RTE 1 Documentary: "Trackers: The People vs. the Banks"

Some other observations.

The Judge said it was odd that neither Thomas Ryan nor his solicitor requested a copy of the tape recording when dealing with the Ombudsman. Especially as ptsb had given a detailed account of what had been said 18 months earlier.

A technical point - The Ombudsman asked ptsb to provide such information as ptsb considered relevant. The judge said it was the Ombudsman's role to decide what was relevant.

The Judge was very critical of ptsb for not disclosing the tape recording and was astounded at ptsb's claim that they did not have any duty of care to disclose this crucial bit of evidence.
 
It's important to realise that the Judge does not hear the case from the start. He just decided that there was new information which might affect the Ombudsman's decision had it been known at the time, and sent it back to the Ombudsman to hear again.

July 2015 - ptsb launches review of all tracker cases and so all ptsb cases before the Ombudsman are put on hold.
You have not really answered my questions:
Ok, so it now seems like the judge didn't find in the Ryans favour but, because of new evidence (i.e. the phone conversation transcript), sent it back for a new ruling by the Ombudsman. That was in 2011. If it was as cut-and-dried as a phone call transcript, supporting what the Ryans claimed they were told, then why didn't the Ombudsman change it's ruling in the time between the HC decision in 2011 and the PTSB review of all it's Tracker cases in 2015? Four years for the Ombudsman to change it's opinion on the Ryans case! The transcript of the phone conversation mustn't be that cut-and-dried. That's why showing the relevant part of the transcript highlighted on the programme last night would have helped us all understand. It would have been a real "GOTCHA" moment, against the bank, that surely no documentary maker would not make use of. There must be something else to it.
 
Good point and I don't know why it took so long. The programme should have explained why it took so long.

A delay of 4 years with the Ombudsman would be nothing these days, but back then, they were much quicker.

I had assumed that the tape recording was a "gotcha" but now I don't think it was. Most phone conversations are not that clearcut.

And another complication which I have just thought of.

The original decision to reject his complaint was made when Bill Prasifka was the Financial Ombudsman.
Ger Deering was appointed in 2015 and he undertook a complete review of all the tracker cases - including the closed cases.

He probably kicked down the door of the Central Bank much more forcefully than Prasifka and told them that they should be looking at systemic failures in the banks' handling of tracker cases. So even though a review was not announced until 2015, he probably knew that the review was coming and put the files on hold.
 
Last edited:
That was pretty unfair on the Ryan's. Leaving them in limbo paying the higher variable rate for another 3 years until their case was reviewed even though they had the transcript proving that they were the victims of mis-selling by PTSB. That's partly why the documentary last night was so unsatisfactory. People, including bank officials make mistakes. The bank official on the phone or a customer forgetting that it's their responsibility to notify the bank that their temporary fixed term is coming up to end-term and they would like to go back on their tracker. The programme should have explored why it took so long for the Ryan's case to be resolved given that they had the transcript proving they were misinformed.
 
Last edited:
Watched this on the Player.

All the victims had one thing in common - they all left their trackers for a fixed rate. This shows cautiousness or slyness - or both.
Why were the motives for leaving the trackers not examined?

If they stayed on their tracker, they would have been better off with none of this hassle and stress.
 
This shows cautiousness or slyness - or both.
Why slyness? I thought that people moved onto fixed rates because they were cheaper than the tracker rates due to rising ECB base rates at the time? An understandably prudent approach to minimising mortgage costs as far as I can see?
If they stayed on their tracker, they would have been better off with none of this hassle and stress.
Be that as it may, it doesn't diminish the mishandling of this whole situation by the lenders involved.
 
Last edited:
Thank you @Brendan Burgess for taking part in it. I am looking forward to Eps 2.

From the end of Eps 1 it shows more of Padraic Kissane without his persistence, evidence in the JFOC, John McGuinness, David Hall too or Charlie Weston exposing the Banks behaviors.

I will be in Eps 2 and am thankful to have had this forum for guidance along the journey of taking on the Bank mostly alone, along with these advocates advice. I believe it will cover the investigation, appeal process for compensation and outcomes.

For those saying the likes of observational filming is distracting this is showing the human impact. In my case 1 account, 6 lives!

I am shocked, hurt and angered by the remarks from Patrick Honohan ex Governer CBI with comments such as their biggest priority was non performing loans. These may have been due to the Banks avoiding their obligations with these Tracker rates etc. I believe it was constructive fraud.
Comments like “I assumed - wrongly as it proved - that the people in charge of the banks would realise..” “was probably too trusting” to me this is just not good enough. I feel these regulators were asleep at the wheel.

 
Last edited:
My story was edited. Our arrears were recapitalized when they shouldn’t have been on the correct rate, we would’ve paid the full annuity but were treated as less than interest only all those wrongful years.
 
What an appalling programme.

With the exception of the brief piece referencing the AIB “prevailing rate” issue (which was admirably summarised by Brendan), there was zero attempt to explain or educate.

The tracker issue was complicated. Some cohorts were clear-cut, some were arguable and some cases, well.

Net result - the Central Bank chased two banks out of the jurisdiction and established an awful precedent that contracts don’t really matter. Apparently it’s all about “vibes”.

On the evidence of tonight’s programme, I think RTE were right to shut down their documentary unit.

As license payers, we are entitled to better than that.
 
Our arrears were also capitalised and this was not included in our story either.

I’m guessing our cases were simplified to make the wider narrative easier to consume. I’m not sorry we took part but also, not sorry it’s aired and done with.
 
"What an appalling programme." per @Sarenco. It was not an appalling programme. The banks created the news, RTE just reported it. And a good job they made of it too.
Did the banks sack anybody?
Some peoples lives were ruined. Sorry about that Chief, is extremely short of the mark.
Will there be criminal prosecutions? - I bet not.
Once again the banks thought they'd get away with it.
 
The two episodes ran for 100 minutes in total.

I was shocked by how bad Part 1 was. That they simply did not explain any of the issues.

Why the bank took the trackers.
Why the customers felt entitled to get their trackers back.
Why the Ombudsman rejected Thomas Byrne's complaint
And why, after the High Court quashed the Ombudsman's decision, did it take 7 more years to resolve the issue. Presumably it was not clear cut.
Why one Ombudsman dismissed a complaint by a customer of Ulster Bank and why his successor upheld a complaint on the exact same issue. Why Ulster Bank appealed the 2nd decision, lost in the High Court and eventually won in the Court of Appeal.

That is what a documentary should have done. It was more reality TV than documentary.

I did about 3 hours of interviews with them in the RTE studios.
They also spent a couple of hours in my kitchen reconstructing what they called "the kitchen cabinet".
I was really worried about which bits they would use so I contacted them after Part 1 and withdrew my permission for them to use the footage shot in my home. I wanted them to focus on the issue of the AIB Prevailing Rate and not on me looking wistfully at the teapot.

I was relieved that in the 5 minutes which they allocated to the AIB Prevailing Rate issue, which was by far the largest cohort in terms of number of people affected and amount of redress and compensation, they did use the bit where I explained some of the arguments on both sides. And they found good footage of Alan and me at the AIB AGM.

Our campaign went on for a number of years and they could have covered a lot more angles to it e.g. AIB making eejits of themselves at the Oireachtas Finance Committee. AIB claiming that the Prevailing Rate would have been 12%.

I am sure that Padraic Kissane would have outlined the arguments on both sides as well. But instead of using that footage, they showed him driving around Dublin, opening up his office, making tea, playing football and having a picnic with his family.

The bit with Joe Meade the first Ombudsman was good. He pointed out that he brought one case to the attention of the Financial Regulator in 2009 but they refused to tell him if they did anything with it.

The guy on the bus was very good as well.

They were more interested in human interest stories - if I could have found them someone who lost their home or who suffered serious financial problems, they would have allocated more time to the story. But the reality of it was that of the 6,000 people who benefited from our campaign, 5,900 did not even know that they had an issue. I also argued that most people in arrears were in arrears due to the loss of income. Of course, the loss of their tracker made it worse, but it was not the primary cause. (The Central Bank arrears statistics were very interesting. The percentage of people in arrears on tracker mortgages was the same as the percentage of people in arrears on non-tracker mortgages.)

On the overall tracker issue, I pointed out that while the Central Bank were very slow to get going, when they did get going, they did a great job. Without them, only about 300 would have got trackers back and serious compensation. Their intervention meant that 30,000 people, 95% of whom did not even know that they had an issue, got life changing redress.
 
Last edited:
One aspect that was not dug into was the way people were driven to contemplate suicide to protect their family home from the banks .
The woman featured showed how the strain broke her.
There is plenty of anecdotal evidence from this period following the Celtic Tiger crash that people who had no history of mental health issues died by way of suicide or the many single vehicle crashes in the middle of the night.
Some people who know guys driving trucks say that incidents of a car crashing into a truck late at night became way too common for it to be just normal road traffic accidents .
Will we ever know ? I suspect the amount of life cover paid out to clear mortgages will never be investigated just to be sure no further scandal will erupt.

Will the real truth ever emerge ? Not a chance until some whistle-blower comes forward , until such a time the narrative of "system failure" will not be challanged.
 
As for the 2009 FSPO Ruling on the tracker , where is the accountability by the Central Bank ?
Those people enjoy Civil Service protections in their jobs , the separation from the Dail to allow them function is correct but where they fail to protect the public then why are they not held accountable ???
The cost of the tracker scandal was ultimately paid by the consumers , for every Euro paid out in compensation this was recouped by the banks from other customers .
Prompt and public action by the Central Bank could have prevented this from becoming an issue in the first place.
 
One aspect that was not dug into was the way people were driven to contemplate suicide to protect their family home from the banks .

The biggest cause of financial stress was the economic collapse and loss of income resulting in inability to meet their full mortgage payments.

The repayments on a €300k mortgage at an SVR of 5% over 20 years are €2,000 a month.
The repayments on a €300k cheap tracker @2% over 20 years are €1,500 per month.

If someone was wrongly on an SVR but could only afford €1,500 a month, their bank would have rescheduled their mortgage.

If someone loses their income and pays nothing at all on their mortgage for three years, it doesn't really matter whether they are on a cheap tracker or a high SVR.

The wrongful loss of their tracker added to people's arrears problems, but was not the sole source. It was not even the main source.
 
We were well warned about the collapse before it took place , David McWilliams and others had cried foul about it .
When the crash took place one of the biggest factors that reduced income from all working in the state was the USC , a deduction from all of us that was then directed into the banks to keep them afloat , this was then followed by other measures that we are still suffering from today .
Investment in infrastructure ground to a halt and now we wonder why we have a trolly crisis as bed space was not built to meet the rising population needs , the same applies to schools etc .
The tracker scandal and arrears crisis are the consequence of irresponsible practices by the banks 25 years ago .
There will always be people who for some reason or other will get into bother with repayments but nowhere near the scale of what this country had to deal with thanks to the banks and the failure of regulators to keep them on the straight and narrow .

A friend has a brother who was in a senior position of one of the pillar banks back during the Celtic Tiger days , he said prudent bank managers were pushed aside and replaced with a new breed of banker that was little more than a second hand car salesman . Everything became about hitting sales targets as opposed to prudent banking .

In 25 years historians may get to the bottom of it but for now we will never get accountability .
 
Hi @Brendan Burgess we did over 5 hours of recording too so I can relate to the editing where we had 7 mins airtime. David Hall did 2.5 hrs recording. It could've been a 3 part series but now that unit are shut down.

I was advised we'd be on the focus of the appeal process. In what I described as a set up by the Bank. But last night it didn't delve to much into it.

In our case the lower panel never escalated it when they had the option to under the appeal guidelines booklet s6.5.

We were treated less serious although signing legal documents surrendering our home twice but as the Bank put it "technically we were still in our home".

No reflection of what being incorrectly classified as LTIO for 10 years had done to us when had we have been given our correct rate we paid full annuity & more but told we'd never overpaid.

One very relatable point was Padraic said last night was when you got the redress letter you were in shock then that quickly turned to anger. This was exactly me when reading the words we never overpaid!

When appealing the Bank submitted their documentation using GDPR for redaction when I had unredacted versions from a data access request months earlier. The CBI said while they could not intervene with this issue they asked our permission to highlight this in their examination. In our eyes the Bank were once again not playing fair, hiding the truth.

I tried in the recordings highlighting the issues around the appeal being far from impartial but I suppose they are limited by time when airing. The Central Bank refused to intervene on the appeals escalation & FSPO said it was beyond their remit. I'd to pull my FSPO complaint, ordered by the Bank to do so. So we’d no option we had to sign this acceptance and take what was offered.

The Banks were left to their own devices and got away far too lightly in our view.

Only for David Hall & ICare we would never have escaped the claws of KBC.

I had a lovely call this morning for Padraic Kissane & as I said hopefully he will keep up the good fight!
 
Back
Top