Case study Built a free Irish pension calculator — would value feedback from people here

@dubliner
Thanks, really appreciate that, and good catches on both.

Fund names getting cut off: fair point, the long Royal London names are hard to tell apart in that dropdown. I'll get that fixed so you can see the full name.

Good spot, in the Royal London figures. I need to look into the others a bit deeper, since a lot of providers have their own official data and the same fund can show up under different IDs.
 
Can you allow partner to have a different AVC pension product?
Allow different AVCs to have current pot values? Allow Defined Benefit scheme to include lump sum amount payable at age pension is taken?
Allow Public Sector pension linked to salary?
 
Interesting!

3 Comments

1. Value of my partner pension was inputted at €82k (No additional contributions) but in the results summary was expressed as ~€67k.

2. In the Retire tab you ask for the monthly or annual spend….but you say this is pre tax. I know my spend rate, but I express it as a net figure. A net spend would be better, I think.

3. Related to No.2 - The net spend will change for the GoGo years, the GoSlow years & the NoGo years. Can this scaling be factored in?
 
For lump sum at retirement allow option of a set amount from AVC. This would allow those following revenue rules of upto 1.5 times final salary when retiring without full service to use AVCs tax efficiently.
 
Thanks, great points. @Uafásach
  1. That's their lump sum. If your partner can already draw their pension while you're still working, their 25% comes out then, so the pot shown was after it. The card now says so, e.g. "after a €20,500 lump sum at 60".
  2. Fair point, but net is hard to do well because tax in retirement depends on so much: married or single, a spouse with no income, kids, age credits, the over-65 exemption, USC. For now it's before tax, so I'd gross your net spend up a bit. I'd rather add net properly than guess.
  3. Done. On the retire tab you can now spend less as you get older (go-go, slow-go, no-go), or more later for care.
 
@Yarm01
Good point. Right now the lump sum is either 25% of the pot, only the tax-free part, or none, so a set amount from AVCs isn't there yet. The 1.5× final salary limit depends on each person's service, so the plan is to let you enter the figure your scheme confirms, with the usual lump sum tax applied. I'll post here when it's added.
 
Looks good. Can you change the employee and employer contributions to give both an option for a percentage and also an actual monetary figure that you can input. I find that far easier to add in the money figure then a percentage as i can get this off the pension website.
 
Fair point, but net is hard to do well because tax in retirement depends on so much: married or single, a spouse with no income, kids, age credits, the over-65 exemption, USC. For now it's before tax, so I'd gross your net spend up a bit. I'd rather add net properly than guess.
Definitely forget doing net (all the credits, thresholds and changes by year, not worth it).
For most people they will want to compare to their retirement income to their own current gross salary anyway I'd imagine.
 
Thanks @Andynb, good idea. On the pension tab there's a switch "enter contributions as: % of pay or € a month", so you can type the monthly amounts straight off your statement, yours and your employer's. It shows the % too, and the € figure when you use the slider.
 
I’ll take a deep look at this later what I see many calculator do is start by asking when I want to retire. When the question I have for the calculator is when can I retire.

The second piece is explaining today’s value and future value. I feel some calc just convert a future number to current without telling you.

On the gross / net point above. I would like to see net as well as gross. Obviously there might need to be assumptions or choices made but my planned expenses would be in net.
 
@faketales
Thanks, good questions.

1. How much do I need? There isn't one right number, because it depends on the lifestyle you want. If you have a rough idea of what you'd want to spend each year in retirement, change your contributions, retirement age and returns until the calculator's sustainable income reaches that figure. That shows you what pot you'd need and what it takes to get there.

2. Future values and inflation. The calculator shows everything in today's money by default, so the figures are what they'd buy now. You can switch to "with inflation added" to see the actual future euro amounts. Inflation is set to 2% by default, and you can change it under "More options".

3. Net income. We've kept it to gross on purpose, because net is different for almost everyone. Rental income, other pensions, a working or non-working partner and how a couple splits their withdrawals all change which tax band you land in. For example, €4,000 a month could be taxed mostly at 20% for one person and partly at 40% for another. Add USC on top and a single "net" figure would mislead more people than it helps.
 
Back
Top