Dog Barking Nuisance

Status
Not open for further replies.

Lone Star

Registered User
Messages
332
Hey there, we've had an ongoing issue with a neighbour (A nasty character) - his dogs are left out 24 hours a day, 365 days a year, snow days included. One is a Samoyed who barks incessantly (a rate of 45 barks per minute) I'm 5 doors away but sound carries, you could be kept awake until 1, 2, 3, 4 am, or if you happened to get to sleep through the 11.30 pm barking - then you will almost certainly be woken in the early hours. Have tried everything and it turns out only a civil action will attempt to come to some sort of remedy - and it will boil down to the flavour of the Judge on the day - in some cases they order dogs to be surrendered - and in others that the dog owner is given x amount of time to remedy situation.

I've tried to rally neighbours and at least 10 are affected and annoyed and kept awake.....at the start they were all for getting something done...and one by one....they've all dropped off - have people no backbone?

I had called to the owners house 3 years ago and nicely asked could they do something - I just got told - yeah it's terrible, the barking wakes our baby, since then I texted...his replies became nasty and menacing. But lately and To keep a fresh record and build some evidence for court (as suggested by the council) I recently sent some texts, turns out his dogs got out recently (he took to social media and blamed me for his dogs going missing/stolen), he followed me on evening in my car, blocked me across the road and my 2 year old was with me, he obviously got the dogs back as they are barking non stop again. that was 2 weeks ago - I texted twice in the last 2 nights...I woke up to two Slashed Tyres this morning. Ahead of going to my solicitor - if anyone has any experience of a nuisamce barking case getting good success in court - I'm all ears, and also can I bring in the recent events - or is that just hearsay? Gardaí said very little they can do because there is no proof - they sent out crime scene guy to take photos.....what a palava
 
I have some experience....however I sold the property and moved on.

The process I followed prior to giving up and selling up was to contact the dog warden ( who was not interested ).

Contact the property owner by e mail, phone and personal contact ( who was not interested )

You are left with taking a civil action to the District Court, you must gather a history of the barking which must be nuisance and excessive barking, pictures are good as is audio, recording on your phone is good. You must build a history of the nuisance with dates and time, and follow it through.

All very unsatisfactory from your point of view of course, it is wrong that an individual must take the dog owner to Court without any interest from the dog warden.

I'm a dog owner and could not imagine being so unrespectful of my local community and immediate neighbours, sometimes enforcement is the right course.

Nuisance, excessive barking that is ignored by the people who could stop it is indefenceable
 
Thanks Palerider - I have become the villain now for speaking out.
I have kept a record since 07 January, and my little boy's 2nd birthday was a tired day as both parents had been kept awake until 4am...I moved to front room only to be kept awake by another set until 5am.
I have Audio.
Afraid now to take photos - unless we buy a drone.
I have emails from 6 other residents - detailing times and also door to door 'communications' - one woman said it has gone on 9 years - yet hasn't knocked on his door as she is afraid she would get anrgy??????????????
I want to sell up at some stage - but hadn't quite planned to move just yet - so after 15 years I feel shoved out of my lovely home.
Dpg Warden's hands are tied to control of dogs act. Most he can do is call to house for us and have a chat...problem is he only works 9-5 mon to fri -so won't ever get the man in the house.
Gardaí can do nothing - yet they tried to drill into me today - that is's up to the warden...I explained...then they said - well the council have to do something..i explained...I explained all and said only route is civil case - but with two slashed tyres after some texts - what happens after a court case!
This barking is crazy stuff - the particular breed is so high pitch - it goes through you. I'm off upstairs now to pad up my bedroom window with patio cushions, foam and all sorts. The other resort is sleep on floor in ensuite! (no windows and between two rooms.

I wonder will a judge take into account the coincidental criminal damage and defamatory comments on social media.

What gets me - is people say - it's an estate - what do you expect?? Eh Peace and Quiet like I give - who do I wake up - no one.

Thanks for reply!!
 
I think this is one of the least recognised social problems around.

The number of people who suffer from antisocial dogs must be huge.

Perhaps you need to find other victims of other dogs. Try talking to a politician.
 
TD has been informed and asked for help. Noise Pollution is going to be one of the next 'big things' - has huge impact on sleep, health and productivity - even relationships etc. I'm exhausted with that and the amount of time I've invested into going door to door, trying all avenues and then feeling brow beat by the people who say one minute - they'll support you and oh yes it's terrible, and then they wince out of it.... Laws in Ireland re Dogs in general needs to be brought into the 21st Century - a shame that ONLY avenue for normal joe soaps affected is to take inconsiderate sadistic warts like this chap to court. Thanks Cremeegg. My first non-bank post! I think it was easier!!
 
Last edited:
Hello,

My own dog was causing problems with barking a few years ago. I was not aware of it because it was happening while I was at work during the daytime, but as soon as my neighbour told me about the problem, I got one of these collars. It quickly helped to solve the problem (complimented with more exercise for the dog before I went to work, so he was tired for much of the day).

I wonder if the owner would permit their dogs to wear these collars, if yourself and a few other neighbours bought them between you ? While I appreciate that it's frustrating to think that you might have to pay for collars, it's far cheaper than taking legal action and it might provide a faster solution (not to mention, help avoid further difficulties with the dog owner) :)

Have a look on the PetSafe website, there's a download link to allow comparisons between their products. There's also a contact us page, so perhaps give them a call and see what they might recommend, if you can't get a collar on the dogs.

There are also other sonic anti bark devices, but I have never used them. After a very quick search online, I found [broken link removed] for example. There are no guarantees that it would work, but it may be worth a try if you can't get your neighbour to agree to the collars.
 
Last edited:
The sonic devices available on eBay are effective but you need to get close enough directionally to ensure you are ' aiming ' it into the desired area, definitely try this out, it is non invasive and once you keep it to yourself the issue should resolve with the dog owner nit having awareness of your counter measures, spend some money on the quality of the device, do your homework.

I have a neighbour at the rear of my house that allows his dog bark from before 7 am, I'm going to get one of these myself, your post has spurred me on to take action.
 
I wonder has he got a dog licence? A visit from a guard might decide that one but it will also put him on alert that he's getting attention, even if he has the licence. He needs one for each dog.
 
Dogs barking - Council issue, get a group together and make a collection of individual complaints about the same dogs at the same address. Maybe you can complain as a residents' association, I'll check
Slashed tyres - Garda issue. Make a report of criminal damage, get a PULSE number and ask for night-time patrols
Dog licence - warden, unless there is evidence of worrying livestock

If the owner is intimidating residents in the estate, gather evidence, make statements to the Guards, tell them to address it, as the dog owner is putting you in fear and making you feel unsafe (if indeed he is). If nothing happens, write to the local Garda Superintendent.

There is no such thing as an anti-social dog. By their very nature, they, like us, are social animals. There may be unsocialised dogs, caused by humans who won't invest in training their dogs or whose parents didn't invest in training them.

The use of shock-collars, sonic and other punishment devices on dogs and other animals is simply outright animal cruelty, inhumane and savagery. Properly socialised dogs bark, growl, whine in order to communicate with their owners / other dogs. Punish a dog for communicating naturally and he may resort to violence (biting) as the only means of communication left to him. When dogs bark incessantly, there is something wrong in their environment, in their training or with their owner.

Why do some humans unaccountably expect all dogs to spring from the womb fully house-trained, socialised and with clear insight into their owners' expectations of them? My children had to be potty trained, taught table manners, etc I don't remember having to electrocute them or otherwise treat them cruelly for the odd transgression.

I own large breed dogs, I trained them, puppies or adult rescues, with professionals (owners who do this learn very quickly that the owner needs more training than the dogs, ask any registered trainer), I participate in donkey, cat and dog rescues, fund rehoming for rescue dogs, am active and mod online specialist breed forums, am an activist to for the abolition of the stupid, ill-informed breed specific legislation and so on. I know dogs and I know people. The dog is never to blame.
 
Many thanks Mr Earl - the only problem is we are dealing with a man who leaves his dogs out 24/7, Slashed my Car Tyres following two nights I texted him - he wouldn't agree to collars or a device. The nicely nicely approach didn't work. I mentioned same to neighbours, re collars/device in one of their gardens as I'm too far out of rang - suggested buying one and no one was putting hand in pocket....they were all for action and now are limping off..racking up now for me this week alone with 2 tyres, cctv being installed and oodles of time.
 
It's a sad situation:
The Samoyed is out back 9 years, The Labrador; the owner got to keep the Samoyed quiet he said!
They are in a sectioned off portion of his back garden, 6 foot walls, Lab can hop on kennel to see out
It's not the Dogs' fault at all
Dogs never walked
I've spoke with many residents - lots agree it's a big problem
Since then - they have all fallen by wayside, hosted a meeting in my house - 2 turned up
Dog Warden can't act in this regard, nor ISPCA, Nor Council, Nor Gardaí (Have been onto all)
Civil Action only route
Dog owner is not in any way reasonable
 
Oh god - I don't even have to google the above - I wouldn't dream of it. I've taken in strays and helped rehome. I certainly would not act in any such way towards two poor dogs. (Or maybe it was meant for the owner?!?!!)

I've found it quite difficult to find cases re barking nuisance (successful or unsuccessful) and then enforcement - yip - that's the next hurdle if a favourable decision were to be made...

I wonder if the Small Claims Court covers this - I could claim for nuisance? on a monthly basis! I'm off sick this week and needed a sleep this afternoon - the main dog was barking constantly today from the morning - For a sleep I actually made up a bed on floor of my ensuite!!

In terms of future sale (The area out front is at least quieter and cleaner now) - a house that was let out to a family with two other barking dogs recently moved out - I was blamed for that as I had got in touch with Animal Welfare and let other neighbours know the state of the back yard - which was a filth pit of at least one month's dog defecation. I am currently the pariah - they soon forget that they themselves asked those same tenants to do something about the barking as do they soon forget about clean ups of the Green I organised last summer, complete with prizes, sponsored refreshments from local Supermacs/Papa Johns and helping organise the children with a door to door fundraising effort to raise enough for a set of Goalposts to use on the Green and taking them off the road and the ball out of many gardens.

I wouldn't say the address and court would attach? Unless of course in the local paper's court section..It's a lovely house and one of nicest sites so sale shouldn't be a problem. I took on a bank and yet am getting shoved out of my home effectively by some half brain with no respect for people around him.
 
It has to be the District Court but I would be reluctant to go that route, try the device on eBay, go online now and do your research, if you have to get a garden electrical socket installed to get the device closer to the dogs then do that, covert counter measures are what you need, bring out your inner James Bond, the smart solution might just work for you.

Don't worry about harming the dogs, they are not cruel and will help train them in due course to reduce their vocal abilities.
 
.... The dog is never to blame.

While I agree with a large amount of what you have posted above, you are wrong about one point - sometimes, the dog is to blame ! There are troubled dogs, just like there are troubled people. It's sadly, a simple fact of life.

I have personally completed numerous dog training, socialisation and agility courses, spent time at seminars with dog behaviourists, taken on a problem dog and successfully developed him into a household pet etc.

I also have first hand experience with large breeds, appreciate that training and regular exercise play a vital part of ensuring that you, your neighbors and your dog all have a pleasant co-existence, but the reality of this situation is that the barking dogs are not being looked after properly, and Lone Star is not in a position to take on the responsibilities of the dog owner, to exercise them, train them etc.

You talk about the use of sonic aids as "outright animal cruelty, inhumane and savagery", well that's just nonsense. Go and do some research on the aids that I have linked to above, they are training aids and not instruments of torture, or whatever else you might like to call them. There are separate, unrelated devices that give a dog an electric shock when they bark, that's not what I've recommended be used here. Perhaps you are confusing the two unrelated items ?
 
Last edited:
Many thanks Mr Earl - the only problem is we are dealing with a man who leaves his dogs out 24/7, Slashed my Car Tyres following two nights I texted him - he wouldn't agree to collars or a device. The nicely nicely approach didn't work. I mentioned same to neighbours, re collars/device in one of their gardens as I'm too far out of rang - suggested buying one and no one was putting hand in pocket....they were all for action and now are limping off..racking up now for me this week alone with 2 tyres, cctv being installed and oodles of time.

Frustrating as it may be to find yourself almost alone in this, I'd go and spend a few quid to try the likes of the birdhouse if you can get one of the next door neighbours to allow you position it in their garden, near the dogs. There seems to be a couple of models, if you do a little research on the web and while there are no guarantees that it will work, it just might. If there's any level of success, then it's worth doing and perhaps even justification for then getting a second one and positioning it somewhere else (to cover another part of the offending parties garden). For €70-€80, it may be money very well spent - far cheaper than legal remedies, and not confrontational given the dog owner won't even know what it is, assuming no one tells him.
 
All the "bark control" devices result in unpleasant consequences for the dog upon barking. They may be electric shocks, offensive smells, unpleasant high-frequency noises, disturbing vibrations around the neck throat or frightening liquid sprays. Anything that punishes, deters or frightens a dog for barking is cruel and abusive and may result in a dog whose only recourse is to biting. It is punishment used as deterrent, certainly cruel and undoubtedly inhumane.
 
Human needs will always come before Doggie needs.

Having a human bunk down on the floor to get peace enough to sleep inside their home which typically takes 20 years to Pay for trumps the needs of any animal, needs by the way that are the responsibility of the owner.

Sleep deprivation is awful, I can still remember my kids when they were babies requiring night feeds, we were walking zombies, you must get enough rest to function and nuisance dog barking can become much more than a nuisance.
 
Palerider - I had just gotten over a year and a half of sleep deprivation with my baby last July - then once that was over - I started to re-notice the barking - it's actually worse than the baby years! Wrecked isn't the word sometimes. My lovely house - what a shame - it used to be so blissfully quiet here!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top