CharlieMac
Registered User
- Messages
- 532
If this would stop me having to get cash out of the ATM to pay my barber for a haircut then I'm all for it. Don't use cash or coins for anything else.
I don't think "trust" comes into it. Trust isn't involved with the original ECB currency - notes and coin, except for the possibility of counterfeit and I think even that possibility is eliminated with a digital currency.In low trust transactions
For sure the concept of a current account would seem redundant. But Fractional Reserve Banking is much more driven by their deposit base. People with surplus digital euro will still seek interest rates on commercial bank deposits. I think the grand plan is that the ECB might indeed pay interest or even charge interest on its digital euro, but only in its role of monetary management not as a competitor with the commercial banks.What I like about the idea is the separation of payments from lending institutions.
Not sure about that. It wasn't their current account liabilities that made them too big to fail and as I suggest above the ECB will facilitate an active commercial deposit taking banking sector. This is an essential aspect of our economy - the magic of FRB and the ECB are not going to destroy it.They banks are hopefully then no longer too big to fail and can be let do so the next time they blow themselves up.
This will not change. As I have said the banks' current accounts are a minor player in whether a bank goes bust, it is their deposit base that makes them vulnerable to a run.The threat of a bank run where people choose cash instead plays a part in keeping the current system honest.
Doesn't sound like bitcoin (where all you need is an internet connection and a phone/computer) or cash (where all you need is the side pocket of your jeans).From centralbank.ie:
You would be able to open a digital euro account at a bank or any other payment service provider
They are not required to monitor what you do with the pound in your pocket and they will have no responsibility for what you do with your digital euro. One of the disappointments as far as I am concerned is this commitment to privacy. I saw it as a perfect way to reduce or at least detect crime.they will be legally mandated to keep an eye on what you do with your money
I'd be highly skeptical of that. If its a digital currency, it will have a digital footprint4) The same privacy as cash payments
There will be no record of the transaction.
I think it would be a very useful to reduce or detect crime. I would be highly skeptical that there are no provisions for such in a digital currency. In other words, complete privacy unless there is a suspicion of criminal activity.One of the disappointments as far as I am concerned is this commitment to privacy. I saw it as a perfect way to reduce or at least detect crime.
I don't think "trust" comes into it. Trust isn't involved with the original ECB currency - notes and coin
My reading of this thread + some googling is that there's no firm/precise committment to privacy (not counting vague statements).One of the disappointments as far as I am concerned is this commitment to privacy
I've never understood the privacy argument against spending on cards. They may know how much you've spent in Dunnes, Boots and Amazon but they've no idea what you've bought.My larger expenditures are all documented on my AIB bank statement anyway
I don’t think double spending can arise with a central currency. When you flash your AIB debit card at the till AFAIK AIB instantly reduce your account balance and you can’t spend that money again. With a decentralised currency on an open source platform there needs time for everyone to agree that you owned the coin. An essential feature of Bitcoin is that when after say 10 minutes the miners have agreed you owned the coin your transfer to a new owner is recorded on the ledger and ithe coin remains traceable back to its creation.@Brendan Burgess did mention "There will be no record of the transaction.", however, I don't see how that could possibly work, as there needs to be a record in order to prevent double-spending. Even Bitcoin has a ledger where all transactions are recorded
Dunnes, Boots and Amazon know, though. (As an aside, that's the main reason that retailers run loyalty programmes — so they can harvest that information and monetize it in various ways.)I've never understood the privacy argument against spending on cards. They may know how much you've spent in Dunnes, Boots and Amazon but they've no idea what you've bought.
Boss I was starting to ask myself "what is the point of this CBDC?". The commercial banks have really optimised digital money transmission, I can't see how CBDC will make it more efficient. It will not compete with commercial banks in terms of the interest, if any, that is credited so no big change to the general role of our commercial banks including leveraging off the deposit base to finance industry.I attended an ECB webinar this morning on this topic. I knew nothing about it.