Health Insurance Policy required with Laya that has 100% orthopaedic and ophthalmic at cheapest rate

Is good day to day cover that important?
Stupid question, I suppose, it is if the day to day costs become large and ongoing.
But what sort of numbers are we potentially talking about in terms of these expenses.
I've always prioritised being fully covered for hospital accommodation and operations
because those numbers are potentially huge.
It's like with house insurance, I want to be covered if the house burns down, I'm not so worried about carpets.
 
Interesting thread we are currently on Laya Prosper advanced other half may require orthopaedic surgery and we would like full cover but has also had a cancer diagnosis. Irish life are the only insurer covering focal therapy in the Beacon which may be relevant to us. It is a 2 year wait period for existing conditions and it may not be something he would want but would like to have it as an option as it it 22K out of pocket.

I have really found Laya to be more difficult to navigate since AIG and subsequently AXA have taken them over. Processing of claims and response times are definitely slower. Renewal is January I can see myself jumping ship going to try them I think.
 
it's not what insurance is really supposed to be for
I would agree but health insurance is more like a life assurance policy, you're going to make a claim if not several claims

For me I feel that day to day expenses cover is probably one of the main drivers in pushing up HI costs
The other year I was on inspire plus at €1550 but was able to claim back just under €1000 in day to day expenses
Great for me but not so good for Laya if I'm a typical customer making the most of their day to day expenses cover as it leaves very little for the big hospital bills they cover
 
Great for me but not so good for Laya if I'm a typical customer making the most of their day to day expenses cover as it leaves very little for the big hospital bills they cover

Would also have to wonder if the consultants would be getting so much business at their very high fees for some visits that take maybe 10 minutes or less if people were not getting perhaps up to 75% back on health policy. I had to pay €400 for first visit to one recently.
 
LayaEmpower Secure (No Excess). €8268
LayaCompanyCare Premium (No Excess). €6288
LayaEmpower Create (No Excess). Must be discontinued?
LayaTotal Health Complete. €3528
LayaEssential Plus (No Excess). €6324
 
There are 30+ Laya plans with full orthopaedic and ophthalmic cover. The yearly charge varies from €9700 to €2570.
 
LayaEmpower Secure (No Excess). €8268
LayaCompanyCare Premium (No Excess). €6288
LayaEmpower Create (No Excess). Must be discontinued?
LayaTotal Health Complete. €3528
LayaEssential Plus (No Excess). €6324
yes Empower Create was dropped in sep 25. VHI also have 100% ortho plans: the AdvancedCare* range are the cheapest ("AdvancedCare 250" is €2694p.a.) but also ProvidentCare Plus, PremiumCare* & Company Plan Executive
 
I am not in a position to pay really high premiums and to be honest I would prefer not even if I could but appreciate lots of good info here I will do a deeper dive into total health complete it is in our budget.
 
If it's any help, I made a list of all the full ortho policies with current prices (direct from my renewal page on the Laya website), plus the occasional comment. Asterisks indicate the policies I was considering for 1 Dec renewal. Simplicity is the marginal favourite but I'm still weighing up pros and cons, known present and likely future needs, swings and roundabouts.

1. Company Health Explore - €4896
2. CompanyCare Excess - €4268
3. CompanyCare, No excess - €4926
4. CompanyCare Choice - €3699
5. CompanyCare Gold - €9427
6. CompanyCare Plus - €5254
7. CompanyCare Premium, No Excess - €6107
8. Company Health Plus, Excess - €3950
9 Company Health Plus, No excess - €4921
10. Complete Simplicity - €4301
11. **Connect Care 150 - €3590
12. **ConnectCare 100 - €3310
13. Control 150 Connect - €3052 (no physio, dental, optical)
14. **Control 150 Secure - €3221 NB Radiology and consultant refunds limited
15. Control 300 Create - €2869. High excesses and limited radiology refunds
16. Empower 150 Secure - €7491
17. Empower Secure, No excess - €8031
18. Essential Connect Family - €3007 (no physio, dental, optical)
19. Essential Connect Health - €3237 (ditto)
20. Essential Plus, Excess - €5268
21. Essential Plus, No excess - €6139
22. Flex 125 Choice - €4938
23. Flex 135 Explore - €3844
24. Flex 125 Plus - €4093
25. Flex 175 Explore - €2791 (no physio, dental, optical)
26. Flex 250 Choice - €3633
27. Flex 250 Explore - €2645 (no physio etc)
28. **Ideal Simplicity - €3597 - €50 excess on Everyday refunds.
29. Momentum - €3824
30. **Power - €3431 - O/P Limit €1000
31. **Simplicity - €3312 - €100 excess on Everyday refunds
32. Simply Connect- €2946. - O/P limit €500
33. Simply Connect Care - €2610 - no optical, no cover Blackrock, Mater
34. **Simply Connect Plus - €3228 - O/P limit €1000
35. **Simply Health, Excess - €3529
36. Total Health, No excess - €3859
37. **Total Health Complete - €3426
38. Total Health Extra - €2558 - O/P limit €500
39. Total Health Select - €5251
 
Thanks mct1 for your work on displaying these prices.
Can you say why you would select Simplicity as your policy for the next 12 months?
Many of these prices may be increased in the next few weeks.
There are too many policies….the insurance companies should be restricted in the number of policies they offer.
 
That €500 outpatient limit is easily reached as I found out to my cost this year. 2 consultant visits and a few doc and physio and it's goneski. Strangely I got more than 500 back two years ago on the same plan so they must have sneaked it in under the radar like a lot of things.
 
Can you say why you would select Simplicity as your policy for the next 12 months?

It's a fine balance, but for example Simplicity mostly has lower hospital excesses than the others with comparable price points, such as Total Health Complete and Connect Care 100. Cover at the Beacon is particularly relevant to me and Simplicity is the winner there.

The downsides for me are the €100 Everyday excess and the consultant refund limit of €125. To compensate for the former I add €90 to the cost of Simplicity when comparing it. As regards the latter, I haven't yet been charged more than €280 for a first consultation, though my husband was recently. However, this is making me reconsider my choice because, as we know, consultants fees only go one way.

More expensive policies like Connect Care 150, Ideal Simplicity, and Simply Health Excess don't seem to offer anything more for the extra.

Other than two pre-arranged review consultations I really don't know what 2027 will bring for me healthwise, but going on the past two years it could be busy. I don't think it has ever been so difficult to find a suitable policy!
 
Last edited:
I have the Simply Health Plus policy, cost about 1900, it's got great benefits but a 40% shortfall on the Ortho. I have mild to moderate arthritis which I manage very well with daily strengthening and stretching exercises plus I'm a regular at the gym. If I need a joint replacement in the future, I will be availing of the treatment abroad scheme. For me, I use the everyday expense element of the policy more than anything else and my out patient excess is €7650. Last year, I claimed more than the cost of my policy back.
 
Park00

yes you can go abroad to get it done. Make sure you follow all correct procedures that is required by the HSE, you can even get pre approval from HSE before you go. Currently HSE are slow to refund people but they saying it will be resolved in next few months


The prices by MCT1 posted above for full Ortho cover are insane and outside the affordability of many and even having full Ortho cover, there's major reductions in other cover within those policies.
 
Hello Heidi 100,

Will the treatment abroad scheme allow a joint replacement if it is available here?
On the Treatment Abroad Scheme itself, generally not. That scheme is for treatment that isn't available in Ireland, or isn't available here within the time that's medically necessary for you, and the HSE has to approve it before you travel. A hip or knee replacement is available here, so the scheme only comes into it if the HSE accepts that the wait is longer than is medically acceptable in your case.

What Heidi100 describes sounds more like the other route, the Cross Border Directive, and that one does cover a joint replacement that is available here. You have it done in a hospital in another EU country, private hospitals included, pay the bill yourself and claim it back from the HSE afterwards. The refund is capped at what the same operation would cost in the Irish public system, so anything the hospital charges above that is yours to pay. You need a referral letter from your GP first, and before you book you can ask the HSE to confirm that you're eligible to apply (prior notification). The UK has been out of the Directive since Brexit; Northern Ireland has a separate HSE scheme of its own.

On the money, the RTÉ piece Heidi100 linked matches what the HSE said in late October: some people had been waiting five or six months for their refund, and it expects to be back to normal by February 2027. So you'd need to be able to cover the full bill in the meantime.

(I'm not a neutral party on this: I founded Ablement, and arranging the Directive route for people in Ireland, from finding the hospital to making the HSE claim, is what we do.)
 
Back
Top