Setting up exec only ARF

NoseyB

Registered User
Messages
28
Very little knowledge on finance but want to set up a type of ‘set and forget’ ARF. I dont want an annuity. Currently my PRB (roughly 500k) is made up of all Vanguard funds and im thinking of just following the same set up if possible. Its divided into an 80/20 split: vanguard global bond index 13%; vanguard inflation linked diversified bond 6%; vanguard European stock index 8%; vanguard global stock index 56%; vanguard global small cap index 8%; vanguard emerging markets stock index 8%; cash 1%. I have no interest in following markets and intend on taking 5% per annum in income to add to my full state pension when i reach 66 in October. I have an emergency fund outside of this of 30k. Looking for advice as to whether this a good diversified approach - or is it too many funds which will carry a cost for each?
 
Personally I think that you're over complicating things and maybe even eroding diversification with so many funds. I basically stick with one - Royal London Ireland BlackRock MSCI World Index passive index tracker - while early retired but I have other non-pension assets that means that I'm comfortable with any possible volatility resulting from such an all equity approach. It might not suit everyone.

Aren't you going to take a tax free lump sum of €500K x 25% = €125K?

You might want to check out some of the usual execution only brokers that are often suggested here:
 
Last edited:
Looks a reasonable set up to me.

A lot of advisers would regard the portfolio as a bit equity heavy when in drawdown but ultimately that’s your call.

The ratio of small caps and emerging markets looks fine.

There’s obviously a bit of overlap between the european fund and the global stock fund but nothing to be overly concerned about.
 
A lot of advisers would regard the portfolio as a bit equity heavy
I wouldn't. But I think there's too many funds. I'd go All Country if he wanted emerging markets but for the last decade it is just higher fees for lower return. I'd have one bond fund and I'd forget about 1% in cash. There's never any point in investing 1% in anything...unless you're talking massive numbers.

I'm always very cautious when I read "Very little knowledge on finance" but want to DIY it...
 
I'm always very cautious when I read "Very little knowledge on finance" but want to DIY it...
I understand but because the pot is relatively small I want to keep it simple and as cheap as possible and essentially I’m using the forum for free advice from those who have more experience.
I'd have one bond fund and I'd forget about 1% in cash.
I’m inclined to agree - I’m just following what was originally advised when setting up the BOB.

Initially I thought I should confine my choices to four funds: a global world index equity fund; a European equities index fund; a global world index bond fund and a cash fund included in the ARF - to draw from in bad downturn years (if that makes sense).

Aren't you going to take a tax free lump sum of €500K x 25% = €125K?
Yes I intend to take a lump sum although not sure yet if I take the whole 25%. Probably will but don’t need all that - I live a fairly frugal life and have no expensive hobbies or loans.

Thanks to all for recommendations re execution only brokers and will reach out when I know a little more as I don’t want to waste anybody’s time.
 
Yes I intend to take a lump sum although not sure yet if I take the whole 25%.
It usually doesn't make sense not to take the full tax free amount. If you don't need all of it then you can just reinvest what you don't need in non-pension assets.
 
the pot is relatively small I want to keep it simple and as cheap as possible and essentially I’m using the forum for free advice from those who have more experience.
€375,000 isn't small. If you are comfortable with DIY, go for it. But you may not get free advice all the time and even the most capable of people on this forum don't know all the ins and outs of the murky world of personal finance.
I’m inclined to agree - I’m just following what was originally advised when setting up the BOB.

Initially I thought I should confine my choices to four funds: a global world index equity fund; a European equities index fund; a global world index bond fund and a cash fund included in the ARF - to draw from in bad downturn years (if that makes sense).
I have seen investment splits of 49.2% and 50.8%. How or why an advisor thought going 50/50 wasn't quite cutting it and they needed to split it by fractions is beyond me.

MSCI, FTSE et all do a pretty good job of designing equity portfolios that represent the global stock market. And they do it for you relatively cheaply. Go with their expertise. Have an equity fund, a bond fund and a cash fund for withdrawals (check with the provider to make sure you can just take money out of the cash fund).
 
Have an equity fund, a bond fund and a cash fund for withdrawals (check with the provider to make sure you can just take money out of the cash fund).
I was adding the European index fund to exclude ‘flavour-of-month’ stocks (such as SpaceX or other ‘very new’ stocks) added to my feeling that European stock index may compensate for some of the ‘rash’ decisions in the US. Does this make sense or am I again over complicating things?

Currently I’m drawn towards a Royal London execution only ARF using Blackrock passive index funds. Bearing in mind my goal is a type of set n forget approach, I’m a bit confused as to how the cash can be used for withdrawal: eg if I put 60k in that fund do I have to top it up each year or is that part of the set-up process automatically?
 
to exclude ‘flavour-of-month’ stocks (such as SpaceX or other ‘very new’ stocks)
Each index has rules around companies being eligible to be included in the index...which were bent to allow SpaceX in, with the exception of S&P. Even still, SpaceX will have a small holding.

I'm always very cautious when I read "Very little knowledge on finance" but want to DIY it...
BTW, I'm sticking with this statement...
 
Currently I’m drawn towards a Royal London execution only ARF using Blackrock passive index funds. Bearing in mind my goal is a type of set n forget approach, I’m a bit confused as to how the cash can be used for withdrawal: eg if I put 60k in that fund do I have to top it up each year or is that part of the set-up process automatically?

You make your fund choices at the start and allocate whatever percentage of the overall fund you want to the cash fund. You also instruct Royal London on the application form to take your withdrawals only from the cash fund. (Not all ARF providers have that ability.) After a few years when your cash fund has run out, then you instruct Royal London to move another amount from one or more of the other funds choices into the cash fund.
 
instruct Royal London on the application form to take your withdrawals only from the cash fund. (Not all ARF providers have that ability.)
Could you share which of the main providers do not have this very basic option/ability?
 
Off the top of my head, Standard Life don't have it for monthly income withdrawals. They can accommodate it for annual and ad-hoc withdrawals. I'm told that they're working on upgrading their system to make this functionality available but I don't know when it will be. I think there were others, but it's been a while since I checked so they may have improved since last I did.
 
Each index has rules around companies being eligible to be included in the index...which were bent to allow SpaceX in, with the exception of S&P. Even still, SpaceX will have a small holding.
I gather Steven, you do not think a separate fund for Euro stock index makes sense - so still stick with an equity index, a bond index and a cash buffer?
if you do take a tax-free lump sum (which almost always makes sense) and you keep it on deposit, you need to maintain a higher allocation to equities in your ARF to achieve your desired (overall) asset allocation.
Thanks for that Sarenco - all advice is greatly appreciated and going back over your posts and others’ I’m finding this forum fantastic for educating someone like me.

to take your withdrawals only from the cash fund. (Not all ARF providers have that ability.)
Again, thanks for the info - I assumed all would have this facility.

The more I read, the more indecision! I guess that’s the problem with adopting a DIY approach as pointed out by Steven Barrett.
Having thought Royal London Ireland was for me, I’m now back to looking at Standard Life and taking the advice to go three funds:
  • 72% – Vanguard Global Stock Index
  • 18% – Vanguard Euro Corporate Bond Index Fund
  • 10% – Standard Life Cash Fund
Any thoughts on this approach?
 
Any thoughts on this approach?
What's the rationale for this split?
Have you checked the documentation on these funds to see if there's much overlap?
As I said before splitting between different funds can actually erode rather than increase diversification.

What age are you? Does this mean that you're 65?
intend on taking 5% per annum in income to add to my full state pension when i reach 66 in October.
Also, it would be useful to know about your overall, including non-pension, savings/investments/assets and circumstances. The sort of thing that a Money Makeover would provide for example.
For example if you have significant non-pension assets (even before taking any tax free lump sum) then that gives you more scope for taking on more potential risk/volatility such as an all equity approach might involve.
 
Last edited:
Well, I wouldn’t opt for a corporate bond fund - much higher correlation to equities than a government bond fund.

It’s difficult to advise from this remove without knowing your full circumstances.

But, assuming (a) you are in your 60’s; and (b) your pension represents substantially all of your liquid assets, then, in your shoes, I would:

(a) take the 25% tax-free lump sum. Keep a couple of years of projected expenses in an instant access account and deposit the rest in a decent 2-year fixed-term deposit account;

(b) invest 85% of the ARF in a global equity index fund and 15% in a euro government bond index fund.

That gives you a traditional 60/40 split of equities/fixed interest instruments.

There are any number of variations on the above that are entirely reasonable but try to keep things as simple as possible.
 
Back
Top