Zach & Paschal - Offer & Counter-Offer . . .

trajan

Registered User
Messages
372
Was watching Goodman: Too Big To Fail hier soir.

I just don't get the bit where Paschal Phelan and his Jordanian partner, Zachariah El-Taher, in Master Meats had a buyout clause that allowed one partner to either accept the other partner's offer for their 50% of the shares or else counteroffer for 10% more - in which case the other partner had to accept.

Is this type of nutty deal common in 50/50 companies ?

Isn't it plain that if the initial offer is fair, based on existing earnings, then the prospective enhanced freedom of decision by the buying partner should generate far more value than would be allowed for by a mere 10% premium ?

And that being so, the party making the initial offer is effectively signalling that the business is worth much more and that the other party should buy it, finance allowing ?

To my mind, the counteroffer should be more like 30% above book value for a business worth millions.

Please note that my comments here do not diminish the challenge of finding finance for a millions-scale buyout.

(Nor do I approve of Paschal's low-ball offer tactics.)

It is just the strategy aspect of it that I am flummoxed by.
 
Last edited:
To my mind, the counteroffer should be more like 30% above book value for a business worth millions.
I would think 10% is sufficient to ensure any bid reflects the true value. Requiring a 30% premium on top of the initial offer would allow someone to bid 90% of the true value knowing the other partner would have to pay 117% and ends up with a bad deal with either option.
 
I understand it is more usual to have no 10%. I think Phelan sued Goodman on the grounds that this unusual addition was unfair and they settled out of court for something between €10m and €15m.
 
I understand it is more usual to have no 10%.

So . . . stalemate when the pards' relations turn sour ?

I think Phelan sued Goodman on the grounds that this unusual addition was unfair and they settled out of court for something between €10m and €15m.

But Goodman wasn't involved when the partnership between Phelan and El-Taher was done.
This 10% thing was something they had agreed between themselves.

Or are you suggesting Goodman engineered El-Toher's buying 50% of Master Meats so as to eventually get in the back door of Phelan's company?
 
So . . . stalemate when the pards' relations turn sour ?
I understand that it is very unusual to have a premium in a Texas shoot out. It gives the first to move a big advantage - I can see frantic last minute lawyering with big arguments as to who got in first. Without a premium it doesn't matter who got in first - the highest bid wins.
Or are you suggesting Goodman engineered El-Toher's buying 50% of Master Meats so as to eventually get in the back door of Phelan's company?
Phelan did argue that he was the victim of a conspiracy between the other two.
 
Back
Top