Case study Built a free Irish pension calculator — would value feedback from people here

scared_reality

New Member
Messages
19
I'm a developer, and over the last few months I've been building a free pension calculator for Ireland in my spare time. Full disclosure: it's my own site. There are no ads, nothing to buy, no sign-up needed and nothing you type is stored. I'm just trying to build something genuinely useful, and this forum is where people know these rules best.
pensionwise .ie


It tries to follow the actual Irish rules:


  • Age-related tax relief limits and the €115,000 earnings cap
  • Lump sum: 25%, first €200,000 tax-free, 20% up to €500,000
  • ARF drawdown with the 4% / 5% / 6% imputed distribution
  • State Pension from 66 (including partial rates) and the Benefit Payment for 65 Year Olds
  • Retiring early from 50, couples, and savings outside a pension with exit tax/deemed disposal and CGT

I'd really appreciate it if anyone could try it with their own numbers and tell me:


  1. Is anything wrong or oversimplified?
  2. Is anything missing that you'd want from a calculator like this?
  3. Is anything confusing to use?

Happy to be told what's wrong. I'd rather fix it than have people rely on bad numbers. It's a planning tool, not financial advice.


Thanks!
 
no sign-up needed
It asks me to sign in.

And the home page is not at all clear as to what I'm supposed to do.

In my opinion the dark mode and unnecessary colourful flashes are awful.

"add what you hold. see where it's going" and "your pension is a fund you have never seen" - what does that even mean?

I can't see any calculator.

Very confusing.

Looks like AI vibe coded slop to me I'm afraid.
 
Last edited:
Fair enough ClubMan, appreciate you having a look.


You're right on the sign in, that was the portfolio bit. The calculator doesn't need it, but the home page didn't make that obvious at all. I've moved it up to the top now.

Dark mode is a personal thing I suppose, there's a light mode with the sun icon at the top. Might make that the default, will see.

Ha, fair. AI helps me write the code quicker, but it's not making anything up. The numbers come from fixed rules I've gone through against Revenue and the DSP, and you get the same result every time you run it. I've put a good few months into it on evenings and weekends. Give it try and thank you again for your response I am reddit guy new here!!
 
There is way too much text on a single page and do you allow for salary growth and change in contribution allowance as you enter different age brackets (if salary is over 115k )
 
Looks pretty good, the actual pension screen graphs are well done, it’s good you can pick the actual funds in pension as opposed to random figures, although my ones don’t seem be there. I guess missing for me is changing the funds and fees once retired and in drawdown from an arf and prsa. There does seem to be someone launching a similar ‘free’ Ai based tool every week at the moment.
 
Seemed to be a lot going on for my phone. Will have a look on laptop later.

I think there is a gap for something. What I think a lot of calculators fail on is changing contributions at different times.
 
@Blackrock1
Fair on the text, I'll trim it. Salary growth is in there (under "more options" on the pension tab), and it shows your relief limit for your current age, but it doesn't step it up as you move into the next age bracket yet. Good shout, adding that.
 
It seems to automatically draw from pension at 60 if you plan to retire before that
Can you delay pension drawdown till 66??

Also any early retirement shows a fall in pension fund in the first year then growth after that

Thinking about it now the fall in the first year might be the 25% withdrawal which shouldn't be happening until you set up your arf
 
Last edited:
@Cervelo good catch, thanks. You can now choose when to start drawing your pension: on the retire tab, "start drawing my pension at" goes from when you retire up to 75. So you can retire at 60 and leave the pot invested until 66.

The drop in the first year is the 25% lump sum coming out of the pot. I've added a "lump sum" marker on the chart so it's clearer.
 
@Setforlife thanks, glad the graphs work for you. You can set a different shares/bonds mix for retirement on the growth tab, and I've just added a separate charge for the ARF too (pension tab, under "more options"). Which provider are your funds with? I'll check why they're missing. And a few of them don’t have live API’s so it’s hard to get them.
 
@givecredit good shout. On the investments tab on calculator page on under "more options" there's a section for other income in retirement: rental income, a defined benefit pension (with the age it starts), and anything else. It all comes down to what your pension has to pay on the pensionwise calculator based on your inputs.
 
@Yarm01
It’s are already present. On the investments tab, under "more options", you can add a defined benefit or public sector pension with the age it starts. AVCs are on the pension tab, and the State Pension is on the retire tab, so they all work together.
 
@faketales
Good shout!! On the investments tab, under "more options", you can add a defined benefit or public sector pension with the age it starts. AVCs are on the pension tab, and the State Pension is on the retire tab, so they all work together.
 
@Fortune
Fair question. I spent a good few months on this because the ones I found were either very basic or were really there to sell you a pension plan or get your details for an adviser.
What pensionwise does that I couldn't find elsewhere:
  • You can download your whole analysis as a PDF, or save your figures as a CSV and load them back in later. You don't have to start from scratch every time.
  • It takes you past retirement. You can see how long the pot lasts in an ARF, starting to draw down at whatever age you pick, and with the minimum withdrawals built in.
  • You can add your other income alongside it: the State Pension, a DB or public sector pension, AVCs, rental income, and ETFs or shares outside the pension with exit tax.
  • You can plan as a couple, step up your contributions as you get older, or max out the tax relief each year.
There's no sign-up for the calculator and nothing to buy. It's not perfect, and I'm still fixing things people point out here, so if something's missing or looks off, tell me.
 
Great job on the calculator! I tried it out and found it really useful.


The visuals look fantastic—the line graphs are really clear, and the year-on-year table is especially helpful for understanding the trajectory over time. Well done!


I do have a couple of suggestions that I think would add even more flexibility:


  • Investments Tab: Add an option to add and track multiple distinct investments.
  • Pensions: Provide options to add multiple pension streams.
  • Rental Property: Add a field for ongoing rental income, plus an option for the sale price after Capital Gains Tax (CGT) so the net proceeds can be factored into investments.
 
@dublinire
Thanks for trying PensionWise and for the suggestions, all three are in now:
  • Multiple pensions: on the pension tab, "+ add another pension". Each one has its own value, monthly payment and growth rate. They're combined at retirement, so the lump sum and €200k tax-free limit work across all of them.
  • Multiple investments: on the investments tab, "+ add another investment". Each one has its own return and can be ETFs, shares or savings, taxed the right way for each.
  • Rental property: rental income was already there under "more options" on the investments tab. You can now also sell the property at a chosen age. It takes off CGT on the gain and any mortgage left, invests the rest, and the rent stops from then.
All of it goes into the PensionWise PDF and CSV, and you can load the CSV back in. Let me know if anything looks off.
 
Back
Top