Landlords continue to sell up - Owen Reilly Q3 2025 Report

Status
Not open for further replies.
Rebalancing that by making landlordism less attractive would be a positive.
Rebalancing so that there are more owner-occupiers than renters is a great idea and should be the aim overall. However, two things of happened:

1. The aim of taking away the ability to sell with vacant possession must be to increase the attractiveness of the PRS as a permanent tenure for people. I don't think this is a good idea. I think a smaller PRS for people who just want to rent for a couple of years is a much better idea. You buy or get social housing when you're settled. This does not appear to be the government's aim though. As large landlords must rent for life, life time tenure in the PRS must be the goal.

2. The suddeness with which this new change has come in, the lack of legislation, the fact that it keeps getting added to (now a rent register and RTB policing of market rents) has scared the life out of landlords, the older ones in particular. It seems that they are leaving enmass, so we are in danger of a sudden collapse of the PRS. Where are all the people who currently can't buy or don't want to buy to go?

More ownership, less PRS should be the aim, this is just not the way to achieve that.
 
Isn't that where we are headed with the HAP and other supports?
No, none of those supports see the state as the provider.

If the state were to become the actual provider I think I'd sell my house in the morning if I could get in and then enjoy a few years of free accommodation while they considered getting around to doing something about it.
 
aim of taking away the ability to sell with vacant possession must be to increase the attractiveness of the PRS as a permanent tenure for people. I don't think this is a good idea.

Agree - the free market over time via price signals allocates housing to its highest and best use - moving properties between the owner occupied sector and the rental sector depending on demand....price signals being the mechanism that mediates all this........the Government again meddling in the market is attempting to artificially 'trap' properties now in the rental sector. Not very clever.

Its exceptionally poor policy and will lead to the misallocation of our existing housing stock which is already in scarse supply and needs to be allocated efficiently....and I know of a no more inefficient allocator of resources than Governments.

I need to see the data fully on the anecdote that says landlords are exiting the market in droves as have seen some contradictory data on this showing RTB tenancies continue to increase YoY (could be increasing complaince versus rental stock increasing?). I would also say that Ireland's mom and pop landlord class intuitively has demographic bias towards those approaching retirement given the 2008 to present period saw banks highly reluctant to do new lending into the BTL sector lowering LTVs (i.e. increasing deposit requirements 20,25%) to a level that made it very hard for new entrants to 'get in' to the sector....so IMO there is a demographic gap of nearly two decades where younger small landlords did not come into the market in the same scale to replace the baby boomer landlord generation who we're aging out of the sector.
 
Last edited:
Rebalancing so that there are more owner-occupiers than renters is a great idea and should be the aim overall

I'm not sure this is a noble aim per se. I think the aim should be to produce a level of housing stock annually and in aggregate that is appropriate for our population. How that stock gets allocated over time rented or owned is better served by supply/demand dynamics not some top down state command and control economy from Kildare St.

The government IMO should be chiefly concerning itself with ensuring an efficient, predictable and logical legal, planning & infrastructure foundations exist at a macro level such that the private sector can react to evolving types of demand for various housing products....whether that is own door, duplex, apartments, high rise, large scale PRS etc.

don’t even understand the intended consequences never mind the unintended ones.

this is the rub.....the Government (with the exception of direct provision social housing) should 'set the table' for the housing sector (legal, planning, infrastructure) and get out of the way and let the private sector decide whats on the menu (with core building standards intact) when it comes to almost everything else. To attempt anything else IMO (which is what this government is now doing it seems) is an act of hubris.
 
Thats 4 now ive heard of this week.

Talking about this at work today and someone else said that they had been given their notice a month ago. 3 couples living in a 4 bed house share. One couple had been in it for 6 years.

The girl who was telling us this got very upset. She told us that the couple who had been there for 6 years took great pleasure in throwing the rulebook at the landlord when the landlord asked about 6 months ago that they cut the grass themselves or pay the person who the landlord already had cutting the grass and tidying up the garden and washing the windows for the last 6 years. They essentially told the landlord that they werent allowed to charge them for this service and since it was included when they moved in it had to stay, so the landlord would have to continue to pay.

I guess the landlord since they couldnt raise the rent wanted to cut back on the costs. And when they couldnt do that decided they wanted out while they still could get out. I bet the constantly changing (for the worse) legislation played no small part in that either.

The sale of a house that is shared has a huge effect on the overall rental market.

For example, when we were in a house share with 2 other couples and a single lodger friend many years ago, we moved out only because the house was sold. It ended up that we bought a 3 bed house. One of the other couples bought a 2 bed apartment. The single person ended up renting with his girlfriend after a few months of living with his parents. And the other couple rented a 1 bed apartment. When house sharers scatter it usually leads to more units being taken up after. In our case that was a 4 bed house that was sold (probably to an owner occupier because the house doesnt look rented when i pass it nowadays), but then it took 1x3 bed house, 1x2 bed apartment, 1x1 bed apartment and another apartment of i dont know how many bedrooms to house the people who were in the original house.

And I think that there is only an extremely slim chance now of a house that was rented, being sold and rented again tbh.
 
Oh what a web a Government weaves when it tries tinker and regulate at a micro level in a market as important as housing.

Its sad....only because in some respects its well intentioned....and in another respect they, the Government, are now political hostages to decisions made way back in 2016 when RPZ was first introduced into a couple of Eircodes in Dublin as a TEMPORARY measure......regulation in a democratic bureaucracy has tendency to only go one way and thats more and more over time....that its focused on housing which is an emotive political issue means that as the tentacles of regulation sneak into every aspect of the rental market the policy volatility across time and the whipsaw of successive governments with different political leanings is just going to be outrageous...given the illiquidity of owning a rental property (it takes months to complete a sale) one could very easily find themselves stuck....if the FF/FG government fell.....Mary Lou could have your rental property under a highly restrictive SF rental regime (rent freezes, insitu sales) before Sherry Fitz has done the first viewing! That measure alone....in-situ tenant sales with deeply below market tenant that now has an SF rent freeze could literally knock 30% of the value off a properties value.....guess that the SF promise in nutshell.....fixing wealth inequality by making the top poorer and the bottom no better off.
 
More evidence of landlords selling up. In Kerry this time. As well as the Loreto evictions which is what the article is about, Danny Healy-Ray says he knows of many others. What a mess for these tenants. As long term tenants, the remaining landlords will have little interest in them; just too risky.

Link is here
 
As well as the Loreto evictions which is what the article is about, Danny Healy-Ray says he knows of many others. What a mess for these tenants. As long term tenants, the remaining landlords will have little interest in them; just too risky.
I feel for the tenants, but I don't blame the landlord for getting out while they can, given the upcoming changes for large landlords. I wonder would the council try to buy the properties under the CRTIS scheme, or has that scheme run out of money now?!
 
Another example of landlords selling up. Here again it is the Fund involved in the Loreto Convent. Same issue it seems, long-term tenants at low rents and with the new rules locked into sub 2% increases, so the tenants are being evicted and the properties sold.

One of the tenants is saying he'd happily pay a higher rent to stay on, but can't. He is also saying that there are many of these types of evictions happening. That doesn't surprise me. Unless you've decided to become a charity, it is the only logical step for a landlord in this situation.

Again, what a mess.

The link is here
 
Unless you've decided to become a charity, it is the only logical step for a landlord in this situation.

I agree. This hit home to me when I saw that the rent we get for our 3 bed house is less than the ‘cost rental’ price of a one bedroom apartment offered by one of the not for profit housing agencies. Seems crazy that there is no real way out of this for landlords other than to evict and sell.
 
Seems crazy that there is no real way out of this for landlords other than to evict and sell.
If you have a long term tenant on a low rent, you've no choice but to evict and sell. You'll never get an increase beyond the 2%. The tenant will never leave of their own accord. Why would they? They are getting a bargain on the rent side and have zero responsibility for repairs or maintenance. Repainting, new furniture, broken appliances, leaks; all the normal costs associated with houses are the landlord's responsibility.
 
Hard to argue that smaller landlords aren't leaving and not being replaced.

Irish Examiner article here based on the most recent Daft Report saying that the number of properties available to let on that platform is half what it was in 2015-2019 and that was a tight enough period. The reduction is despite lots of new BTR apartment in Dublin and much more building generally.

Also begs the question where are the RTB figures coming from. From memory these showed an increase across all types of landlords. The number of tenancies apparently increased from 213k to 246k in a period of 18 months or so.
 
Also begs the question where are the RTB figures coming from.
From registered tenancies likely. Remember, Daft only reports on volume through their platform, you need to balance their figures with a changing market share.
 
From registered tenancies likely.
Yes, it is their registered tenancies, but that is still an extra 33k extra tenancies in 18 months and an additional 16k landlords in the same period, see here

The two main platforms (daft and myhome) show declines, the estate agents report declines, even Threshold etc. are reporting declines in tenancies, so I do wonder what this large RTB increase is based on
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top