Intel to create 'hundreds of jobs' with €5bn investment in Leixlip plant, announced 13th July 2026

The same batteries
Ah, that's just as ill-informed as some of your other claims above so.

First of all no, not the same batteries at all. They produced batteries for industrial machinery, not for grid storage. Secondly, the 2025 fire was caused by improper storage of batteries while not in use. Grid storage facilities are required to have active cooling and fire suppression systems in place here, they had neither.

The installed base of grid storage has increased more than 3000% over the last couple of years, yet the total number of failure events continues to fall.
 
The installed base of grid storage has increased more than 3000% over the last couple of years, yet the total number of failure events continues to fall.
It's as if technology and engineering was making things safer, like it does cars and planes (more than 100 times safer than they were 50 years ago) and medicines and houses (fire safety, wiring etc) and just about everything else.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Leo
get the powers that be focused on the real nub of the problems we have about water and electricity - wastage in the distribution networks.
Our water network loss rate was 49%. It's now 36%. The European average is around 25%.

We have a very old network, a very dispersed population and thanks to the morons who opposed water charges we have no meters to show where the leaks actually are. If want to get down to or below the European average we need meters and water charges and more investment.
Irish Water have actually done a great job considering the above constraints.

Our electricity Grid is very out of date. We have a one way grid designed to deliver electricity to homes and businesses. It was not designed to power electric cars or run heat pumps and it certainly wasn't designed for solar panels on homes and other buildings feeding electricity back into the grid.

Our decision to move to a very dispersed generation system (wind) means that power is generated far away from where it is used which puts an additional strain on the Grid.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Leo
Which specific claims as distinct from my direct quotes from news outlets?
Regarding nuclear, you said: 'its still impossible to make them safe and not just against earthquakes and the like.' while in fact current plants are extremely safe when compared to the alternatives..
 
Thanks you confirm all my points perfectly.

The morons in charge are investing in new ways of generating and sourcing resources that get wasted - .i.e they can't get them to consumers, to their point of usefulness. Waste, waste and more waste.
 
Regarding nuclear,
We don't need it, and I showed facts that demonstrate that its not safe, as we have more than enough electricity generation capability by all accounts, we can't use what we currently generate. Why waste more money?
 
I'm still waiting for that list of my ill-informed claims.
Care to explain why you think nuclear can't be made safe?

I presume you're unaware that the current death rate per terawatt hour for gas generation is 70 times that of nuclear?
 
Last edited:
we have no meters to show where the leaks actually are. If want to get down to or below the European average we need meters

The meters haven't gone away. They are still operating and Uisce Eireann does use radio technology to read them and identify where the leaks are occurring. Its why the waste has reduced from 49% to 36% without a single charge imposed.
 
Its why the waste has reduced from 49% to 36% without a single charge imposed.
Yes, it's disgraceful that there are no water charges. It just shows how our commitment to environmental protection is nothing more than lip service, as is talk about broadening the tax base. Utterly shameful.
 
It just shows how our commitment to environmental protection is nothing more than lip service

The waste has reduced from 49% to 36% and heading in the right direction, how is that 'nothing more than lip service'? It shows we are committed to reducing our water wastage which is primarily from underground water pipes and not from household consumption.

There is little evidence that I have seen that suggests household consumption is leading to any significant water waste. Hose-pipe bans are brought in during drier spells, and there are calls to reduce time spent in bathroom showers, but that's about it.

I dont think there has been any call to ban flushing toilets, boiling food, stop using washing machines, dish-washers etc?

*There is an open thread on water charges here https://www.askaboutmoney.com/threads/water-charges-back-on-the-agenda.223515/
The last few posts probably more appropriate there than in this thread.
 
Last edited:
I'm still waiting for that list of my ill-informed claims. :)
I presume you're unaware that the current death rate per terawatt hour for gas generation is 70 times that of nuclear?
Where did I suggest gas? As I said already, supported by facts, we have serious d-i-s-t-r-i-b-u-t-i-o-n problems, for both energy and water. Fix those and the need for new g-e-n-e-r-a-t-i-o-n or new 200 km cross-country water pipelines would disappear in the short to medium term, saving us and the planet. Those and my proposed energy capture and re-use for new and existing industrial sites will serve us and the planet favourably.
 
Meanwhile in other appalling water news ...

"More rivers in Ireland are deteriorating than improving according to the latest Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) assessment, while temporary beach closures caused by pollution incidents almost doubled last year.

Across the country, swimmers, anglers and businesses say those trends are being felt in very different ways, from repeated 'do not swim' notices to declining fish stocks and major fish kills.
"

"A report on water quality from Oonagh Smyth and producer/director Genevieve Brennan will be broadcast on the 30 July edition of Prime Time at 9.35pm on RTÉ One and RTÉ Player."

If you missed last night's programme it is on the RTE Player.
 
Where did I suggest gas?
We're talking about electricity generation, in an Irish context gas makes up the most of our supply so I just took it as an example.

I'm specifically addressing your claim that 'its still impossible' to make nuclear safe, when in fact even including past generation technology, it is safer than almost all others, including wind and solar.
 
Meanwhile, the Uisce Éireann contractors work the bank holiday weekend

"Uisce Éireann has said it is "well prepared" as it is due to carry out its largest ever repair this weekend.

It will repair up to 15 leaks on its supply line from Barrymore Eustis in Co Kildare to Saggart in Co Dublin.

The supply line carries over 200 million litres of water every day, one-third of all the supply to the Greater Dublin area
."

"Speaking on RTÉ's Morning Ireland, Uisce Éireann’s Regional Operations Senior Manager for Drinking Water for the East Region ..."

Now there's an impressive job-title, almost as good as some in the HSE. Best of luck over the week-end guys, I hope it goes well and helps save the Shannon area being decimated and the midlands getting ripped to shreds.

I'm specifically addressing your claim that 'its still impossible' to make nuclear safe, when in fact even including past generation technology,
And I've already stated, with evidence, that we don't have a generation problem, we have distribution problems, as with our water systems, which have quality problems as well. Also when quoting my posts, please give them the original context; there's important context ignored, repeatedly.
 
And you dragged gas into the thread for what specific reason?
We're talking about electricity generation, in an Irish context gas makes up the most of our supply so I just took it as an example.

Which example of electricity generation would you prefer I use to show your claim that nuclear energy can't be made safe is wrong?
 
I hope it goes well and helps save the Shannon area being decimated and the midlands getting ripped to shreds.
That's a lot of hyperbole for one sentence.
The proposed pipeline would take approximately 2% of the annual flow at the Parteen Basin (the proposed extraction point). What percentage of the population of the Dublin area are from the Shannon region? If the pipeline is not build should they all be sent home so that they can use their own water?

How would the midlands get "ripped to shreds" by laying a pipe?
 
Back
Top