Revenue warned Government against pushing risk-averse savers to ‘dip their toes’ into volatile investment markets - Indo

Jerome

Registered User
Messages
13
Ireland is no different from other EU countries in terms of how much spare cash is held on deposit in banks, it has argued, and the country does not appear to be an outlier in terms of participation in capital markets. While the tax regime for investment funds is complex, it is not necessarily acting as a barrier, Revenue also said.
Very interesting article on the rationale as to why Revenue are opposing any reform of the taxation system.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
While the tax regime for investment funds is complex, it is not necessarily acting as a barrier, Revenue also said.
If that is true it is only because people have no other choice in this country to access low cost market tracking Index Funds outside of their pensions.

They are not serious about allowing Irish people to build wealth.

Index funds are the least risky way to build wealth by investing in capital markets.
 
It’s an eye opener to get it confirmed how much revenue are the main ‘it’s fine the way it is unless you can prove it isn’t’ dept.

At lot passive aggressive, you don’t understand what we do but we can’t tell you about it kind of stuff, some of the quotes are like the very lowest level stuff you get it a meeting from the noisy but least useful staff, who always think everything is alright the way it is but aren’t really sure why, except it would definitely involve work changing it.

It is difficult to see how tax could be the key determinative factor into why a retail investor may choose to invest in a life product over an investment fund,

an analysis of whether the difference in tax treatment was justified appears not to have been undertaken

as with all anti-avoidance rules, its existence has a deterrent effect which it is not possible to put a value on
 
Agree not really the Revenue's business. An equally valid arguement is that the punitive tax regime that applies to UCITS is pushing retail investors towards more risky investments (shares, investment trusts) rather than a diversifed, well regulated investment vehicle (UCITS) aimed at retail investor. When one looks at the taxation of 'offshore investments' they took a 1990 anti avoidance provision and applied it to gross roll up funds. The Revenue should look at what they cause rather than telling people the devil you know etc.
 
the country does not appear to be an outlier in terms of participation in capital markets
They are being quite contrarian in this view. E.g. from the Central Bank:

Findings from previous research have established that retail investment participation in Ireland is low by international comparison. Quarterly Financial Accounts data shows that at end-2025 financial market instruments [ Debt Securities, Listed Shares, Money Market Fund (MMF) Shares, (non-MMF) Investment Fund Shares] account for 6 per cent of total household financial assets, compared to a euro-area average of 20 per cent.
 
Revenue is saying having pension funds is equal to having investments outside of a pension, so they claim we're heavily invested in the capital markets. The Central Bank is excluding pension savings, correctly in my view. That's why both are at odds with each other.

Irish pension savings are higher than average - because we don't have a salary linked state pension. Irish people are forced to self-fund retirement and while private pension wealth shows up in household wealth, state pension wealth doesn't.

Pension savings are highly restricted, the age you can access them, rate of drawdown, taxes on them when you access them, the odd pension levy might even appear - and the rules could change at any time. They are not equal to having savings or investments that can be accessed at any time for any reason.

Also Revenue's warning "The State should not be encouraging risk-averse retail savers to move their cash from deposit accounts into investment markets at times of heightened volatility and uncertainty" is effectively arguing in favour of market timing.
Are they going to be the ones to decide the correct time to launch the account with regard to volatility and uncertainty?

Anyone who's been invested through the dot-com bubble, world financial crash, Irish financial crash, covid, Russian invasions, Trump's chaos, AI bubble would be hard pressed to remember a time when they didn't worry about heightened volatility and uncertainty.
 
“Also, if the taxation regime is so hostile, how come Ireland is a leading domicile for investment funds? ”

Is this not an absurd statement to make? The hostile regime applies to Irish residents holding the funds, not the treatment of the funds themselves
This has precisely 0 relationship with why the funds choose Ireland as its domicile.

Generally think Revenge are great, but my word it’s like they let some TY student on placement write that drivel.
 
Back
Top