BBC: Tech CEOs blaming AI for mass job cuts, why?

traditional male employment options in the north of England and the social problems that resulted, notably that the young men have big psychological issues with feeling inferior, especially when the women were the ones getting the service industry jobs and their wages supporting the families.
But with AI its not those traditional physical roles that are being replaced its the white collar desk based jobs now, so the effects will not be on those traditional sectors now. As @Purple has pointed out they have been dealing with technology replacing jobs for decades. Therefore the social effects will be completely different
 
I was told by an employee in the Department of Trade and Enterprise that Dublin doesn't need grants and supports for employment as we have Google and Facebook etc. I replied that they aren't much use to a young person who left school at 16 and would traditionally have acquired their education and skills on the job rather than in a college
The Problem is we have not supported the type of industry in the recent past (last 15 years) the type of Industry that will benefit from AI the Most have been Ignored can Ireland turn this around yes or no,
I say no, For the most part we have lost the know how for ever,
Purple the Agri sector never ever lost the Locals with the good pair of hands as technology replaced jobs the always were able to see around the corner and find a way to not neglect what you yourself describe as the local with the good pair of hands,
For The Most Part Irish Home Grown Industry allowed this sector to die and most are dying and don't know why,
 
Last edited:
The Problem is we have not supported the type of industry in the recent past (last 15 years) the type of Industry that will benefit from AI
True, but that's where the growth was, that's where the capital inflows came from and that's where the US taxes could be harvested. Even without the jobs we could still have a lot of the taxes.

the Most have been Ignored can Ireland turn this around yes or no,
I say no, For the most part we have lost the know how for ever,
I know that we have to teach the skills in house that used to be taught in Trade schools as we don't have engineering trades anymore. I think the world is changing too fast for our State Sector education system to keep pace. The prospectus for my trade hasn't changed in over 30 years and it was out of date back then when I did it.
 
For The Most Part Irish Home Grown Industry allowed this sector to die and most are dying and don't know why,
Its not that irish industry allowed it to die, its more that employees obviously gravitated to the multinationals with those high paid "clean hands " jobs and ignored the lower paid hands on jobs in irish indiginous industry.
Also the government spoiled with multinstional corporation tax ignored thr difficulties of irish industry and began over regularlting alot of these out of business aswell.
 
10,000 jobs cut yesterday in Oracle. A friend who recently left there said that they will be laying off 30,000 people.
 
Facebook cutting 10% of its workforce again due to "efficiency", its dublin workforce is already down substantially. Facebook also employs alot of contractors to do the moderation of content, I presume they are also replacing alot of that with AI and automation.
 
Facebook cutting 10% of its workforce again due to "efficiency", its dublin workforce is already down substantially. Facebook also employs alot of contractors to do the moderation o
Its not that irish industry allowed it to die, its more that employees obviously gravitated to the multinationals with those high paid "clean hands " jobs and ignored the lower paid hands on jobs in irish indiginous industry.
Also the government spoiled with multinstional corporation tax ignored thr difficulties of irish industry and began over regularlting alot of these out of business aswell
We need to very quickly change policy and shift focus back to indiginous Irish Industry and start trying to attract more Industry to take advantage of the people skills AI is making redundant ,
 
We need to very quickly change policy and shift focus back to indiginous Irish Industry and start trying to attract more Industry to take advantage of the people skills AI is making redundant
Very hard to do when we have low levels of productivity in the SME sector, largely due to low levels of per-capita capital investment. We don't just need a VC culture we also need proper management in the SME sector where companies have the confidence and skills to take on debt in order to grow.
 
We need to very quickly change policy and shift focus back to indiginous Irish Industry and start trying to attract more Industry to take advantage of the people skills AI is making redundant
Very hard to do when we have low levels of productivity in the SME sector, largely due to low levels of per-capita capital investment. We don't just need a VC culture we also need proper management in the SME sector where companies have the confidence and skills to take on debt in order to grow.
I linked my own post above,
I can see it is not very well stated
I should have stated along with our own indiginous Irish Industry we need to focus on attract in a broad range of Industries
I know American Companies who have moved to Europe to be closer to their customers base and first port of call was Ireland and found from Feedback unless the were big Ireland showed very little interest and finished up locating to Holland instead of Ireland The funny thing is the employed a few Irish people for their operation in Holland,

The Brick wall the came up against was the people they were talking to in Ireland viewed their Industry trough the eyes of Existing Irish Industry and did not engage in a meaningful way,
 
Last edited:
Meta contractor Covalen to lay off 700 people (https://www.irishtimes.com/ireland/...0-jobs-threatened-at-meta-contractor-covalen/)
"The latest announcement comes days after Meta said it would lay off 10 per cent of its international workforce,...".
The article states that they do activities like content moderation. This is one of the easiest targets for AI to replace, leaving aside the question of quality of moderation.

In a separate article in the Guardian, "Mustafa Suleyman, Microsoft’s AI chief, said in February that he believes that AI will be able to replace most white-collar work within the next 12 to 18 months."

Regarding Covalen, what interests me - but doesn't surprise me - is the union's response, which sounds like every statement from every union ever after job losses announced.
“We urgently need real Government intervention around AI-related job losses, not just proposals and assessments. Tech companies cannot be allowed to discard hundreds of workers overnight to fund AI without strict government oversight.

“Employers in tech can afford to protect staff. Our wages and conditions should not suffer for a crisis we neither caused nor will profit from.”

Naturally I have sympathy for anyone losing their job, but this is the price of progress. This is the path we are on since the industrial revolution.
I have no doubt that the contract between Meta and Covalen does indeed allow for staff to be cancelled with short notice. This is how outsourcing works. And indeed, if Microsoft or Meta's profits increase, the Irish economy does profit from it.
 
Ten years ago if covalen was hiring 700 workers to work on social media moderation these would be promoted as high skilled, high value jobs for educated graduates and proves that Ireland is moving up the "value chain" away from the low value added jobs in manufacturing where Ireland needs to be. Now these are the very jobs that are being discarded by AI. Facebook had 3000 employees in Ireland 5 years ago now that has been reduced to 1800. It is the relatively high paid jobs for educated third level graduates that are being replaced by AI yet it is not getting that much attention . Is it because there is no easy jargon or mantra to address this ?
 
Is it because there is no easy jargon or mantra to address this ?
the new Jargon might be do we have to many houses for the amount of workers we now need,
on a more serious note we need to get moving on planning where the new jobs are going to come from, we know we have a shortage of workers in some areas the Question is will the people let go leave Ireland I suspect a lack of affordable housing and high living cost in Ireland will see many move on out of Ireland,
 
Ten years ago if covalen was hiring 700 workers to work on social media moderation these would be promoted as high skilled, high value jobs for educated graduates
You are correct, except a lot of "job creation" is talked up for obvious political purposes, using such language as "high skilled, high value" when in reality the roles are not.
I googled for a random example and found a nice example from the UK.
Lots of statements from politicians like "This investment will create highly-skilled jobs and boost living standards across the country". But in reality this is building Amazon "fulfillment centres" and we know all about them.

On the subject of AI replacing jobs, the winner is arguably Asia where much of the hardware is built.
 
On the subject of AI replacing jobs, the winner is arguably Asia where much of the hardware is built.
It's also the place where a lot of the "high skilled, high value jobs for educated graduates" are, the same ones that will be replaced by AI.

I'm not under valuing the intellect of achievement of any graduate but if the job you get doesn't relate to your degree and you can be trained in in a few weeks or months then it's not a high skilled job. I'd say that the role of washing machine service person (level 6 qualification) requires a higher level of job specific skill and training than many of the "high skilled, high value jobs for educated graduates".
 
Looking at this purely from an Irish point of view, the landscape for Irish graduates is changing extremely quickly and it is very difficult to both predict how this will play out or to advise students in what paths to follow right now. In my view companies are taking a massive gamble in wholeheartedly adopting AI and ploughing millions into it, which naturally will be at the expense of staff (i.e. humans). This is a huge initial investment with a view to cutting costs and I would be very fearful that it will go badly wrong in the long run. In my own job I can already see the impact it is having on the quality of work (negatively) and I can see how this will potentially play out in the long term and it's not good. Where AI should be viewed as a very powerful tool to be used by humans, it is instead being viewed as a replacement for humans. The staff using it are being strongly encouraged to adopt it into everything they do. The smarter employees will still review and take ownership of the output produced by AI and make the necessary changes (and spot and correct the many mistakes). The rest will simply happily take whatever churn it produces and run with it. Over time, this will result in inferior product and will pollute the very data on which AI relies, thereby leading to an ever decreasing quality of data. I really hope I'm wrong but the signs for me are ominous.
Back to the Irish point of view, inevitably this will lead to a reduction in the coffers from these large tech firms so we need to be getting plan B together pretty quickly.
 
Back to the Irish point of view, inevitably this will lead to a reduction in the coffers from these large tech firms so we need to be getting plan B together pretty quickly
We see very little posting about the Benefit of AI to be gained by end users from an Irish point of view,
I think the UK Government understand the benefit to be gained by small size Companies embracing AI,
I think Irish Government is focusing on large tech firms and how it affects them no one is really looking to help/encouraging Irish companies to embrace AI at an early stage,
 
What are your thoughts on the programs the Dept. of Enterprise have in place?
They are run by Enterprise Ireland and Local Enterprise Boards and I don't think much of them. The serious funding is for 3rd level institutes to advise businesses. EI has turned into a funding mechanism for universities.

My experience using EI and the IMR (Irish Manufacturing Research) for robotics and automation was that we got a portion of the money back that we spent educating students and consultants. Their actual constructive contribution was close to zero and we were 100% better off just doing it ourselves. The only thing that I ever found to be actually useful was some LEAN training.
 
What are your thoughts on the programs the Dept. of Enterprise have in place?
I see very little about creating jobs for the people displaced by AI,
not just the ones getting displaced in big companies , If The Department Of Enterprise programs are working we should be seeing headlines of AI replacing some existing jobs in Irish companies by now,
 
Back
Top