Landlords continue to sell up - Owen Reilly Q3 2025 Report

Status
Not open for further replies.
But there isnt anyone queuing up. Everyone wants out and nobody wants in.
100% correct. I listened to him on some podcast over the summer with a friend of his. Both of them were bemoaning the fact that first time buyers were going to have an awful time come the Autumn because investors would be buying up all available properties as the new rules were so pro-landlord and so attractive for landlords. Delusional and completely the opposite has happened.

He also said in the same podcast that a landlord could under the current rules grant a one year lease, not renew it and get the tenant out that way. He thought that the same thing was possible under the new rules. I nearly fell off my chair. He's a housing 'expert'!
 
I always find that countries are named and bundled together using the most drastic examples in each.
I find the same thing myself. And the French system is fair - it is one year fixed if unfurnished so suitable for short term people, 3 year fixed the tenant has to furnish. Again, that is fair as the tenant has to invest in the property so should be entitled to security of tenure. It is fair on the landlord as well. While they can't get vacant possession for three years, they have no fitout or maintenance costs. It won't suit everyone obviously, but it is balanced.

You can bet as well that there is zero tolerance in France for non payment of rent where there isn't genuine hardship or for wrecking properties. I have had French tenants. They are excellent.
 
You can bet as well that there is zero tolerance in France for non payment of rent where there isn't genuine hardship or for wrecking properties
Not that easy. Need to go to court. But I do know of one case and the tenant stayed in property and paid his debt.
I listened to a program recently. There is also a problem of a lack of rental and investment in the system. The speaker also spoke of the rules having increased.
In terms of rent, they are controlled during a rental with an authorised inflation link indexation each year. They can be reset when tenants leave.
 
Reminder that Hearne is the social Democrats spokesman for Housing.

I for one will be sending him my usual Christmas present of a box of crayons so he can continue writing such remarkable market insights....If only he were housing Minister :)
 
@Premos It is still a much more balanced system than we have here.

I've no issue with sensible rent controls as some landlords will gouge and that does have to be prevented. The French rent control system sounds reasonable enough.
 
I've no issue with sensible rent controls as some landlords will gouge and that does have to be prevented. The French rent control system sounds reasonable enough.
I am also not totally against rent controls during a tenancy, at some level. However, the fact that rents in RPZ have never been reset over 10 years is a real issue. The first few years were acceptable. The last 5, less so. The fact that market rent will not be market rent and reset might not be reset is definitely a worry.
 
I wonder if they are stalling now because they have an "emergency" eviction ban in the works.
That's a scary thought as I am out of country and not able to swear an oath today. I will get my agent to prepare it for when I return.

The irony on the avalanche of NOT is the total lack of clarity on the new rental rules/system. Without this, the new rules seem to be just window dressing on the issue of ability to reset rents to a true market rent as opposed to an artificial average rent due to rent controls. Hence, owners of rental property are confused, bewildered and possibly afraid their asset(s) may be devalued / become unsaleable, and issuing NOT while they still can.
 
And all they have to do is come out and say "yes, we understand that landlords are worried and confused, so we will withdraw the changes and come back next year with something we have thought about some more and that is well explained and fair". But they wont do that. The will race ahead with flawed legislation totally ignoring the damage it is doing and double down on the stick (or sledge hammer at this point).

And there is very good reason to be afraid, so people being forced to act now to protect their assets before they are locked in to a losing investment forever.
 
As much as R. Hearne piece is all emotional with very few explanations or solutions, I think that investors "fatigue" and psychology are not considered properly by politicians. Trust has probably been broken too many times. I would consider that a lot of small LLs have enough of the constant kites flying that things will get better and that their concerns are taken into account. The RPZ were temporary but have been constantly renewed. Once high inflation hit, increases were limited to 2 per cent. Tax incentives were talked about last year, I think that this was even announced in the budget 2023 and ended up very limited after a year of rumours. This year, from February, talks started about RPZ and the fact they needed to be revisited, announcements were made in June extending them, leaving the system as it was for existing tenancies and promising a market reset. Now market rents are not market rent. A few months ago, it was all about number of LLs increasing (which no one felt), now notices are high... And I forgot to mention a couple of rent freeze and eviction ban during the same period.
 
Once it becomes a PR stunt you know it's damage limitation. I worked close with PR people and when they got involved in an bad news issue, it was heavy on words, and empathy, but not on meaning...mostly waffle. This is a conscious act so the company could be seen to be engaging.

As said above by @JamieB_ all they have to do is take a step back and stop with this knee jerk policy. Then redesign it with the benefit of hindsight and mature recollection...
They never should have announced what they were doing before the legislation was drafted.

It's like the NCH, going to tender before the design was signed off. Lessons are never learned when blame can be passed to others
 
Last edited:
As far as i am concerned the IPOA are not doing their job at all. They are just sitting in the corner afraid to say anything. I dont actually know what the point of them is anymore.
 
Really surprised there hasn't been a legal challenge, that's how this level of interference should be dealt with. I'd happily contribute towards such a challenge if the IPOA took one as would many many others.
 
Apparently the law says thats not allowed. You have to challenge it by yourself and cannot get crowd funded for it. Convenient isnt it. The big players with the money and less risk of ruin wont challenge it because they have lots pf perks that the ordinary person doesnt so they are happy as it is.
 
everybody wants out and nobody wants in".Wish I could be that certain.
Since the end of 2024, the only groups of LLs that have increased are the ones with over 50 tenancies, there were 12 additional LLs in these categories (over 50 and over 100 tenancies). So not too many want in. All the other groups of LLs have decreased and there are now about 1800LL less than in December last year.
 
Last edited:
there were 12 additional LLs in these categorie
Exactly, and we know alot of these could actually be state backed bodies as cost rental tenancies are included in the private tenancies data.

There was 2,414 cost rentals at the end of 2024 Vs 3,907 at the end of Q3 2025. I suspect the only landlords that are growing are the state funded bodies that are misleadingly included in the private rental data.



We know from public fillings that the largest landlord in Ireland IRES REIT is reducing its portfolio also (3,652 units at end of June 25, down from 3,669 at end of Dec24).


Does anyone else have any other idea of who might be growing? One thought I have is that property in a pension fund might be rtb registered in the name of the pension trustee or administrator and thus the RTB consider them one landlord but in reality those properties still owned by individuals.
 
Thank you Dermot! You are right, not very open or transparent at all.

Also, all the emphasis is on the fact that our current tenancies remain and that the current rules apply to them. That begs the question, if the new rules are so good why aren't they singing their virtues to us. Then we'd have nothing at all to fear

Am I correct in thinking that the large landlord rules aren't set out at all - surely many IPOA members are large landlords.
 
We know from public fillings that the largest landlord in Ireland IRES REIT is reducing its portfolio also (3,652 units at end of June 25, down from over 3,669 at end of Dec24).
It is a real warning sign when a REIT is selling off individual apartments.

Also, IRES REIT's share price has fallen since the new rules were announced. It was about €1.12 on 10 June. It is 93c today. That is near its all time low of about 84c. The rules are designed to benefit REITs more than ordinary landlords, but they are getting a very lukewarm reception with the funds as well.

That to me anyway is a clear signal not to become involved in this market. Doubtless many estate agents will be encouraging novice investors so as to increase their own business. It is very dishonest of them.
 
Don’t understand this.

“5. In the current arrangements, landlords are not categorised as ‘smaller’ or ‘larger’. That categorisation only applies when a landlord ends a new tenancy that starts after 1 March 2026.”

Does that mean all existing tenancies that a LL has now will change to the new LL rules as soon as any post Mar26 tenancy is ended?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top