Landlords continue to sell up - Owen Reilly Q3 2025 Report

Status
Not open for further replies.
Its totally clear that at this point there is only one solution at this point. Take your ball back and sell it and find another sport to invest in.

Isn’t that it. If a landlord isn’t happy with the conditions of being a landlord they should make a decision and sell.

The resulting outcome isn’t a problem for the landlord and not one they should really be thinking about. Just like if there were tax changes for other investments someone selling shares wouldn’t worry on the impact on the company.

The concern of landlords here about the impact on rental supply isn’t really concern. It’s a hope that the government will cave to some degree.

I think the government are aware that landlords will sell but feel it will be worth it if it brings in more security to tenants. Thats a political decision they are making which might very well be wrong.

The addition supply for buyers will also be a political positive for them even if it makes a bigger issue in the rental sector.
 
Clearly the intention of rent controls has not been met over the years. Nobody will admit it. At this point its just all people with their head in the sand and no common sense who support rent controls. I am just flabbergasted at how people continue to ignore the facts and continue to be blind to past legislation and just keep on making it worse. They wont even analyse what went wrong before and why it went wrong. All I can think is it must be the same dumb advisor advising each subsequent minister. And on we go. Amazing.
 
I think the government are aware that landlords will sell but feel it will be worth it if it brings in more security to tenants. Thats a political decision they are making which might very well be wrong.
Watching the Housing Committee debates, especially the one with the RTB and the Department of Housing officials, I don't think it is that. I really think they think this will work and that landlords will be happy with it. Hence the current 'education' campaign via the emails posters have been getting

You are correct though - there is 0% chance they will cave in or change their plans
 
The resulting outcome isn’t a problem for the landlord and not one they should really be thinking about.
Actually as a parent of adult children, it is a concern to me. As a resident in this country, I also worry about the societal impacts these poor decisions are having as much as anyone else. Why wouldn't I? The all housing issue is dividing society.
As these emails seem to be a new thing, the figures for October and November must not be that good either.
 
Last edited:
Does anyone else expect a lot of rentals to be going on the market (to be sold) in January?
 
Plus annual tenancies not being 'renewed' - the number of properties leaving the PRS is likely far higher than the NoTs suggest
 
Let's say we accept:Too many regulations,RTB not up to job, Uncooperative tennants,RPZ etc etc.In purely financial terms-what kind of rental yield(compared to other investments like stocks etc)would be enough to keep small landlords in the marketplace.Sometimes there is nothing to fear but fear itself.
 
Just a thought. All very well to talk about selling up, but for a small landlord who bought 25+ years ago, wouldn't there be a very hefty CGT bill? That would have to be considered together with all the other factors (I'd accept a below-market-rate rent rather than a massive CGT bill)
 
Just a thought. All very well to talk about selling up, but for a small landlord who bought 25+ years ago, wouldn't there be a very hefty CGT bill? That would have to be considered together with all the other factors (I'd accept a below-market-rate rent rather than a massive CGT bill)
If you end up having to sell with a tenant in situ, your CGT bill will be very much reduced because the value of your property will be very much reduced
 
To clarify, pre 22 means pre JUNE 2022

Yes, that is my understanding.

Though if it was me, I wouldn't entirely trust someone on the internet :).

There is also the risk that they change the rules anyway, but that is where we currently are.

You only get 1 short at it, especially if you leave it until the last minute.

If you are planning to sell anyway, it might be worth doing it earlier under the right to evict for sale. That would allow you to try more than once.

Another tip was to request a hearing on the validity of your termination notice yourself. That way you get a ruling on it can can re-try if it is invalid.

I am not sure what the timescales are on them. Even if it took 60 days to get your hearing, you still would have a time for a 2nd try if you sent the notice 220 days before the deadline.

I could also see the RTB delaying NoT hearings until it was to late to try again in that case.

There is a possibility that they are threading the needle on keeping it constitutional. Technically, no property owner has been forced into anything.

They agreed to the new terms, including the auto-renewal under whatever the terms will be at the future time. They can opt-out (in theory) of the new rules, so nobody's property rights are being violated. Just opt-out if you don't like it. The fact that a tiny mistake in the opt-out ruins it is part of the trap.

If they try to retrospectively change contracts that makes any constitutional challenge easier for landlords to win.

That would make a bait and switch harder. However, if the opt-out is technically possible, even if risky in practice they might squeak through on constitutionality. I think the bait and switch would be to make the opt-out effectively impossible.

There was a youtube video where the landlord followed the slow process and got his eviction determination from the RTB. He went to court and the RTB had made a typo, so his case stalled. I could see that kind of things being part of things. The RTB might "accidentally" make errors.
 
They agreed to the new terms, including the auto-renewal under whatever the terms will be at the future time. They can opt-out (in theory) of the new rules, so nobody's property rights are being violated. Just opt-out if you don't like it. The fact that a tiny mistake in the opt-out ruins it is part of the trap.
You can bet with the 6 year tenancies, they will make it as tricky as possible to issue the NoT correctly. You'll only have one shot at it and if you make the smallest mistake you'll have a very angry tenant in place for a further 6 years.

At least with the current system if you mess up, you can reissue the NoT. It is a pain, it is costly and time consuming, but you will be able to sell with vacant possession.
 
under the right to evict for sale. That would allow you to try more than once.
How does that work please? Is the NoT issued and then withdrawn? Then another NoT can be issued at some future date? Does a subsequent NoT have to be for a different reason?
 
Last edited:
How does that work please? Is the NoT issued and then withdrawn?

Basically, with the 6 year rule, you have pretty much have 1 shot at a no-reason eviction.

You can re-issue NoTs if they fail. The problem is that if you are evicting on a pre-22 tenancy for "no-reason", then it is only allowed at the end of the six year term.

The tenant can wait until 6 years and 1 day and then dispute the NoT. This stops the eviction process and they get a hearing. If the NoT was invalid for any reason, then you are past the window to evict. You can't re-issue the NoT since you had to do it before the 6 years are up.

You now have locked into a post-26 tenancy. You have to wait for 6 years before being able to evict to sell again.

If you evict for sale, you can do that anytime (on pre-26 tenancies). That way you could try more than once. If it fails, you can say you are still planning to sell.

I think it might also work if you can get a hearing yourself on your NoT. Evict with 220 days to go before the end of the 6 year cycle, and then request a hearing. If they rule against the NoT, you may still have time to try again. Ofc, the RTB could just delay your hearing until the clock has run out.

Pre-22 will end 6 years after they start. If you don't want a 2026 tenancy, you need to evict before that happens. The post-22 ones, in theory, never run out, so you can continue with the current tenant (and lower rent) indefinitely.
 
Pre-22 will end 6 years after they start. If you don't want a 2026 tenancy, you need to evict before that happens.
That is a very good point. How many landlords are aware, I wonder, that a pre-22 tenancy will automatically convert to a fixed 6 year tenancy or more importantly a permanent one if you are a large landlord ie. no fault evictions are completely banned for large landlords
 
Basically, with the 6 year rule, you have pretty much have 1 shot at a no-reason eviction.
Thank you for the detailed reply.
What about a tenancy that has rolled over to a post jun22 unlimited term - can a LL issue an NoT and then withdraw it?

If a LL wanted to safeguard their interests and was unsure how the new Act might affect them, or other possibilities like a short-term ban on terminations, is that allowed or does an NoT stand unless it’s disputed by the tenant?



Edit: just saw this in post #246 from @Nutso. (Copy of correspondence from the Rental Market Policy Section, Department of Housing, Local Government and Heritage)

WITHDRAWING A NOTICE OF TERMINATION
If you change your mind - and if your tenant is still in situ - you can withdraw your notice of termination and retain your current tenant arrangement. If you withdraw the notice, it is good practice to inform the tenant in writing and to keep a record.
 
Last edited:
In terms of LL leaving or not leaving the market, I really think that the RTB is somewhat disingenuous. Cost rentals were included in the figures I believe at some point in 2024. The end of the year report mentions 2414 cost rentals (which would mean 238190 "private" registrations at the end of 2024. Now, end Q3 2025, there are 3907 cost rentals which means 236844 "private" registrations. 1346 rental lost is not a huge difference, but once again, the current message is that there have always been LLs leaving the market and LLs entering it.
 
In terms of LL leaving or not leaving the market, I really think that the RTB is somewhat disingenuous. Cost rentals were included in the figures I believe at some point in 2024.
As well as cost rentals, the current figures include about 4,000 unregistered landlords who were caught and made register (from memory the RTB said that over 6k were caught and approx. two-thirds had registered). Again, these are not new tenancies or an increase in tenancies. They were always there. Again, disngenuous to include them without highlighting how they arose
 
If a landlord isn’t happy with the conditions of being a landlord they should make a decision and sell.
On this one again, when one doesn't have a good incentive to rent, they just don't rent. It doesn't mean the property is actually sold. A family member went to a nursing home. Renting was mentioned by some, we opposed as we knew the difficulties involved.
As a LL, my property has been vacant for 5 months over the past 3 years, so 14% of the time. The first time, 3 months as we were not sure what to do with it. It was left in a bad state and we knew the yield was not good. AE were contacted and keys given to one. Second time, 2 months. Tenants left at a time when it was not really suiting our private life, we just could not be bothered! That might seem strange but some people have huge amount of money on deposit or even on current account. Now, we are considering leaving it vacant until the time our eldest might need it. Before that time, the turnaround had been a couple of weeks max.
 
It was left in a bad state and we knew the yield was not good.
I know the feeling. All this talk of certainty for landlords from the RTB is BS. What would really help landlords is being able to request a decent deposit (3 months) and knowing that if a tenant stopped paying rent or was causing trouble, they could be evicted, quickly. Any other talk of certainty is laughable seeing they or many landlords will be locked into a very one sided system, and certain they may not get vacant possession of a property for a long time, or ever.

The uncertainty is certain. Landlords will be leaving properties vacant for family members or just selling up.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top