Is it legal to take Property Tax from Social Welfare or Childrens Allowance?

T

TrundleAlong

Registered User
Messages
170
I am not sure why people get Social Welfare and Children's Allowance?

Is it part of our constitution to assist people in need and families etc.?

If this is the case how can our government allow the revenue commissioners access to these funds for property tax purposes.

Could it be challenged in a court of law?
 
TrundleAlong said:
I am not sure why people get Social Welfare and Children's Allowance. Is it part of our constitution to assist people in need and families etc.
Click to expand...

You can read the Constitution here . You'll find a number of articles relating to Social Policy.
 
People on SW can just keep deferring the tax until the house is sold.
 
By deferring payment they are in effect borrowing from the Government to pay their property tax. This is wrong and the Government are behaving like money lenders to those who cannot afford to pay. This penalty interest will mount up over the years leading to a lot of worry for people.
 
TrundleAlong said:
By deferring payment they are in effect borrowing from the Government to pay their property tax. This is wrong and the Government are behaving like money lenders to those who cannot afford to pay. This penalty interest will mount up over the years leading to a lot of worry for people.
Click to expand...

Just as income tax is based on the income you earn, property tax will be based on the property you hold, there is nothing unfair or inequitable about that! How you choose to pay the tax is up to you - defer, borrow or pay it out of your income... or dispose of the property if you so wish.

Property tax is applied in most of the Euro region and I don't see any reason why it should be different here! In fact in most of Europe it it is applied to all assets held by the individual, not just property.
 
sahd said:
They can only deduct it if it does not bring their weekly income below the amount of supplementary welfare allowance
Click to expand...

That suggests that the Supplementary Welfare Allowance is the amount set by various agencies as the minimum amount that a person needs to exist. The Social Welfare amounts above this are a "bonus" of sorts. This extra layer of fat looks as if it will be fair game in the future.

What is the difference between the basic Social Welfare payment and the Supplementary Welfare Allowance? Would it be better to let the Revenue take this difference. How much would it add up to in a year?
 
What is the difference between the basic Social Welfare payment and the Supplementary Welfare Allowance?
Click to expand...
Those two amounts are the same, €188 for a single person or €312 for a married couple.

There is really no scope to deduct from these payments. It has already been advised to the minister for SP that such deductions would be illegal.
 
SWA is €186 pw. €2 pw less than the standard rate of €188. So
€2 x 52wks= €104 which would cover the minimum Property tax of €96

and still leave people just above the poverty line, how bad.


This government is showing us how you can get blood from a stone.
 
The Supplementary Welfare Allowance rate is currently €2 per week lower than the standard Jobseeker's payment, at €186 for a single person and €310 for a couple.

The Social Welfare bill which was passed last week allows for deductions of up to 15% of a person's weekly SW payment to recover overpayments. This got through with very little comment or objection (which was all directed towards the carer's cuts). As this is now law, there is little to stop revenue introducing a similar legislative change to deduct the local property tax from SW payments.
 
Last edited:
TrundleAlong said:
If you EARN you might be able to pay. If you don't EARN how can you pay.

A home doesn't EARN.
Click to expand...

If you own the property, then you are wealthy enough to pay, just like every other European and if not, then do like every other Europen - borrow, defer or sell!

It's about time Irish social protection got into line with the rest of the Euro zone, espically since we are borrowing to pay for it.
 
gipimann said:
The Supplementary Welfare Allowance rate is currently €2 per week lower than the standard Jobseeker's payment, at €186 for a single person and €310 for a couple.

The Social Welfare bill which was passed last week allows for deductions of up to 15% of a person's weekly SW payment to recover overpayments. This got through with very little comment or objection (which was all directed towards the carer's cuts). As this is now law, there is little to stop revenue introducing a similar legislative change to deduct the local property tax from SW payments.
Click to expand...

I doubt they will bother as a SW recipient can just defer payment indefinitely.
 
As we move into a more integrated Euro zone this will happen as a matter of course, but having said that, it would seem that Irish public service pay is not that far off the European average, when all is said and done according to both the OECD and the IMF.
 
Jim2007 said:
If you own the property, then you are wealthy enough to pay, just like every other European and if not, then do like every other Europen - borrow, defer or sell!

It's about time Irish social protection got into line with the rest of the Euro zone, espically since we are borrowing to pay for it.
Click to expand...

When we are equal in all aspects of our lives, tax rates, social protection, health costs, transport costs, insurance costs, in effect the normal cost of living costs then I might agree with your argument.
 
gipimann said:
The Social Welfare bill which was passed last week allows for deductions of up to 15% of a person's weekly SW payment to recover overpayments.
Click to expand...

But if this is for "overpayments" then it is a method for recovering this error in payment. Some might have spent this overpayment, some might not. I don't think that this is comparing like with like.
If €188 per week is deemed the amount that a persons needs to have to survive then I cannot see how anyone can take a portion of this to pay a tax.
 
Jim2007

You reckon if you own property "you are wealthy enough to pay ".

Does this mean that if one owns a house worth 200.000 but owes the bank 400.000 then one is wealthy enough to pay ? This is exactly the position for tens of thousands of people., many of them on S.W.

These people cannot - as you claim - sell, and certainly cannot borrow. Deferring would seem the only option.
 
oldnick said:
Jim2007

Deferring would seem the only option.
Click to expand...

It appears that people will be forced to defer payment and be forced to borrow their property tax @ 4% per annum from the Irish Government.

To be paid back years down the road when the widow or widower has to sell or the kids are settling their parents estate. With inheritance tax thresholds dropping like a stone the children/executor might end up being a tax collector for the government.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top