Brendan Burgess
Founder
- Messages
- 58,598
Some other observations.
The Judge said it was odd that neither Thomas Ryan nor his solicitor requested a copy of the tape recording when dealing with the Ombudsman. Especially as ptsb had given a detailed account of what had been said 18 months earlier.
A technical point - The Ombudsman asked ptsb to provide such information as ptsb considered relevant. The judge said it was the Ombudsman's role to decide what was relevant.
The Judge was very critical of ptsb for not disclosing the tape recording and was astounded at ptsb's claim that they did not have any duty of care to disclose this crucial bit of evidence.
The Judge said it was odd that neither Thomas Ryan nor his solicitor requested a copy of the tape recording when dealing with the Ombudsman. Especially as ptsb had given a detailed account of what had been said 18 months earlier.
A technical point - The Ombudsman asked ptsb to provide such information as ptsb considered relevant. The judge said it was the Ombudsman's role to decide what was relevant.
The Judge was very critical of ptsb for not disclosing the tape recording and was astounded at ptsb's claim that they did not have any duty of care to disclose this crucial bit of evidence.