Schools, what level of risk do they pose?

C

Clamball

Registered User
Messages
820
I am wondering what everyone else thinks.

With 5K cases a day and out of control spread of the virus, are schools a safe area where the virus won’t spread or is it a high risk activity.

I personally think that public health always closed schools before because it was a place where people congregated and keeping people home stopped disease spread. But suddenly in 2020 they realised this created other issues because parents can’t work if the kids are not in school. Obviously in other centuries mothers were always home. And with Covid the risk of serious illness and death increases with age, so if kids get sick there is less risk of serious illness and if the grandparents are not called in for childcare there is less chance of them catching Covid.


But as far as I understand the kids still catch Covid at the same rate as other age groups so the risk of spread is identical? So 30 kids in a classroom with an SNA and a teacher, compared to 30 over 80’s in a carehome with 2 care assistants. If one is Covid + is there less risk of spread in the classroom compared to the care home? My view is the risk of spread is higher in the classroom because small kids are poorer at following rules and they are together, closer, for 6 hours, whereas in the care home they can move from their bedrooms to living areas to dining areas but are together 24 hr a day.

The outcomes are more serious for the care home with risk of death being significantly higher, but is the risk of catching Covid the same as the classroom.

And the other thing that worries me is that the 30 kids and teacher and SNA go home and spread the virus to 32 more families.

If I was the decision maker I would ask most kids learn remotely, but allow kids of frontline workers or deprived kids still come to school.

I realise none of us are public health experts but what do people think?
 
Clamball said:
because small kids are poorer at following rules
Click to expand...

Social distancing within classrooms hasn't really worked because they play in the yard together. What has worked is keeping classes away from eachother.

Clamball said:
If I was the decision maker I would ask most kids learn remotely, but allow kids of frontline workers or deprived kids still come to school.
Click to expand...

I can't see how that would work..... teacher in the classroom teaching can't do remote teaching at the same time. To me, it's all in school or all stay at home.
 
Kids immune systems are so aggressive they fight off covid very quickly. Chances are by the time you test them they have already expelled the virus from their system and will fail a PCR test (source Professor Luke O'Neill). The problem is that there may still be a narrow window of time in which they can infect parents... who can then infect grandparents... So I don't think our contact tracing is really picking up the impact of schools being open.
With schools open can you really have a proper 'lockdown' in terms of restricting movements with so many people getting to and from school on a daily basis... Nope.

Against this, I remember when the schools were closed in Spring secondary school kids were just out and about in shopping centers, congregating in parks etc And then as OP notes younger kids might be left with older relatives while parents work.

So I can see why some countries have closed schools and some have kept them open.

I think right now as we have had a natural break from Christmas and cases are on the increase, schools should be kept closed for a longer period until the Level 5 restrictions start to kick in. Sending kids back to schools will mean huge increase in contacts. Keeping the schools closed and in theory the kids should only be seeing the same people they saw over the last 2 weeks.
 
Why not simply close the schools for January and open them for a month longer during the summer?

We are going to have a terrible January, but after that, things are going to get better month by month with the roll out of the vaccine.

There is a much better chance that we can have a proper Leaving Cert in July than in June.

Brendan
 
Brendan Burgess said:
Why not simply close the schools for January and open them for a month longer during the summer?

We are going to have a terrible January, but after that, things are going to get better month by month with the roll out of the vaccine.

There is a much better chance that we can have a proper Leaving Cert in July than in June.

Brendan
Click to expand...
That sounds reasonable and logical. It won't happen.
 
Brendan Burgess said:
Why not simply close the schools for January and open them for a month longer during the summer?

We are going to have a terrible January, but after that, things are going to get better month by month with the roll out of the vaccine.

There is a much better chance that we can have a proper Leaving Cert in July than in June.

Brendan
Click to expand...
I think some form of this is likely. They can cancel the two mid term breaks and reduce the Easter break to gain back some time as well.
 
PaddyBloggit said:
Social distancing within classrooms hasn't really worked because they play in the yard together.
Click to expand...
I don't know how you can be so sure about that Paddy. They are in the classroom for 5 hours a day but play for 40 minutes. One is indoors and one outdoors; possibly a big difference.
 
Schools closing in England and Scotland...
To paraphrase Boris they are not high risk but can be vectors when there is high community transmission.
 
Cricketer said:
I don't know how you can be so sure about that Paddy. They are in the classroom for 5 hours a day but play for 40 minutes. One is indoors and one outdoors; possibly a big difference.
Click to expand...

I am sure based on my experience since September. It's impossible to keep the children away from each other. They forget, both inside and outside of the classroom.

Even some of the children pretended to sanitise their hands if they could get away with it.

Though my class were in pods of 2, in reality they all got mixed up. Going out to the yard, coming in, they forgot to social distance.

I have windows open but even with distancing of tables from each other, they are not 2m or even 1m apart if they turn around to each other, which is what they did.

Our lunch breaks were split so that there were less pupils in the yard, so the classes were inside for half of the big break.... policing distancing where they turned to face each other was almost impossible.

In the yard, balls and other equipment were banned so they started playing running/chasing games. This generated heat, sweat, fast breath etc. and these games all seemed to end with them all congregating together.

Keeping children apart in a school setting is only in name. Practically it's very hard to enforce.

Bottom line is children forget, both inside and outside the classroom.

What I was trying to say in my last post (albeit badly) is that social distancing within specific classes didn't work but did between different classes.
 
PaddyBloggit said:
I am sure based on my experience since September. It's impossible to keep the children away from each other. They forget, both inside and outside of the classroom.

Even some of the children pretended to sanitise their hands if they could get away with it.

Though my class were in pods of 2, in reality they all got mixed up. Going out to the yard, coming in, they forgot to social distance.

I have windows open but even with distancing of tables from each other, they are not 2m or even 1m apart if they turn around to each other, which is what they did.

Our lunch breaks were split so that there were less pupils in the yard, so the classes were inside for half of the big break.... policing distancing where they turned to face each other was almost impossible.

In the yard, balls and other equipment were banned so they started playing running/chasing games. This generated heat, sweat, fast breath etc. and these games all seemed to end with them all congregating together.

Keeping children apart in a school setting is only in name. Practically it's very hard to enforce.

Bottom line is children forget, both inside and outside the classroom.

What I was trying to say in my last post (albeit badly) is that social distancing within specific classes didn't work but did between different classes.
Click to expand...
How many cases of Covid19 were there among the children in you class/school?
 
Within my class, two that I know of (informed by parents).

I was never contacted by the HSE but I was a close contact according to my doctor.

I had to sort my own covid test. Came back negative. (I wear both a mask and a visor)

Within the school, don't know. We aren't told.

GDPR etc. makes it all hush hush.
 
PaddyBloggit said:
Within my class, two that I know of (informed by parents).
Click to expand...
Did they infect anyone else or did they get it at home?

PaddyBloggit said:
I was never contacted by the HSE but I was a close contact according to my doctor.

I had to sort my own covid test. Came back negative. (I wear both a mask and a visor)
Click to expand...
Children are far less likely than adults to infect others.

PaddyBloggit said:
Within the school, don't know. We aren't told.

GDPR etc. makes it all hush hush.
Click to expand...
No it doesn't. GDPR is about personal data. Stating total numbers of cases doesn't breach it.
 
I have no hard figures available, but from listening to radio reports and newspaper articles and a few contributions from trade union spokespeople our schools have the potential to be hotbeds of infection. Please convince me otherwise.

1. I hear of children being sent to school while sporting the symptoms of Covid. [Get them out of the house; damn the consequences]
2. Some months ago school principals couldn't get a contactable telephone number of some responsible person in the HSE. [Since rectified]
3. Students are being sent to school while their parents are awaiting the result of Covid tests. [Don't tell anybody syndrome]
4. Children have failed to keep safe distances in playgrounds. They meet after school too and often congregate in groups. [Children have a better immune system than adults but they can infect adults pretty fast]
5. Everybody working within the school systems at a higher risk than most others without. [My opinion]
6. The Track and Trace capability has all but died miserably. [Not a moral boost for school workers]
7. The initial supplies of hand sanitisers supplied to schools were found to have some adverse effect on users. [Wait for the litigation procedures to kick in later]
8. I understand school principals are governed by GDPR. [Does this mean they cannot identify those infected with Covid?]

. . . . . . . on the other hand . . . . . . . .
I see school going kids sanitising their hands properly entering shopping centres (rubbing the sanitiser liquid over all fingers above and below and even into the fingernails plus their wrists. Most of us adults who walk past the sanitisers could learn from the kids. Keeping schools open before February is irresponsible.
 
Purple said:
Did they infect anyone else or did they get it at home?
Click to expand...

I don't know. Teachers are kept out of the loop.

Purple said:
Children are far less likely than adults to infect others.
Click to expand...

To be fair, I kept my distance the best way I could. I washed hands often.

I wore a mask and visor but got lackadaisical after awhile and only used the mask.

We, initially, collected books, let lie for 2 days, before we touched them. That wasn't overly practical from my side so I collected, corrected and washed hands.

Purple said:
No it doesn't. GDPR is about personal data. Stating total numbers of cases doesn't breach it.
Click to expand...

Oh I know that but when gdpr is thrown at you as a reason to shut down an enquiry... it's a handy thing to fall back on.

"No we can't... gdpr and all that."

The one thing I have noticed since the children started washing their hands and sanitising more frequently is that absences are down and the sniffles have gone silent.
 
Leper said:
1. I hear of children being sent to school while sporting the symptoms of Covid. [Get them out of the house; damn the consequences]
2. Some months ago school principals couldn't get a contactable telephone number of some responsible person in the HSE. [Since rectified]
3. Students are being sent to school while their parents are awaiting the result of Covid tests. [Don't tell anybody syndrome]
4. Children have failed to keep safe distances in playgrounds. They meet after school too and often congregate in groups. [Children have a better immune system than adults but they can infect adults pretty fast]
5. Everybody working within the school systems at a higher risk than most others without. [My opinion]
6. The Track and Trace capability has all but died miserably. [Not a moral boost for school workers]
7. The initial supplies of hand sanitisers supplied to schools were found to have some adverse effect on users. [Wait for the litigation procedures to kick in later]
8. I understand school principals are governed by GDPR. [Does this mean they cannot identify those infected with Covid?]

. . . . . . . on the other hand . . . . . . . .
I see school going kids sanitising their hands properly entering shopping centres (rubbing the sanitiser liquid over all fingers above and below and even into the fingernails plus their wrists. Most of us adults who walk past the sanitisers could learn from the kids. Keeping schools open before February is irresponsible.
Click to expand...

1. Hard to tell
2. Correct
3. We've had a few kept at home while adults waited for test results.
4. Some of ours attended training where social distancing wasn't observed.
5. TBH, even with the cases in my classroom, I felt as safe as I ever was and I'd much prefer to be in the classroom teaching than at home online.
6. It didn't seem to work too well from the start.
7. I reckon those who were affected will get over it. Although saying that, I always go to wash my hands over sanitising. Who knows what the long term effects are from continual sanitisation.
8. Individuals with the virus cannot be indentified in any shape or form.

Re, keeping schools open. I think we should stay closed until February 1st. A full three weeks. That means I can also plan properly for online tuition.
 
Last edited:
What class were you teaching Paddy? Obviously distancing doesn't work too well up to the end of 2nd or so. Pods of 2? How many were in your class? You've either a small number or a very big classroom; wouldn't four pods of 6 or six pods of 4 be more manageable than twelve pods of 2 etc? Children mixing coming in and out of the building would be casual contacts and supervising them should mitigate that. I realise it depends on your clientele. There's a lot of certainty here from both yourself and Purple. I think we could all dial down the certainty a little, it's still a new virus after all.

Re. closing for January - I agree. Though it's hard to imagine it's going to be an easy decision to reopen towards the end of the month when dozens of deaths may be being recorded each day.
 
Cricketer said:
I think we could all dial down the certainty a little, it's still a new virus after all.
Click to expand...
I think facts and detail is what we need now. There's more than enough fear going around.

The median age of those who are dying from this is well into the 80's and most of them have serious preexisting conditions. We need to look at hospitalisation and ICU figures and the age breakdown of those who are getting infected. The graph of those in at-risk groups is more important that the total case numbers, although I fully understand that the two are linked, as the issue is whether or not our hospital system will become overloaded.

If we are talking about opening or closing schools what we really need is the R Number for Primary School children and the R Number for Secondary School children. There is a much stronger case for keeping secondary schools closed than primary schools; secondary school students are much better able to work from home and are also more likely to catch Covid, spread Covid and suffer stronger symptoms of Covid than primary school kids.
When this started we had no choice to use blunt instruments. In the past 9 months we've had more than enough time to sharpen them up.
 
No official announcement yet but RTE are reporting that Taoiseach Micheál Martin has confirmed the Government is "looking at school closures being extended to the end of the month"
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top