Intel to create 'hundreds of jobs' with €5bn investment in Leixlip plant, announced 13th July 2026

Uisce Eireann CANNOT provide water. By their own admission on yesterday's news, 45% of this precious resource just leaks away in certain areas. The usual cop-out responses of course, "Oh, loike we inherited a crappy setup, under investment, for loike decades, so nothing to do with us, ya know? So loike, listen, yeah, our answer is to loike rob water from say 200 kms or so away from us and fix the problem that way." Yeah and then lose 45% of that because the old leaky pipes are still there.
The best water system in the world will "leak" water. The definition of leakage is varied and its near impossible to work out the rate in Ireland as most homes do not have a metered supply. Many farms and other heavy users can bypass the metered system for commercial users and this unmetered usage will show up as "leakage" - and its likely an anomaly figure like 45% is made up of some of this

In fairness to Irish water, the greater Dublin area has gone from over 40% to under 30% in the past few years which is a huge improvement, but no-one wants to mention that as it shows progress.

More has to be done and metering and monitoring all distribution points is needed. Funny, the likes of sinn fein who are jumping on this bandwagon and marking data centres as the culprit, would also rile up against the very meters that would pinpoint the leaks.
 
It's also worth remembering that most Nuclear Power Stations are very old.
Possibly because its still impossible to make them safe and not just against earthquakes and the like.

like citing Icarus as an argument against air travel.
Now you're really grasping at mythical straws for arguments, like the mythical safety of nuclear power. Why not talk instead about polluted and polluting discharges from them: water, air, spent nuclear fuels, and other radioactive detritus some with incredibly long half-lives? Windscale/Sellafield has been dumping some of that stuff into the Irish Sea for decades.
 
I'd be suggesting that the upgrades to Fab 34 and the other plans they have be stalled by the planning authority until Intel can produce a plan that includes making the new facilities net zero consumers of electricity and water.
If we are looking to close any industry due to the power and water it uses I give you Aughinish Alumina. Close it and Russia doesn't have a major source of Aluminium to use to build weapons to kill Ukrainians and the on site power station could power 200,000 homes. We'd also massively reduce the amount of fresh treated water available since it uses water from the national supply in its processing plant.
 
Possibly because its still impossible to make them safe and not just against earthquakes and the like.
How is that a reason to keep 70 year old power stations open.

Now you're really grasping at mythical straws for arguments, like the mythical safety of nuclear power.
I've given you the statistics. The data is readily available. Nuclear power is far less polluting and kills far fewer people than producing the same amount of power by burning hydrocarbons.

Why not talk instead about polluted and polluting discharges from them: water, air, spent nuclear fuels, and other radioactive detritus some with incredibly long half-lives?
Yes, all of that is relevant. The waste is stored in secure underground sites. The water and air are treated and monitored to ensure that they do not discharge radioactive particles. That is very different from hydrocarbon burning stations which discharge their waste into the atmosphere and kill millions of people.

Windscale/Sellafield has been dumping some of that stuff into the Irish Sea for decades.
Sellafield is still leaking radioactive waste from a containment unit built 70 years ago. The EPA say that it poses no meaningful risk to health and constitutes less that 1% of the radiation exposure of Irish residents.
 
Australia to enact special laws on data centres and AIs:

The new standards would set clear legal obligations for large data centres, requiring them to put more power into the electricity grid than they take out.

Also, in Ireland we don't know how much water data centres are using:

 
And we don't have numbers for people killed by radioactive fallout from accidents and incidents globally, as we don't have accurate figures for all the accidents and incidents, only those that happened to hit the headlines, like Fukushima, Three Mile Island, Chernobyl, Windscale/Sellafield, etc, and even for those the data for the spread of fall-out is vague, maybe deliberately
Perhaps you don't, but that doesn't mean no one has them! The UN have a committee dedicated to just this issue and multiple countries have detection and monitoring systems in place with a keen eye on their neighbours. You can't just hide a nuclear accident.

Chernobyl for example, they tried to cover that up but international monitoring resulted in the Kremlin being forced to admit the truth. There were 31 direct deaths in that incident with the WHO tracking radiation affects and estimating between 4,000 and 9,000 people will die prematurely as a result of cancer.
 
Also, in Ireland we don't know how much water data centres are using:
According to the article, only 24 data centres are connected to public supply.

The other near 70 must source their own supply.

Funny how sinn fein and loud mouth pbp types seem to ignore this.
 
The other near 70 must source their own supply.

Funny how sinn fein and loud mouth pbp types seem to ignore this.
Does the Australian government seem to be that type? Nope.

I have never voted for either of those parties but there are serious questions about data centre resource usage relative to their economic benefits.

And the exact figures I dont think that is clear from the article.

In 2021, 24 of Ireland’s 82 operational data centres were connected to the public water supply. The Water Forum, Ireland’s statutory body that advises the government on water policy, has said it may be a case that some of those 82 data centres “are small and fit under a different category of customers, or that single water connections may supply water to a number of data centres located on the same site”.
 
I have never voted for either of those parties but there are serious questions about data centre resource usage relative to their economic benefits.
There is also a broader strategic geopolitical consideration. Given the proliferation of data centres due to AI it is vitally important that Europe has lots of data centres. The best place for them is Iceland due to their free energy and cold climate and they have around a half as many as us with a population less than one tenth of ours. We are also a good location for many reasons and given that our tax base is built on MNC's locating here this is part of the price we pay for the taxes we charge.
 
There is also a broader strategic geopolitical consideration. Given the proliferation of data centres due to AI it is vitally important that Europe has lots of data centres
Then they should have a 'strategic' exemption for being assessed as part of what Ireland needs to cut from carbon emissions.
Data centres didn't really exist when that was being set.
If Ireland is to be a key 'strategic' base of them for the EU as a whole.

And I would see it different if an MNC is here with other operations bringing in revenue and jobs and tax and setting up data centre as part of that - which in fairness, Intel are in that category.
To an operation that just comes here for the data centre.
 
Because apparently it is "vitally important" that Europe has lots of data centres.
Data centres are resource intensive.
They were not even in consideration when carbon targets were being set.
This is a new "vitally important" strategic need for Europe.
We should be taking every effort in planning to make them as resource neutral as possible but there are constraints to that.

I would apply similar logic to other strategic initiatives eg if new military factories had to be set up.
 
Because apparently it is "vitally important" that Europe has lots of data centres.
Data centres are resource intensive.
They were not even in consideration when carbon targets were being set.
This is a new "vitally important" strategic need for Europe.
We should be taking every effort in planning to make them as resource neutral as possible but there are constraints to that.

I would apply similar logic to other strategic initiatives eg if new military factories had to be set up.
I think that Climate Change is the single biggest geographical, geopolitical and economic issue facing the planet and we must do whatever is required to cut our carbon emissions. There are plenty of ways to do that and have data centres and a proper military.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Leo
More waste - electricity this time

"Enough wind energy to power 667,000 homes, or roughly every household in Dublin, Westmeath and Wicklow combined, was lost in the first half of 2026 as the grid struggled to keep pace with Ireland's renewable energy growth, Wind Energy Ireland has said.

New analysis from Wind Energy Ireland, based on EirGrid figures, shows that significant volumes of renewable electricity generated by Irish wind farms could not be used because the electricity grid was not strong enough to carry it."

More wanton waste as the infrastructure to distribute electricity already being generated cannot get to the points of consumption because the grid is defective. Great news, in a way!

Now we can stop the conversion of perfectly good agricultural lands into silicon deserts with dangerous battery storage options, stop talking about nuclear options, and get the powers that be focused on the real nub of the problems we have about water and electricity - wastage in the distribution networks.

Get the Uisce Eireanns, Eirgrids, ESB Networks, the civil servants, relevant ministers off their collective superannuated butts and fix the real problems - put the valuable resources we already have and are already generating to productive use and enforce new planning conditions to build buffers for the future, and to avoid further environmental pollution.

No more new solar, no radioactivity, no robbing Lough Derg's waters for Dublin's sake and begin to green our little island again for a change.
 
Now we can stop the conversion of perfectly good agricultural lands into silicon deserts with dangerous battery storage options,
What issues have there been with battery storage in Ireland? Worldwide the last few years have seen a massive increase in installed battery storage capacity with no increase in fire rates.
 
Fire in Claregalway Co Galway and some of the firefighters involved fighting the battery fire have been unable to return to work.
 
Now we can stop the conversion of perfectly good agricultural lands into silicon deserts with dangerous battery storage options, stop talking about nuclear options, and get the powers that be focused on the real nub of the problems we have about water and electricity - wastage in the distribution networks.
We still don't have enough power for peak periods without backup battery and either reliable green energy (nuclear) or the burning of hydrocarbons (oil or gas).

Get the Uisce Eireanns, Eirgrids, ESB Networks, the civil servants, relevant ministers off their collective superannuated butts and fix the real problems - put the valuable resources we already have and are already generating to productive use and enforce new planning conditions to build buffers for the future, and to avoid further environmental pollution.
Maybe a pipeline to Dublin to help stop the Shannon flooding?

No more new solar,
What will we use instead?
Only 25% of our power is used by domestic consumers. There are 2.12 million homes in Ireland so enough electricity to power 667,000 homes is 31.5% of 25% or a little under 8% of our total demand.

no radioactivity,
I'd rather have safely stored radioactive materials than the pollution from burning hydrocarbons. Pollution caused by the burning of fossil fuels causes over 5 million excess deaths each year. Nobody dies from the generation of power by nuclear power stations.

no robbing Lough Derg's waters for Dublin's sake
Nobody is proposing that. You do realise that the water flows into Lough Derg and into the sea, right? The Shannon floods almost every year and had done forever, particularly since the Victorian era works on the river.
If there should be no pipeline should we stop people from the Shannon region moving to Dublin and using, sorry "robbing" the water supply in the Capital?

and begin to green our little island again for a change.
Get the sheep off the mountains and plant them with native hardwoods. Sheep create an ecological desert and are very harmful to the environment.

If you want to know how damaging farming can be just think that The Burren is a totally artifice environment and a result of soil erosion caused by Neolithic farmers clearing the native pine and Hazel. It is sustained by sheep grazing.

Therefore getting the sheep off the hills and mountains would do more than anything to help green our little island again.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top