Eid in Croke Park

There is.
That's not a law. That's in the Act. The law is determined through legislation and case law.
We've one Eastern Orthodox guy who takes the 7th of January off for their Christmas. We pay him for that too :eek:

Employees are entitled to equal treatment regardless if religious or not. Maybe you need a test case.
They are treated equally; they all get accommodated based on their needs and their value. If someone is an important employee and they have been working here for years they will get more latitude than someone who is just in the door and unskilled. We've no pay scales, no collective bargaining and an informal and casual atmosphere in the place. We know that that could potentially cause problems but it's worth it for a great working atmosphere where there are lots of laughs, a collective understanding of the needs of the business.
 
So we can all break any law and its ok until someone complains ?
The Equality Act specifies 9 protected grounds in relation to employment. It is against the law to discriminate against someone on the basis of any of those grounds. The way in which the law is applied is based on case law, since we use the British Common Law system. It has not been established in law that giving employees descressionary days off on an ad hoc basis is discrimination. Therefore doing so is legal until a case is taken and upheld by a court.

How do you get from that to "we can all break any law and its ok until someone complains"?
 
They are treated equally;
But they are not. If i am not religous i get less holidays in your workplace than my religous colleague.

You may have a great workplace atmosphere and fair dues for that but it is not operating within employment laws.
 
But they are not. If i am not religous i get less holidays in your workplace than my religous colleague.
If you have a sick mother you might get more time off too. Or if you have to go to the dentist more. Or if you have a sick child. Or a disabled spouse etc. You'll be expected to make up the time/get your work done when you get back to work. You'll have to ensure that your absence doesn't hold up production or effect invoicing.

You may have a great workplace atmosphere and fair dues for that but it is not operating within employment laws.
Probably not, you'd want to hear the slagging that goes on, but it's not because we give descressionary paid time off.
 
So we can all break any law and its ok until someone complains ?

No of course not, and I understand the sentiment in your position but you have come to a conclusion based on insufficient information.

Discriminatory case are broadly, not exclusively, based on the premise of denying access to, or denying provision of, some good or service, position or status.

If an employer provides access to time-off for Muslims to celebrate religious events then the question, to my mind would be, is access to celebrate religious events being denied to Christians, Hindu's, Jews etc.

For Christians in this country that is obviously not the case as the govt has legislated for paid time-off for such events, so perhaps the discrimination lies within government for failing to legislate for minority religions and paid time-off from work such as Eid?

In my workplace the ladies bathroom has a provision of three lock-door cubicles whereas the gents has only one lock-door and three on-the-wall urinals. Arguably, male colleagues are being discriminated against on gender grounds in the absence of providing similar privacy while attending the bathroom. On the flip-side, the employer does provide for a lock-door cubicle privacy in the male bathroom.

Until the argument is made, and upheld, then it is perfectly legal for the employer to provide discretionary one lock-door cubicle, to three lock-door cubicles in the gents/ladies.

What you are arguing more like, is unfavourable terms and conditions - the extra time-off, but as highlighted above there are many instances of discretionary time being provided for a whole plethora of reasons.
 
The law states that religion cannot be one of these reasons.
The argument could be made that the State is discriminating against people of other faiths by giving holidays to Christians on their holy days but not giving holidays on the special days of those other faiths. Isn't that discrimination based on religion?
 
The argument could be made that the State is discriminating against people of other faiths by giving holidays to Christians on their holy days but not giving holidays on the special days of those other faiths. Isn't that discrimination based on religion?
May well be but not the issue at hand. Employers can't take on to implement their own laws because they don't agree with those enacted by the state.
 
The Saudi's can fine you, deport you or imprison you if you are a non Muslim and you try to enter Mecca.
I believe that's a Saudi thing rather than Shariah law though.

Scrolling through the last couple of pages, I'm kinda sorry I started this thread. I thought it was wonderful that the HQ of our national games was being used for a purpose beyond what the founders of the GAA or perhaps even the founders of our State ever imagined, and that we could acknowledge and celebrate that, a purpose beyond the everyday, however uplifting mere sport and music can be.

The original topic and intent seems to have disappeared down a mink-hole. "A mink-hole, mathepac, what's that when it's at home?", you may ask. It's a bit like your normal labyrinthine rabbit-hole, but much more comfortable.
 
And I am very relaxed, just sometimes feel the need to call out the virtuous.
I don't think you would last long running a modern manufacturing Business if you were in charge of
employees,
Or should I say the business would not last long,
 
Last edited:
Back
Top