SF rant ahead...
Was listening to Newstalk yesterday when Lynn Boylan was harping on about data center water usage and in denial that its a a tiny fraction of water produced despite verifiable figures provided and the fact that dat center can recycle water and use fans for cooling - really surprised Shane Coleman didn't press her harder on this (he could have had a "European Parliament" moment with her
) . She also threw in the old chestnut of data centers using a quarter of electricity and paying a lower price than households. But do they?
Data centers pay approx. 19c a unit for electricity. (sf love to quote this figure and then compare it to the non discounted peak rate of 37c which "YOU" are paying)
I checked my bill from Jan/Feb. My average rate was 19.3c a unit. So, little me, with a house in rural Ireland using about 600kw of electricity a month am paying the same price as data centers! As are hundreds of thousands of households with a smart meter and a discounted plan who take advantage of low rates between 11pm & 8am
Its a pity journalists are not like journalists of old and delve into figures and challenge narratives of interested groups.
Using back of envelope calculations and verifiable electricity generation figures, Daytime electricity use by Data centers is about 14-16% of generation. Night-time use is 40%-50% of generation as night generation is about 65% lower than daytime.
What sf "forget" is that data centers use similar amounts of electricity every hour of the day AND night. And whilst they may use 23% of generated electricity on an overall basis, it's about 15% of peak generation - substantial, but not the big bad wolf sf would make them out to be. And their average rate of 19c is similar to what any household would pay if they had a similar 24 hour usage pattern.
So, yes, data centers are big users of electricity, but during daytime when electricity use is at its peak, its a 15% load on the grid and not the "quarter" that gets quoted. And the rate of 19c is attainable by any domestic user with the same usage pattern.
Doesn't make headlines
Was listening to Newstalk yesterday when Lynn Boylan was harping on about data center water usage and in denial that its a a tiny fraction of water produced despite verifiable figures provided and the fact that dat center can recycle water and use fans for cooling - really surprised Shane Coleman didn't press her harder on this (he could have had a "European Parliament" moment with her
Data centers pay approx. 19c a unit for electricity. (sf love to quote this figure and then compare it to the non discounted peak rate of 37c which "YOU" are paying)
I checked my bill from Jan/Feb. My average rate was 19.3c a unit. So, little me, with a house in rural Ireland using about 600kw of electricity a month am paying the same price as data centers! As are hundreds of thousands of households with a smart meter and a discounted plan who take advantage of low rates between 11pm & 8am
Its a pity journalists are not like journalists of old and delve into figures and challenge narratives of interested groups.
Using back of envelope calculations and verifiable electricity generation figures, Daytime electricity use by Data centers is about 14-16% of generation. Night-time use is 40%-50% of generation as night generation is about 65% lower than daytime.
What sf "forget" is that data centers use similar amounts of electricity every hour of the day AND night. And whilst they may use 23% of generated electricity on an overall basis, it's about 15% of peak generation - substantial, but not the big bad wolf sf would make them out to be. And their average rate of 19c is similar to what any household would pay if they had a similar 24 hour usage pattern.
So, yes, data centers are big users of electricity, but during daytime when electricity use is at its peak, its a 15% load on the grid and not the "quarter" that gets quoted. And the rate of 19c is attainable by any domestic user with the same usage pattern.
Doesn't make headlines