Tenancy created in february 2020

Browneyedgirl4

Registered User
Messages
88
My husband has a rental apt rented since feb 2020 for a low rent. He can only increase the rent by 2% p.a. If he wants to reset to market value will that only occur if the tenants leave voluntarily or he evicts to allow a family member to live there for 12 months ….he has a niece looking for somewhere to rent in the next few years…..
Will he have to wait until feb 2032 before he can offer her the place (i.e. at the end of a 6 year cycle…
Also, if he does offer it to his niece and she leaves after a year or two can he reset to market value then for the next tenant ?
Finding it very hard to understand the new rules.
Thanks
 
Finding it very hard to understand the new rules.
Yes it is.

If the tenants leave voluntarily he can reset to market for his next tenants. But this will be a 6 year tenancy and he won't be able to evict for occupation by his niece. You should take a look at other threads on here about the serious risks for landlords created by the new rules.

He can evict now for occupation by his niece as the current tenancy started before 1 March 2026.

Whether he can increase the rent to market after his niece moves out, I just don't know. There are some very knowledgeable posts on here, so hopefully one of those will answer that.
 
But this will be a 6 year tenancy and he won't be able to evict for occupation by his niece.
Correct, not by a niece. This is not a close enough family member.
Small landlords (1 to 3 tenancies): During a 6-Year Tenancy of Minimum Duration
If a landlord owns 1 to 3 tenancies on the day they serve a Notice of Termination, they can also end a tenancy during a 6-year Tenancy of Minimum Duration if:
  • – They need to sell the property to avoid undue financial or other hardship.
  • – The landlord or a close family member needs to live in the property. Close family means a spouse, civil partner, child, step-child, foster child, adopted child, parent, step-parent or parent-in-law only.
 
I just checked again, the tenancy commenced on the 21st March 2020……if he continues to rent to the current tenants when can he reset to market value (if at all ?)…
One last thing if the rules stay as is and one of our children wants to live in it in approx 2036 when they are 25 can he evict for that purpose ?
Personally I think he’d be better selling as very concerned by new rules…
 
I just checked again, the tenancy commenced on the 21st March 2020……if he continues to rent to the current tenants when can he reset to market value (if at all ?)…
No, he can't. For as long as this tenancy continues, he can only rent at the March 2020 rent plus max 2% pa.

One last thing if the rules stay as is and one of our children wants to live in it in approx 2036 when they are 25 can he evict for that purpose ?
Yes at the moment if the current tenancy continues and yes also if his current tenants leave and he relets as a small landlord. Based on what has happened over the last ten years, I'd say the chances of the rules being (a) the same and (b) in any way pro-landlord in 2036 are precisely nil. You've no guarantee that the child will actually want the house then either.

Personally I think he’d be better selling as very concerned by new rules…
Under the new rules, for the vast majority of landlords, the risks well outweight the only benefit - increases to market rent in limited circumstances. What you need to look at is how much he is actually making from this investment and what his yield is. If the yield is low (and it sounds like it is), that is a very clear signal to sell. It is pointless taking big risks if he'd earn nearly as much with a deposit account.
 
Correct, not by a niece. This is not a close enough family member.
Is that only relevant for TMDs?

If the tenancy started on 21st March 2020 it was in the old six year cycle system and if it wasn’t terminated at the end of the six years in March, it rolled over to an unlimited tenancy. I read on AAM that the Dept of Housing wrote to landlords saying nothing would change for existing tenancies.

As long as the current tenants are in an unlimited part4, the OP can still issue an NoT for a niece, is that right?

Edit: yes, just read greenbook (post #2) again.
 
Last edited:
And one last question. …if he evicts for his niece to live in….and she leaves after 12 months …can he put the rent up to market value for the new tenant?
 
Also, if he does offer it to his niece and she leaves after a year or two can he reset to market value then for the next tenant ?

You can always reset to market if you don't rent it for 2 years. The tenant must actually have left though, or the tenancy continues, even if no rent is being paid.

It depend on if the niece is a tenant. If it is a tenancy, then it maintains the rent setting.

Having said that if the niece leaves voluntarily, then he can reset either way. Either she is a tenant and left voluntarily, or she wasn't a tenant, so the there was no tenancy for 2 years.

However, she would have the right not to leave without following the whole process if she is officially a tenant.

As long as the current tenants are in an unlimited part4, the OP can still issue an NoT for a niece, is that right?

Yes, tenancies from before March still have the option to evict for niece move-in.

Once a tenancy is started after March, the new rules apply.

New tenancies only allow that at the end of the 6 year cycle. During the cycle, it is only for direct immediate family.

And one last question. …if he evicts for his niece to live in….and she leaves after 12 months …can he put the rent up to market value for the new tenant?

Again it depends if the niece is a tenant, or not.

A tenancy is created when you create a landlord / tenant relationship. It doesn't matter if a lease is signed, or there is some agreement made in advance. It is enough that it has the features of a tenancy.

If you have a house and you give it to someone and then they pay you for the privilege, then it could very well be deemed a tenancy.

The main exception is if you also live in the house. In that case, it is a paid lodger situation (formally a licensee).

Would the niece be renting? The tenancy will mostly appear as soon as he hands over the keys and accepts rent.

The current tenancy would end when the current tenant moves out. The rent setting still remains in place for 2 years, even with no tenancy.

If a new tenancy is started during that period, it inherits the rent setting.

On the other hand, if there is no tenancy for 2 years, then the previous rent setting expires. A new tenancy would be unencumbered from the previous rent setting.
 
Yes, tenancies from before March still have the option to evict for niece move-in.

@Greenbook @bipped @LarryScott Are you sure about this? The original March 2020 tenancy would have become a TUD in March 2026. (And for clarity, it does not become a TMD as per new laws introduced in March.)

As far as I can see, the rules pertaining to a TUD mean that the current tenants can be put out only for an immediate family member, which as I understood it does not include a niece. I did not yet succeed to find an explicit statement of this however.

https://www.citizensinformation.ie/...rights-and-responsibilities/types-of-tenancy/ has a pretty good summary. It fully defines "immediate family" only in the section about TMD, however.

Valid reasons for ending a tenancy of unlimited duration​

A landlord can only end a tenancy of unlimited duration after the first 6 months if:

  • The tenant is not meeting their obligations, such as paying the rent
  • The property is no longer suited to your needs, for example, if it is too small
  • The landlord intends to sell the property within 9 months
  • The landlord needs the property for their own use or for an immediate family member
  • The landlord plans to change the use of the property (for example, convert it from residential use to office use)
  • The landlord intends to refurbish the property substantially
 
@Greenbook @bipped @LarryScott Are you sure about this? The original March 2020 tenancy would have become a TUD in March 2026. (And for clarity, it does not become a TMD as per new laws introduced in March.)
My understanding was that the old rules continued to apply in all respects to pre-March tenancies, so the niece/nephew eviction rule remained.

Citizens Advice are usually very accurate though - just shows what a morass this has become.
 
And one last question. …if he evicts for his niece to live in….and she leaves after 12 months …can he put the rent up to market value for the new tenant?
Which many of us on these types of thread are landlords, you really need to make sure you are certain of the particular rules that apply to you. Ideally by asking the RTB in writing.
 
Ideally by asking the RTB in writing.
From what I've heard of the RTB though, they either won't answer you at all, will tell you to get legal advice, will give you a wrong answer or if you ask twice will give you two different answers.
 
From what I've heard of the RTB though, they either won't answer you at all, will tell you to get legal advice, will give you a wrong answer or if you ask twice will give you two different answers.
:oops:

Yep, all true. That's the 'service' they give to us landlords who pay for them ! I'd just ask on here, the RTB and the IPOA and then take a wild guess that I'd be getting it right !!
 
Yep, all true. That's the 'service' they give to us landlords who pay for them ! I'd just ask on here, the RTB and the IPOA and then take a wild guess that I'd be getting it right !!
Yes, they provide a terrible service to us landlords alright.

And ultimately all we can do sometimes is take our best guess as the rules are so complicated. Unfortunately, guessing wrong can result in criminal prosecution and compensation payments to tenants! A wonderful situation to be in.
 
My understanding was that the old rules continued to apply in all respects to pre-March tenancies, so the niece/nephew eviction rule remained
I'm not able to find this niece/nephew exception documented. Can you help locate it?
 
Here it is, in S.34(4) of the Consolidated Act. The first part refers to pre-March tenancies

F147[(4) In paragraph 4 of the Table the reference to a member of the landlord’s family is a reference to—

(a) subject to paragraph (b), any spouse, civil partner within the meaning of the Civil Partnership and Certain Rights and Obligations of Cohabitants Act 2010, child, stepchild, foster child, grandchild, parent, grandparent, step parent, parent-in-law, brother, sister, nephew or niece of the landlord or a person adopted by the landlord under the Adoption Acts 2010 to 2015, or

(b) where the notice of termination is served in respect of a relevant Part 4 tenancy (within the meaning of section 35B) and the termination date specified in the notice of termination falls before the expiry of a tenancy of minimum duration under the relevant Part 4 tenancy, any spouse, civil partner within the meaning of the Civil Partnership and Certain Rights and Obligations of Cohabitants Act 2010, child, stepchild, foster child, parent, step parent, parent-in-law of the landlord or a person adopted by the landlord under the Adoption Acts 2010 to 2015.]
 
@Greenbook @bipped @LarryScott Are you sure about this? The original March 2020 tenancy would have become a TUD in March 2026. (And for clarity, it does not become a TMD as per new laws introduced in March.)

Fair enough, that is still up for debate. It is a risk for those with pre-22 tenancies that haven't reached the end of the 6 year cycle.

I think the conclusion when it was discussed was that the latest law explicitly says that pre-June 2022 tenancies update to post-June 2022 tenancies, once the 6 years end. This was not changed in March.

This means that tenancies of fixed duration (pre-22 version) should become tenancies of unlimited duration (22-26 version).

Since they didn't add a similar clause for the tenancies of minimum duration (post-26 version), there is no automatic upgrade of the pre-22 to the post-26. Thus, they would update to the 22-26 version.

This would be consistent with statements made that there was no change for any pre-26 tenancies. Again, who knows.
 
This would be consistent with statements made that there was no change for any pre-26 tenancies. Again, who knows.
Thanks very much for that.

So, as far as we can make out, the OP's husband can evict the current tenants on the basis that his niece will be staying in the property.

It is so unsatisfactory, yet again, this is what we think, but we are not 100% sure.
 
Apologies - don’t know how to link to a post in an old thread, but the first post in this thread had the text of the information sent to landlords from the Department. It clearly says no changes to ending a pre-March tenancy.


Surely the department of housing wouldn’t bother putting that in writing if it wasn’t true? Would they not just ignore the changes and let landlords find out from the rtb?
 
Last edited:
Surely the department of housing wouldn’t bother putting that in writing if it wasn’t true?
It certainly looks like you can still evict for occupation by a niece with a pre-22 tenancy which then became a tenancy of unlimited duration.

I think @LarryScott's point is that the rules are so complicated and so nit-picky that it is hard to be 100% certain with very detailed questions like this. Between the move from the pre-22 six year to the tenancy of unlimited duration after 6 years and now the new rules, there could be some subsection somewhere or some interaction between two sections somewhere which means that this ground no longer exists in certain circumstances.
 
Back
Top