Revenue warned Government against pushing risk-averse savers to ‘dip their toes’ into volatile investment markets - Indo

Low levels of uncertainty and volatility, which Revenue seem to be implying would be the only possibly acceptable time for members of the public to reduce their weighting in cash and put some savings into financial market investments, usually occur near market tops when it is often the worst time to invest.
Well that does not appear to be the case at the present moment.
 
That is not my read of it. The dividends are not included in the 8 year DD so they are not double taxed.
I think I expressed myself badly. I am told that the DD is necessary because otherwise the dividends would accumulate within the ETF and be re-invested tax free. However, I have distributing funds, so I get the dividends directly and pay tax on them myself, yet I still suffer the DD the purpose of which is to catch undistributed dividends.

You are absolutely correct but that is not what the anti DD lobby are asking for. In fact they are very coy of asking for anything, rather than a stake through the heart of DD, as they certainly do not want the level playing field you describe.
Well I'd be happy with that. I'd even be happy if I was paying tax on the undistributed dividends and the undistributed gains (gains are likely small enough in an index tracker). I hold a few ETFs, but I didn't buy them to avoid tax. I bought them to avoid having to pick shares and because of the low costs. I didn't buy any more because of the DD and I'm now buying share directly myself which I probably shouldn't be.

Why isn't DD universal worldwide if its the only way to tax etfs as some here are indicating with there defence of it?
I would 100% agree with this. If ETFs which passively track share indexes are such evil tax avoidance vehicles why are we the only country with a DD. We do seem to be an outlier here. Other countries - the US - insists that dividends and gains are distributed, so that they are taxed in the investor's hands, other countries - the UK - deem the dividends to be distributed.
 
Why isn't DD universal worldwide if its the only way to tax etfs as some here are indicating with there defence of it?
Gemini said:
Ireland is the only country with a strict, multi-year "deemed disposal" rule where an investment fund is treated as sold and repurchased on a fixed anniversary. However, several other jurisdictions achieve a similar result—taxing unrealized gains or undistributed fund income before you actually sell—through annual mark-to-market, deemed-return, or deemed-distribution regimes.
Maybe the problem is with the name as it does seem unique. Maybe we should move to annual mark-to market, it sounds so much better.
 
Back
Top