RTE 1 Documentary: "Trackers: The People vs. the Banks"

“It was more reality TV than documentary”.

That sums it up very well.

The whole issue deserved to be treated with far more journalistic rigour.
 
The CBI said while they could not intervene with this issue they asked our permission to highlight this in their examination. In our eyes the Bank were once again not playing fair, hiding the truth.

I tried in the recordings highlighting the issues around the appeal being far from impartial but I suppose they are limited by time when airing. The Central Bank refused to intervene on the appeals escalation & FSPO said it was beyond their remit.

The Central Bank appear to have handled this correctly. It is not their role to interfere with individual complaints but they use such complaints to guide their investigations.

And the Ombudsman only gets involved after the internal appeals process has been exhausted.

I'd to pull my FSPO complaint, ordered by the Bank to do so.

I don't understand what you mean? They cannot "order" a customer to pull their complaint.

They can make you a settlement offer in full and final settlement of your complaint. You are free to accept that and withdraw your complaint or reject it and proceed with your complaint.
 
@Brendan the story told on our case was only the touch of the iceberg.

After the appeal ruling the panel advised to complain to the Ombudsman if not satisfied.

Just before this appeal ruling, an offer to secure the home through MTRS (Mortgage to Rent Scheme) through a PIP / ICare was agreed. We'd already signed 2 surrender of ownership through MTRS before the appeal was submitted.

We were not happy with the process, nor the Bank behaviors during the appeal in withholding information etc and so we made a complaint as advised by the panel.

Then the Ombudsman's office informed up the appeal process was beyond their remit.

During the short time of when we did complain we soon received a call to say the MTRS of security in our home was gone unless we retracted the complaint and so we'd no other option but to pull the complaint, for the sake of securing our home.

I hope this makes things a little clearer.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
No, it does not make it clear at all. I will try to guess:

The Bank of Ireland agreed to sell the home to iCare under the Mortgage to Rent Scheme.
But as a condition, they wanted you to pull your complaint to the Ombudsman.

That seems reasonable to me. By selling your home to iCare, you got a huge write down of your mortgage. You wanted that and further compensation for losing your tracker?

It is reasonable to look at the entire package.
 
I’ll have to agree to disagree on this one Brendan.

For families who had paid the agreed amount but were not given their tracker when due. Suffered extreme mistreatment by KBC for almost 10 years, some awards did not reflect the damage people incurred. Like how can you put a cost on a life lost?

As an example this was once we were eventually told we were impacted. That month alone €1473 was overcharged.

IMG_6260.webp
 
Hi Babóg

There is no problem at all in disagreeing with me, or correcting me. It happens all the time. :)

You haven't explained the full story clearly, so I am filling in the gaps .

You mentioned that you did an "MTRS" without explaining what that was. So I am guessing it was a Mortgage to Rent Scheme and edited your post accordingly.

I have been involved in a lot of tracker cases. I have been involved in a lot of arrears cases. And I have been involved in a lot of cases combining both.

Case A
Arrears: €40k
Tracker overcharge: €60k.
These people would not have been in arrears had they been charged the right amount and deserve serious compensation.

Case B
Arrears: €200k
Tracker overcharge: €80k

These people would have been in serious arrears even if they had never lost their tracker.

Case C
Arrears: €200k
Tracker overcharge: €80k
House sold leaving the bank with a shortfall of €300k

These guys did very well. They would have had an unsustainable mortgage even if they had a tracker.
They were overcharged by €80k
They got a write off of €220k
And they got compensation for losing their home.

And they continue living in their original home at the expense of the taxpayer.

I am sorry for them that they lost their home, but they lost it because of their income crashing and not because they lost their tracker.

I can't tell from the information you provided, which case you most closely resembled.
But if your home was sold to iCare, you must have been in very serious arrears - well in excess of the tracker overcharge.
And you must have been in deep negative equity.
 
Last edited:
I watched the second programme and @Brendan Burgess was brilliant at getting the key points across in a clear manner.

But after that I gave up.

I just can’t stand programming that deliberately leaves out keys things like dates and amounts and puts in close-ups of tears and teacups instead.
 
Back
Top