Tenancy created in february 2020

RTB website today (it changes regularly):

Tenancy created before 1 March 2026:
You can end a tenancy at any time for the following 6 reasons:
  • -The tenant breached the obligations in their tenancy agreement. For example, by not paying their rent.
  • -The property is no longer suitable for the tenant’s needs. For example, it is too small.
  • -You plan to sell the property within 9 months.
  • -You or an immediate family member need to live in the property. This only applies to private landlords.
  • -You plan to carry out substantial refurbishments to the property.
  • -You plan to change the use of the property, for example to convert it into an office.
All landlords can end a tenancy that was created before 1 March 2026 for these reasons. There is no difference based on how many tenancies you have for a tenancy created before 1 March 2026.


No details there on what constitutes immediate family. Then there’s the guide:


The only guidance provided for pre Mar26 tenancies is that there’s no restriction based on landlord size. It certainly gives the impression that immediate family are only those listed.
 
One more question please, it seems if the tenant leaves my husband can put up the rent to market value but he is then tied into a 6 year lease where he can’t get the property back ..only for an immediate family member……it just seems so wrong that you can’t evict to get your property back, even to have it lie empty…..how does rtb know how legitimate the Immediate family member scenario is…..what if the immediate family member is not paying rent or their name registered on a lease …..is the TUD (which he has now) a better situation to be in …more scope to rent to a niece/nephew…..
 
One more question please, it seems if the tenant leaves my husband can put up the rent to market value but he is then tied into a 6 year lease where he can’t get the property back ..only for an immediate family member……
Yes, that is correct. Any new tenancy created by a small landlord post March is for 6 years. The landlord can only get the house back if an immediate family member (not a niece) needs the property or he has to sell because of hardship.

Rent can only be reset if the tenant leaves the pre March tenancy voluntarily.

TUD is arguably better - he can evict to sell, niece can be moved in, but the rent can't be increased except for the annual max 2%.
 
What happens if a landlord evicts to sell and changes their mind or can’t sell ?
You need to offer the house back if you don't sell it within 9 months.

If you don't then you can be fined, and the tenant may get to move back in.

If the tenant can't move back in, then there could be a second fine and compensation to the tenant.

how does rtb know how legitimate the Immediate family member scenario is

There have been cases where a former tenant has hired a private investigator.

Generally, the family member must move in, and then stay for at least 1 year.

It's not clear how much time from when the tenant leaves until the family member moves in is reasonable. If the tenant has left, but the family member isn't ready to move in, then that could cause issues.
 
if you don't sell it within 9 months.
What happens if a buyer backed out - for whatever reason - just before the contract was signed and it was six months into the sale process. Is the seller free to re-list the property even though any subsequent sale might be outside the 9 month limit? There’s all kinds of delays that can happen with selling that are out of a landlords control, buyers find other more suitable properties, lose jobs, fall ill, legal questions on the title, their own sale can fall through etc.

Or what if a buyer is serious about buying but something delays the contract signing and it’s won’t be signed until 10 months? Is the landlord supposed to tell the buyer the house is off the market as it must be re-offered to a former tenant?
 
Last edited:
The nine months runs from the expiry of the notice period or, if there is a dispute about the validity of the notice, from the date that dispute is finally determined.

You don't have to complete the sale within nine months; it's enough that you have an unconditional contract of sale within that time.

On my reading of the legislation, once you've got to the point of having an unconditional contractc of sale, you're in the clear. Even if the sale subsequently falls through and you end up suing the purchaser for non-completion and putting the property back on the market, you're in the clear.

The risk is that you have a conditional contract of sale, and then issues arise and the conditions never get satisfied or, at any rate, don't get satisfied within the 9-month period. Which means that, as the seller of a property in this situation, you might be wise to accept the slighly lower offer from the potential buyer who has the cash, isn't in a chain, etc, etc and doesn't want special conditions about this inserted into the contract over the slightly higer offer from the potential buyer who does.

(You can fairly reliably get an unconditional contract of sale by auctioning the property.)
 
That is the problem. You might have a purchaser, but no unconditional contract within 9 months. The property could be slow selling, then the purchaser's engineer spots some issues and negotiations on price re-start. You're now at the 9 month point, have to say goodbye to your purchaser and offer it back to the tenant, who can, if they want to move back in. Presumably, this will now be a 6 year contract so you've lost your sale. You won't be able to increase the rent to market because the tenant was evicted.

If you have a vacant house because the tenant has left voluntarily, and you are thinking of selling at all, you should think very seriously about a sale. It may be your last chance for a long long time. And if we end up with SF in government, say in combination with FF, you'll have a 'temporary' eviction ban which will last forever. Like rent caps, once an eviction ban comes in, it'll be impossible to remove it.
 
The bottom line here is — if you're evicting someone in order to sell your property, plan your sale strategy very carefully before the eviction. You need a strategy which offers a high prospect of a quick sale. If you know or suspect that there are issues regarding the title or condition of the property, get them sorted before you evict. Talk to your estate agent about the desirability of selling the house by auction rather than by private treaty. If selling by private treaty, talk to your solicitor about conditions that you will or won't accept in the contract. And go into the negotiations with a preference for uncomplicated buyers who ae not in chains, etc, The good price that you will actually receive is preferable to the best price that you may not receive.

Basically, these are the strategies followed by anyone who, for whatever reason, prioritises a quick sale. And a landlord who has evicted a tenant to make a sale is always going to be someone who wants at least a reasonably quick sale.
 
You're now at the 9 month point, have to say goodbye to your purchaser
Imagine being a first time buyer, you’ve had an offer accepted and all the legal searches, surveys etc drags the process out, then you’re at nine months and the seller says sorry, I can’t sign the contract as I’m legally obliged to stall this sale because a former tenant might want to move back into the property. Sounds like tenants have more rights than even people who want to buy their own home.
Landlords would be taking a huge risk if they spent time and money refurbishing a property for sale. They could find they can’t actually sell because an ex-tenant decides to move back into the updated property at the old rent.
 
Landlords would be taking a huge risk if they spent time and money refurbishing a property for sale. They could find they can’t actually sell because an ex-tenant decides to move back into the updated property at the old rent.
And presumably now on a 6 year or forever lease.

The bottom line here is — if you're evicting someone in order to sell your property, plan your sale strategy very carefully before the eviction. You need a strategy which offers a high prospect of a quick sale. If you know or suspect that there are issues regarding the title or condition of the property, get them sorted before you evict. Talk to your estate agent about the desirability of selling the house by auction rather than by private treaty. If selling by private treaty, talk to your solicitor about conditions that you will or won't accept in the contract. And go into the negotiations with a preference for uncomplicated buyers who ae not in chains, etc, The good price that you will actually receive is preferable to the best price that you may not receive.
Organisation is the key. And you are better off with a good price and a sale rather than holding out for the top possible price only to be caught by the 9 month trap.
 
Presumably, this will now be a 6 year contract so you've lost your sale.
Didn’t think about that. Does the former tenant who moves back in start a brand new tenancy? What about the first six months then, can that new tenancy be terminated before part4 rights start?
If a former tenant decides they want to move back, is there a time limit on when they have to be back in-situ?
 
Imagine being a first time buyer, you’ve had an offer accepted and all the legal searches, surveys etc drags the process out, then you’re at nine months and the seller says sorry, I can’t sign the contract as I’m legally obliged to stall this sale because a former tenant might want to move back into the property. Sounds like tenants have more rights than even people who want to buy their own home.
Landlords would be taking a huge risk if they spent time and money refurbishing a property for sale. They could find they can’t actually sell because an ex-tenant decides to move back into the updated property at the old rent.
I wonder what the 'reward' the RTB would grant to the tenant in the event that they took a dispute to the RTB for failure to offer the property back in the event it was not sold? Could be up to €20k going by the case of the 80 year old widow who didn't offer the property back when she didn't move in. I think I would take the €20k on the chin - anything is favorable compared to having to go back to being a landlord!
 
Just read that occupation after accepting an offer-back is treated as a continuation of the original tenancy so any part4 rights continue as before. S35.6(b).

So the tenant accepts the offer back within the seven days allowed, and there’s a new tenancy created but it’s under the old rules, eg, any future NoT would require the full number of days notice for total occupation.

Im trying to understand how that works in practice - is it a new post march26 tenancy agreement but not a six year TMD? So the previous rent remaining is clear, don’t understand if the contract is a TMD, how can the pre-March rules still apply?
 
Last edited:
Didn’t think about that. Does the former tenant who moves back in start a brand new tenancy? What about the first six months then, can that new tenancy be terminated before part4 rights start?
I am taking it that that is the case. It is a new tenancy starting post March 2026, the original tenancy will have been officially ended and the tenant out of the property for at least 9 months. However, for a full answer, one of the more expert posters on the legislation would need to have a look at that.
 
So the tenant accepts the offer back within the seven days allowed, and there’s a new tenancy created but it’s under the old rules, eg, any future NoT would require the full number of days notice for total occupation.
I wouldn't say that a new tenancy is created. I would have assumed that the original tenancy is revived from the dead.

The evict to sell NoT failed to mortally would the tenancy :).
 
the original tenancy will have been officially ended and the tenant out of the property for at least 9 months

Maybe the rtb would say the tenancy didn’t officially end. If the tenant has continuing rights would that mean they just pick up their old tenancy as if they never moved out at all? Say the 9 months passed on 30/09 and landlord made an offer-back on 01/10 to restart on the acceptance within the 7 days allowed, they’d be liable for rent etc from 08/10 and everything would carry on as before.
I forgot what a poster pointed out before that the lease and the tenancy are different things.
 
Back
Top