BBC: Tech CEOs blaming AI for mass job cuts, why?

galway

Frequent Poster
Messages
274
In recent weeks, giants including Google, Amazon, Meta , as well as smaller firms such as Pinterest and Atlassian, have all announced or warned of plans to shrink their workforce pointing to developments in AI that they say are allowing their firms to do more with fewer people,
above Taken From the BBC in the last few days,
One not the above stated the expected to half their workforce as a result of AI,
Do people in general think AI will shrink the workforce in the firms the work in over the next few years,
Any think it could half the workforce in a few years,
 
Last edited:
I work in tech a lot now, the reason is that you can use AI agents to do a lot of jobs - and they are highly impressive in terms of their ability and scope, then with coding you can do a huge amount of engineering without an engineer, and instead have an engineer look over the code after the AI writes it. These things all mean that in tech businesses with large resources and huge knowledge bases that AI tools can replace a lot of people there, I don't think it was 'sudden', rather the advances were so impressive so fast (within the last year) that it's bleeding out from the tech firms into widespread news and job markets.
 
Thanks MortgageBroker
AI has changed the mindset of some small Employers to take another look at technology to improve efficiency in their firms and are seeking to take advantage of technology the best way to do so is to lift out several layers of middle management They are finding the best use of AI is to helps the people at the very bottom become more productive by directly engaging and using the Information Ai has given them,
 
Last edited:
All true, but I feel some CEOs recently have partially been using the AI card to mask layoffs due to financial issues. Example Atlassian, successful products but hasn't been profitable for almost a decade. It's still the right decision for them, probably. Cut workforce, roll out more AI, get to profitability.
 
Last edited:
They are finding the best use of AI is to helps the people at the very bottom become more productive by directly engaging and using the Information Ai has given them
That gets rid of alot of "knowkedge workers" that are on relatively high wages doesn't it also alot bureacracratic roles but the grunters at the bottom are still needed
 
calling people grunters not very nice and speak for itself, people who use the word well we need say no more,
now let see what the word Gunter means,

Do you know where the word Gunter came from it night help you to understand AI and why it will make the relatively high wage workers who are well informed and well versed in their fields, AI is going to make some of them redundant,
on the other hand AI will help people further down the line become as well informed and well versed in the narrow field the work resulting in making some of the above redundant hopefully new jobs open up for them,
 
Last edited:
Was reading an article on the BBC website about the financial issues facing India's middle class. One of the examples was a call center, which has replace 3,000 works with AI chat bots.
 
Do you know where the word Gunter came from it night help you to understand AI and why it will make the relatively high wage workers who are well informed and well versed in the fields AI is going to make redundant

Perhaps @galway refers to the Gunter's Chain which was invented in 1620 for use by surveyors and has presumably been made obsolete by modern techology? Do spare a thought for the poor surveyors of old who had to lug around a 20.1m chain, or perhaps for their poorly-compensated assistant who had to do the lugging.
a former measuring instrument 66 ft (20.1 m) long, subdivided into 100 links, each of which is a short section of wire connected to the next link by a loop.

Or perhaps he refers to the unit of measure itself? The furlong and the mile appear to have survived, however, despite the advance of fancy new and improved measuring techniques.
  • a measure of length equivalent to a Gunter's chain, equal to 1/10 furlong or 1/80 mile.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps @galway refers to the Gunter's Chain which was invented in 1620 for use by surveyors and has presumably been made obsolete by modern techology? Do spare a thought for the poor surveyors of old who had to lug around a 20.1m chain, or perhaps for their poorly-compensated assistant who had to do the lugging.
correct,
Do spare a thought for the poor surveyors of old who had to lug around a 20.1m chain, or perhaps for their poorly-compensated assistant who had to do the lugging
Don't do a Joe on it now,:D
Gunter's Chain weighed max around 30lbs or 13.6 kg 66ft in length

the poor surveyors of old may have been poor but is not a reflection of their Intelligence,
when in use the poor surveyors did not lug forward the whole 13.6kg 66 ft from one measuring to the next they newly anchored the chain in the outstretched position they then went back to where the chain was anchored and swung it around for the next point and so on,
the job did not require heavy lifting the requirement was consistency presence and at the time for the most part light physical activity no heavy lifting or high speed just consistency,
 
Last edited:
It’s worth keeping in mind that most of these companies claiming layoffs because of AI are also selling AI products. It’s a win-win that is creating headline after headline, a plausible excuse for cutting post-COVID fat while pumping AI - look how much it saved us, maybe our AI product can save you money too!

I work in IT and spend most of my days working with AI now, it’s great, but I think the potential of huge job losses is being recklessly overblown as part of the marketing of AI.
 
I presume it is ok to link the below:


TLDR is:

the choice facing Irish workers is between two versions of the same outcome: a bubble that punishes workers on the way down, or a technology that punishes them by making their labour redundant on the way up.
 
I work in IT and spend most of my days working with AI now, it’s great, but I think the potential of huge job losses is being recklessly overblown as part of the marketing of AI.
I work in IT too and totally agree! I have had some good experiences with various LLMs and equally some mind boggling ones as well. Each AI model has its own strengths but I wouldnt trust any of them if outside of my skill zone. Still early days but from the free public models I have been using I would not trust them for hyper technical advice.
 
That gets rid of alot of "knowkedge workers" that are on relatively high wages doesn't it also alot bureacracratic roles but the grunters at the bottom are still needed

I often have breakfast with the former manager of a American Engineering Company based in Ireland
He always said when CNC Machining came in quite a few Engineers lost their way they made lots of hard tooling to form all shapes and sizes from metal blanks shapes
when the tool got tried out and the formed shape did not match what they were expecting lots went back looking for the problem in the CNC program that made the formed shape recutting tooling and in some cases getting new tooling made outside and getting the same results and then Questioning when outside vender last had their machines Calibrated last and want them to check if they had a problem with machinery or the equipment the used to check tooling,
He used to tell them I don't want to send the tooling to the customer I want to send the part that came out of the tooling we made parts like the one that the customer just ordered before we ever had CNC and we made it so good we were their only single source for there parts,

he seen cancellation orders for new parts because the were chasing the wrong knowledge acknowledging the strength of a companies knowledge knowing where to find it and understanding ones own lack of it

he used to often quote Shakespeare, arrogance blinds a leader to danger,
 
Last edited:
I often have breakfast with the former manager of a American Engineering Company based in Ireland
He always said when CNC Machining came in quite a few Engineers lost their way they made lots of hard tooling to form all shapes and sizes from metal blanks shapes
when the tool got tried out and the formed shape did not match what they were expecting lots went back looking for the problem in the CNC program that made the formed shape recutting tooling and in some cases getting new tooling made outside and getting the same results and then Questioning when outside vender last had their machines Calibrated last and want them to check if they had a problem with machinery or the equipment the used to check tooling,
He used to tell them I don't want to send the tooling to the customer I want to send the part that came out of the tooling we made parts like the one that the customer just ordered before we ever had CNC and we made it so good we were their only single source for there parts,

he seen cancellation orders for new parts because the were chasing the wrong knowledge acknowledging the strength of a companies knowledge knowing where to find it and understanding ones own lack of it

he used to often quote Shakespeare, arrogance blinds a leader to danger,
I'm a Toolmaker by trade and worked on manual machines (Milling Machines and Lathes) for years before moving to CNC's. Now it's almost all CNC's with CoBots loading the machines and AI assisting with the programming.

It used to be local young men with "a good pair of hands" who got the jobs. Now it's engineering graduates of all genders, colours and ethnicities as well as lower skilled people to work in support roles like packing, dispatch, accounts and clerical work and even then many of those admin jobs have also been automated.
What AI will do to Banking and Finance and IT has already happened in manufacturing and happened in Agriculture over the last hundred years.

It may be counterintuitive but in the case of the business I work in over the period of my working life employee number have increased, as have real wages. The differential between the highest paid person and the lowest paid person in the business has decreased and our gender pay gap in positive, in that the average female employee earns more that the average male employee.

The downside is that the locals with the "good pair of hands" don't get many of the jobs anymore as we hire based only on ability and attitude.
 
Thank you @Purple that is really interesting. It just makes me recall a British documentary I saw some years ago about the disappearance of traditional male employment options in the north of England and the social problems that resulted, notably that the young men have big psychological issues with feeling inferior, especially when the women were the ones getting the service industry jobs and their wages supporting the families.
 
Thank you @Purple that is really interesting. It just makes me recall a British documentary I saw some years ago about the disappearance of traditional male employment options in the north of England and the social problems that resulted,
I was told by an employee in the Department of Trade and Enterprise that Dublin doesn't need grants and supports for employment as we have Google and Facebook etc. I replied that they aren't much use to a young person who left school at 16 and would traditionally have acquired their education and skills on the job rather than in a college.

Given the levels of educational snobbery in Ireland part of me is happy with the prospect of graduates who think they are highly skilled not just losing their job but realising that they entire employment sector will disappear.

notably that the young men have big psychological issues with feeling inferior, especially when the women were the ones getting the service industry jobs and their wages supporting the families.
I think that's caused more by the fact that housing supports and welfare is overwhelmingly given to women (like in the UK our welfare system encourages couples not to marry or even put the father's name on the birth cert), leaving men powerless and inconsequential.


My advice to young people who want to futureproof their skills; do a construction trade. If you are good you'll always have a job. You'll be highly skilled and well paid. You'll also be taken seriously when you tell people you work hard and have a hard job.
 
Back
Top