had been committed. If employers can go to the courts to enforce new, non‑contractual conditions of employment, then no worker is safe. The entire purpose of the industrial‑relations system is to prevent exactly this kind of escalation.

This case should have been treated as an industrial‑relations problem from the outset. Instead, it became a constitutional spectacle. That is a national failure.
 
The Burke case represents a profound departure from that tradition. A school imposed a new condition of employment — compelled speech — that was (a) not required by any national legislation and (b) not related to the employee’s core duties as a teacher. Introducing a non‑work‑related term after employment has commenced is fundamentally at odds with established industrial‑relations norms. If compelled speech is genuinely a job requirement, it should be spelled out before hiring, not retrofitted into an existing contract.

Under any reasonable IR standard, employers should not be able to unilaterally impose new personal‑conduct obligations that fall outside the scope of the job. If the State believes compelled speech is necessary in certain circumstances, then national legislation should specify when and how such obligations arise, and what safeguards apply. That is how industrial‑relations systems normally handle new duties: through clear statutory frameworks, not ad‑hoc employer directives.
Burke wasn't suspended for that. He was suspended for publicly confronting the school principal in a loud and inappropriate way and then disrupted the school chapel causing pupils to walk out in protest against his actions. When a meeting was held to decide if he should be subject to a disciplinary process he refused to engage in it or present his case to the board of management of school. It is ironic that this is presented as a case of the school seeking to impose modes of speech on him whereas in reality it is Burke seeking to impose his religious beliefs on the school.

It is also ironic that we impose modes of speech every day. Pupils are required to address teachers by the name of title that the teacher prescribes. We must also address Judges in courts in a particular way.

We are not compelled to but we also address religious clerics by their title. I'm an atheist and I think all that stuff is complete nonsense but I'm not going to be rude to people for no good reason so I use their title.
Many women change their name when they get married, or even if they don't do so legally they do so in everyday speech. Some women find that degrading and a symbol of what they see as a patriarchal society but they still address those married women by their chosen name.
If I'm introduced to Billy I'm not going to start calling him William. That would be bad manners.

We all, almost without exception, address people as they wish to be addressed. Doing otherwise is bad manners.

This isn't some high minded position taken by Burke; it is intolerance, bigotry and plain bad manners born of religious fundamentalism. He wasn't suspended for his views, he was suspended because he was unwilling to accept the right of others to not hold his views and disrupted his workplace because of it.

Edit; a good overview of the case from the specialist employment law firm Crushell & Co posted here.
 
Last edited:
A course of 100% critical thinking would elevate dodos, depressives and slackers to an academic status they'd have no claim to.
If they can grasp the concept then that would elevate them beyond being dodos, many of the greatest people who have ever lived have been depressives and slackers, by their nature, don't get much done.

I don't want to be dependent on a younger generation led by knockers of others' ideas.
They could hardly be much worse then their predecessors.
 
If they can grasp the concept then that would elevate them beyond being dodos, many of the greatest people who have ever lived have been depressives and slackers, by their nature, don't get much done

The very worst of these critical thinking merchants grasp only too well the concepts developed honestly by others. Yet their understanding offers no bar to the thrill of seeking flaws in them and pointing them out with affected social concern. Ask one of these people to list one good thing about anyone else's proposal and watch their demeanour. Looking at the good side of other people's ideas is an alien thing to them.

Slackers, in a group situation, know only too well that the proposer of an idea is often on his/her own while presenting it to others. They also know how to emotionally connect with the critical thinkers while saying nothing themselves - which amplifies the sense of support for the knocker. Slackers mightn't get much good work done. But they get a helluva lot of socio-professional harm done by their silent devilment, attitudising, dirty looks and general non-verbal broadcasting.
 
The very worst of these critical thinking merchants grasp only too well the concepts developed honestly by others. Yet their understanding offers no bar to the thrill of seeking flaws in them and pointing them out with affected social concern. Ask one of these people to list one good thing about anyone else's proposal and watch their demeanour. Looking at the good side of other people's ideas is an alien thing to them.
A very useful exercise is to try to make the case for the thing you disagree with. Nobody thinks that they are the bad guy therefore attacking the character or motive of the person you are disagreeing with never furthers a discussion or changes a mind. There's a great series on YouTube called The Enemies Project. It's well worth a few minutes of anyone's time.

Slackers, in a group situation, know only too well that the proposer of an idea is often on his/her own while presenting it to others. They also know how to emotionally connect with the critical thinkers while saying nothing themselves - which amplifies the sense of support for the knocker. Slackers mightn't get much good work done. But they get a helluva lot of socio-professional harm done by their silent devilment, attitudising, dirty looks and general non-verbal broadcasting.
Ironically I think I agree with you but I'm not sure what you are saying as your scenario can be applied quite broadly.
 
Ironically I think I agree with you but I'm not sure what you are saying as your scenario can be applied quite broadly.

The scenario is a school or college class doing a Critical Thinking course.

And doing no Creative Thinking within that course.

Males and females, all going negative, all tearing the ass of each other indirectly via knocking one another's assertions.

No siree.
 
The scenario is a school or college class doing a Critical Thinking course.

And doing no Creative Thinking within that course.

Males and females, all going negative, all tearing the ass of each other indirectly via knocking one another's assertions.

No siree.

That's a very negative scenario.
Critical thinking is the use of objective analysis to evaluate an issue, idea or concept in order to form a well reasoned judgement. It is not what you assert above.

Creative thinking is a different thing altogether and is not complementary to Critical Thinking.
 
Creative thinking is a different thing altogether and is not complementary to Critical Thinking.

The point I'm making is that a course on critical thinking without integral creative thinking content - or else a parallel creative thinking course - is going to lead to the elevation of knockers to jobs - like leading management jobs - that they just won't be able to do.

You gotta have both perspectives for managing a business or even just an R&D project.

Surely be to Moses you don't believe that Irish people have an intrinsic sufficiency of creativity, do you ?

Purple, at times you leave me purple in the bloody face :oops:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top