If it's any help, I made a list of all the full ortho policies with current prices (direct from my renewal page on the Laya website), plus the occasional comment. Asterisks indicate the policies I was considering for 1 Dec renewal. Simplicity is the marginal favourite but I'm still weighing up pros and cons, known present and likely future needs, swings and roundabouts.
1. Company Health Explore - €4896
2. CompanyCare Excess - €4268
3. CompanyCare, No excess - €4926
4. CompanyCare Choice - €3699
5. CompanyCare Gold - €9427
6. CompanyCare Plus - €5254
7. CompanyCare Premium, No Excess - €6107
8. Company Health Plus, Excess - €3950
9 Company Health Plus, No excess - €4921
10. Complete Simplicity - €4301
11. **Connect Care 150 - €3590
12. **ConnectCare 100 - €3310
13. Control 150 Connect - €3052 (no physio, dental, optical)
14. **Control 150 Secure - €3221 NB Radiology and consultant refunds limited
15. Control 300 Create - €2869. High excesses and limited radiology refunds
16. Empower 150 Secure - €7491
17. Empower Secure, No excess - €8031
18. Essential Connect Family - €3007 (no physio, dental, optical)
19. Essential Connect Health - €3237 (ditto)
20. Essential Plus, Excess - €5268
21. Essential Plus, No excess - €6139
22. Flex 125 Choice - €4938
23. Flex 135 Explore - €3844
24. Flex 125 Plus - €4093
25. Flex 175 Explore - €2791 (no physio, dental, optical)
26. Flex 250 Choice - €3633
27. Flex 250 Explore - €2645 (no physio etc)
28. **Ideal Simplicity - €3597 - €50 excess on Everyday refunds.
29. Momentum - €3824
30. **Power - €3431 - O/P Limit €1000
31. **Simplicity - €3312 - €100 excess on Everyday refunds
32. Simply Connect- €2946. - O/P limit €500
33. Simply Connect Care - €2610 - no optical, no cover Blackrock, Mater
34. **Simply Connect Plus - €3228 - O/P limit €1000
35. **Simply Health, Excess - €3529
36. Total Health, No excess - €3859
37. **Total Health Complete - €3426
38. Total Health Extra - €2558 - O/P limit €500
39. Total Health Select - €5251