Data center electricity use

peemac

Registered User
Messages
2,295
SF rant ahead...

Was listening to Newstalk yesterday when Lynn Boylan was harping on about data center water usage and in denial that its a a tiny fraction of water produced despite verifiable figures provided and the fact that dat center can recycle water and use fans for cooling - really surprised Shane Coleman didn't press her harder on this (he could have had a "European Parliament" moment with her :D ) . She also threw in the old chestnut of data centers using a quarter of electricity and paying a lower price than households. But do they?

Data centers pay approx. 19c a unit for electricity. (sf love to quote this figure and then compare it to the non discounted peak rate of 37c which "YOU" are paying)

I checked my bill from Jan/Feb. My average rate was 19.3c a unit. So, little me, with a house in rural Ireland using about 600kw of electricity a month am paying the same price as data centers! As are hundreds of thousands of households with a smart meter and a discounted plan who take advantage of low rates between 11pm & 8am


Its a pity journalists are not like journalists of old and delve into figures and challenge narratives of interested groups.

Using back of envelope calculations and verifiable electricity generation figures, Daytime electricity use by Data centers is about 14-16% of generation. Night-time use is 40%-50% of generation as night generation is about 65% lower than daytime.

What sf "forget" is that data centers use similar amounts of electricity every hour of the day AND night. And whilst they may use 23% of generated electricity on an overall basis, it's about 15% of peak generation - substantial, but not the big bad wolf sf would make them out to be. And their average rate of 19c is similar to what any household would pay if they had a similar 24 hour usage pattern.

So, yes, data centers are big users of electricity, but during daytime when electricity use is at its peak, its a 15% load on the grid and not the "quarter" that gets quoted. And the rate of 19c is attainable by any domestic user with the same usage pattern.

Doesn't make headlines
 
Great post @peemac. It is a pity that Journalism is now opinion led rather than fact and data driven. There was a time when the aim was for journalists to go and find the news and reporters to then report the news. Once that happened the public formed an opinion of the news or they read opinion pieces from people who didn't claim to be journalists.

Now we get the "journalist's" opinion of part of the news and that's about it.
 
Their use of resources is out of all proportion to the economic benefits and employment they bring to the country.
Multiple jurisdictions are bringing in heavy restrictions on data centres and we should do likewise. This isn't some sort of SF lone run.
They are using 23% of generated electricity. They aren't bringing in any where near 23% of employment, tax, revenue etc to justify that.

And anyhow, already discussed on a very recent thread.
 
Multiple jurisdictions are bringing in heavy restrictions on data centres and we should do likewise.
What other country refers to itself as a jurisdiction?

Few other countries make as much money from the companies who use data centres.
 
What other country refers to itself as a jurisdiction?

Few other countries make as much money from the companies who use data centres.
I don't know? But the state of New York isn't a country and it has announced restrictions.
Australia has also, and the central government are over-ruling state governments on this.
So jurisdiction seems a valid collective word to use here.

"The prime minister has explicitly flagged that data centres will need to create more jobs beyond those generated during their construction phase."


There's no direct link between the companies that are bringing in revenues and the data centre operators. We could be stuck with energy intensive data centres after major MNCs leave.

Any new data centres should be carbon neutral and more than that, not grab an undue share of the green energy the rest of the economy needs and displace domestic users into use of carbon based energy.
Any existing data centres that do not meet that standard should be levied accordingly.
Or else if they need to be co-located with a major MNC facility, perhaps that could be taken into account with tax credits.
 
There's no direct link between the companies that are bringing in revenues and the data centre operators. We could be stuck with energy intensive data centres after major MNCs leave.
There's a limited direct link but there's a strong indirect link. We are part of the EU and we are building an interconnector with France. The question is not what use Data Centres are to Ireland, rather it is what use they are to the EU?
The answer to that is obvious and it makes that connectivity to the mainland more important for the rest of the EU.
80% of the data cables between Ireland the the EU go through Ireland and Irish Waters. We have a cool stable climate. We are politically stable. Those are all very good reasons for Data Centres to locate here.


Any new data centres should be carbon neutral and more than that, not grab an undue share of the green energy the rest of the economy needs and displace domestic users into use of carbon based energy.
Once we have the interconnector with France up and running we'll have access to their clean and green nuclear power.
 
They are using 23% of generated electricity.
Most countries create excess electricity from 9pm to 8am. On windy nights (plenty of them in Ireland) the excess electricity literally is thrown away as currently there is no way to store it. Many of the gas generators have to operate at night to ensure stability of supply - in a way Data Centers assist that stability due to their very even load (less that 5% variance from peak to trough) and therefore very easy to forecast their use months in advance.

The only "logjam" which is not any where near what it was 3 / 4 years ago as a lot more generation has come on stream, is daytime peak hours - and at those times data centers use about 15% of generate electricity - even less at premium peak of 5-7pm

I also don't agree with these endless charts showing highest electricity prices as they are based on non-discounted rates. But i do disagree with the "tescoisation"(new word I've just invented :p) of pricing where a high unit price is quoted, but it is then discounted by up to 39% (Energia last Feb) if you change supplier or negotiate with current supplier.

A lower headline rate and a max 10%-15% loyalty/ new customer discount would bring Irish rates closer to the average EU rate.

I did a check on the Netherlands - Lowest offer price for a new customer 28.1c and the off peak is only slightly lower at 26c. A mere 1.4c off their standard rate. That's more expensive than my current rates with Energia. Fixed costs are lower at €127 a year v €250 here. But looking at the "table" you think Netherlands is 24% cheaper than Ireland.
 
Their use of resources is out of all proportion to the economic benefits and employment they bring to the country.
They are simply paying the going rate for resources that are available to every sector though.

If we are to start penalising or discriminating against sectors based on aggregate benefits, I'd think we should go after the ones that are poisoning our air and water first.
 
If we are to start penalising or discriminating against sectors based on aggregate benefits, I'd think we should go after the ones that are poisoning our air and water first.
We are already down that road, with the national carbon budget.
 
And the rate of 19c is attainable by any domestic user with the same usage pattern.

Can domestic users write down the 19c per unit as domestic living costs against taxes they are liable to pay on gross income?

I've nothing against data centers but I think this issue is typically bandied about in terms of "nothing really to see here" and "they are eating all our electricity". The reality is somewhere in the middle.

Certainly 23% usage, or even 15% peak consumption time, is a significant amount that feeds into a sector that is relatively tiny in the grand scheme of things.

I think raising red-flags on this is useful. It brings attention to the matter, and when the spotlight is on then there is a better chance of finding reasonable outcomes in my opinion.
 
I think raising red-flags on this is useful. It brings attention to the matter, and when the spotlight is on then there is a better chance of finding reasonable outcomes in my opinion.
There seems to be a "how dare they even discuss this" attitude in certain quarters. "We'll tell them our version of what we deem it necessary for them to know and there's an end to it!"
 
Last edited:
Lynn Boylan was harping on about data center water usage and in denial that its a a tiny fraction of water produced despite verifiable figures provided and the fact that dat center can recycle water and use fans for cooling
Date centres and others who use water cooling and water recycling, discharge the heated air produced to the atmosphere; that's hardly green in any sense.
 
Who here has suggested refusing water or electricity to existing operators?
Not referencing anyone here but the overall debate where the opposition, environmental groups, trade unions and others are calling for such measures.
 
Date centres and others who use water cooling and water recycling, discharge the heated air produced to the atmosphere; that's hardly green in any sense.
Green/Environment and Sinn Fein are rarely heard in the same sentence.

sinn fein's only reasoning for bringing data centers into the water argument is because they can quote a big number - up to FIVE MILLION LITRES every day. This gets their primarily low-brow voter base riled up and that's all they want. Hasn't really worked for them this time

That Irish water and others points out that 675 Million litres are used nationally every day and even the highest figure sinn fein can manage to obtain, represents about 0.7% of water produced is of no consequence to their propaganda machine.

They make zero comment on the environmental figures.
 
Can domestic users write down the 19c per unit as domestic living costs against taxes they are liable to pay on gross income?
any person with business use can apply all business related costs against their income. Makes no difference whether you are a datacenter or a micro business operating from your home. If the use is business related its a deductible expense.

If you "work from home" you can also claim partial relief from income tax. - So answer is yes, once its business/work replated
 
Back
Top