Eid in Croke Park

mathepac

Registered User
Messages
9,535
Wonderful to see our Islamic sisters and brothers celebrate one of their important religious festivals in Croker today.

I was surprised to see how few people were actually there, praying on the grass, but I assume that as some of these festivals follow the lunar rather than our Gregorian calendar, arranging for time off work, from school, etc could have been problematic. I don't know enough about the beliefs / festival of followers of Islam to know how they might organise this.

I hope the facilities were appropriate for the event.
 
Eid al-Fitr (small Eid) was on the 20th of March this year. It is a celebration of the end of Ramadan. We give our Muslim employees the day off with pay that day (if it's a week day).
Eid al-Adha (big Eid) was yesterday. It commemorates the Prophet Ibrahim.It lasts three days.

Eid just means Feast.
 
But they are public hols so the Muslims get them too surely..
We're very flexible, we find that if you are nice to people and accommodate them they are accommodating in return so, for example, when we need people to work Easter Bank holiday weekend (we run 24/7) then the people who don't celebrate Easter, either socially or spiritually, are more likely to volunteer.
That and our current holidays reflect a bygone era when most of the population of the country were Catholics (as opposed to being culturally Catholic).
 
We're very flexible, we find that if you are nice to people and accommodate them they are accommodating in return so, for example, when we need people to work Easter Bank holiday weekend (we run 24/7) then the people who don't celebrate Easter, either socially or spiritually, are more likely to volunteer.
Doesn't make sense. Correct me if im wrong but one set of employees are still getting an extra holiday? Why would you not give everyone an extra holiday of their choosing. Or else give everyone Eid day off.
 
Thanks, I knew there was more than one, just unsure how many, but did know that visiting Mecca was a big one, for many, a once-in-a-lifetime experience.
But you have to be a Muslim to go there. The Saudi's can fine you, deport you or imprison you if you are a non Muslim and you try to enter Mecca.
 
Why would you not give everyone an extra holiday of their choosing.
People take time off all the time to suit their personal needs. They go to medical appointments, parent teacher meetings, to let someone into the house with a delivery etc and then they come back and work harder or work late or skip a break to catch up. They all get paid for that time out. Then when they need to work late, work a weekend etc they reciprocate. I find that, contrary to @cremeegg's view, if you treat people like adults and give then flexibility and agency they reciprocate.
 
They all get paid for that time out. Then when they need to work late, work a weekend etc they reciprocate. I find that, contrary to @cremeegg's view, if you treat people like adults and give then flexibility and agency they reciprocate.
Thats grand. I'm sure that policy applies to everyone there. But on top of that a set of employees are getting an extra days holidays on religous grounds. That is against the law.
 
The employment equality acts. But you know that.
I do know it. That's an act. I asked you what law you were referring to.
There's nothing in the act or related laws that says employers cannot give descressionary days off to employees so that they can celebrate religious holidays.

And I am very relaxed, just sometimes feel the need to call out the virtuous.
Well done. I sometimes feel the need to call out people who think they are virtuous by calling out people whom they think are virtuous.

I don't see any difference between anyone's invisible friend in the sky. To me religions are all just different forms of crazy but if that's what gives you comfort and helps you get through the day then have at it.

I don't see why people should get time off for Easter, when every tomb in Jerusalem opened and the dead walked the earth (did they die again or are the still rockin' around the place somewhere?), but not for any other such nonsense from any other primitive tribal writings.
 
Last edited:
T
There's nothing in the act or related laws that says employers cannot give descressionary days off to employees so that they can celebrate religious holidays.
There is. Employees are entitled to equal treatment regardless if religious or not. Maybe you need a test case.
I don't see why people should get time off for Easter
They get holidays because the govt has designated them as public holidays.
 
That is against the law.
The employment equality acts.

I think that is a gross misinterpretation of the law. Something may be considered discriminatory in nature but until it is found to be discriminatory then there is no breach of the equality acts.

Until such time as someone actually complains about the discrimination, and that complaint is upheld as discriminatory, then it is perfectly legal for an employer to deploy whatever discretionary arrangements they see fit for their staff even if it is on grounds of religion, gender etc.
 
Back
Top