Who's for President 2025? Any takers?

What would the WRC say I wonder if a convicted rapist took a case after being denied a job having served their sentence ?
There's no protection against it. It's not a protected characteristic and that particular offence, it is never regarded as 'spent'.
If it was a lesser offence then after X years it is 'spent' and there is no obligation to disclose it.

A conviction for a sexual offence, an offence tried in the Central Criminal Court, or an offence resulting in a prison sentence of greater than 12 months will not be treated as spent convictions.

 
Catherine Connolly went to Syria in 2018 for "research and training". She went with the venerable Clare Daly & Mick Wallace. What training did they undertake? Bashar al-Assad was still in power at the time and gasing his own people. Is this the person we want as President?
 
under no circumstances would I employ a convicted rapist. I wouldn’t even have to think about it.
Yes, and it's not up to CC to "have a think about it," or to "reflect on it as a woman" . There are clear processes and procedures - as any Civil Servant here knows very well. Plus, there are extra layers of vetting required in certain Government Departments including Justice and Houses of the Oireachtas etc with a higher bar than the standard. (There are also strict conditions in relation to sex offenders as CC should have known.)

Her previously employed convicted criminal didn't meet that standard and therefore was never officially permitted access to work there. (Although it seems CC tried to overturn that decision by the Gardai.)

According to multiple sources who spoke to The Journal this week, An Garda Siochána refused to grant the necessary clearance to allow Ní Shionnáin work in the buildings of the national parliament over security concerns. In her interview, Connolly denied that she had written to authorities to overturn any decision that had been made. She said the process had “gone on and on” and that in the end Ní Shionnáin had left of her own accord.

She said that she did have some contact with a Chief Superintendent involved in the security clearance process.
 
He comes across as completely reasonable and transparent.
a €3k debt isn't news.

I agree with some of these points and the overall sentiment expressed.

That said, the decision-making of what's in the public interest was poor. Gavin was a high-profile public figure.
Tenant/landlord disputes are in the public interest. A public body has been established to assist in resolving disputes.

Donald says he 'tried everything'. He didnt. He didn't use the media to report that a high profile figure like Jim Gavin is a landlord who owes a tenant €3,300.

Most people don't want to be the news in a dispute, not least reporters themselves. Often, when other options fail, they resort to using the media to help highlight an injustice.

Donald had every opportunity to use his position to highlight his grievance when Gavin was a high profile figure. He chose not to, and that is his choice.

I just think it is somewhat dishonourable of him considering his own position, to now use the media because Gavin is now running for a high profile public position.

All for a €3,300 debt 16yrs ago that could have been highlighted in the media long ago.

That is just my outlook on it, I accept others will not agree.
 
if there was a chance to also embarrass FF in the process
I do think that was the motive.

I don't buy into the vindictive nature of it if it happened when he was Dublin manager. Its news, sin é. I agree it probably wouldn't have got much traction as it would probably have been resolved.

My only issue is that Donald chose not to make it a media issue although he could have, as he is now doing. I just think having made that initial decision he should have kept to it.
 
Donald says he 'tried everything'. He didnt. He didn't use the media to report that a high profile figure like Jim Gavin is a landlord who owes a tenant €3,300.
As above, a member of the media using their position to run a personal vendetta would be very much frowned upon. I'm sure when he said he did everything he didn't literally mean everything, like he didn't walk around Jim's office with a placard, he didn't talk to Joe, he didn't employ a dept collection agency, etc., etc.. What was likely intended was that he did everything that is reasonable given the small sum involved.

Much larger debts involving more public figures are common, few if any make the papers. Even those that result in court judgments that would be risk-free to report seldom get much coverage.

Most people don't want to be the news in a dispute, not least reporters themselves. Often, when other options fail, they resort to using the media to help highlight an injustice

Have you some examples? I've written off a larger debt than that, I'd much prefer to lose double it again rather than feature in the media.
 
a member of the media using their position to run a personal vendetta would be very much frowned upon.

But he is a member of the media using his position now to get his money back.

I'm sure when he said he did everything he didn't literally mean everything, like he didn't walk around Jim's office with a placard, he didn't talk to Joe, he didn't employ a dept collection agency, etc., etc.. What was likely intended was that he did everything that is reasonable given the small sum involved.

True, so is using the media now to get his money back reasonable, or unreasonable?

Have you some examples? I've written off a larger debt than that, I'd much prefer to lose double it again rather than feature in the media.

Same as that. So that is two examples of people, you and me, preferring not to be a feature of media reports.
 
I’m very easy on this. Many years ago our local union branch invited a writer from the Examiner to face us with what he had been reporting. We felt aggrieved and once in the door he said “You create news, I’ll have it in print; that’s my job.” We were all quiet boys and girls when he left the meeting, but we learned that if we behave like stool pigeons, we’ll get shot at. Jim Gavin would have done better to resolve the issue years ago and not set himself up as a stool pigeons.
 
My only issue is that Donald chose not to make it a media issue although he could have, as he is now doing. I just think having made that initial decision he should have kept to it.
He pretty much wrote off the money years ago but, as luck would have it for a media person, he found himself in possession of a much more valuable news story.

It would be a poor media reporter who let that story slide, particularly given the history.
 
I’m very easy on this. Many years ago our local union branch invited a writer from the Examiner to face us with what he had been reporting. We felt aggrieved and once in the door he said “You create news, I’ll have it in print; that’s my job.” We were all quiet boys and girls when he left the meeting, but we learned that if we behave like stool pigeons, we’ll get shot at. Jim Gavin would have done better to resolve the issue years ago and not set himself up as a stool pigeons.

I do not disagree with any of that.

Here is thing - the manager of the greatest, if not, the most successful GAA football time ever is a landlord who owes a former tenant €3,300 and wont pay it back despite all the efforts of the tenant.

Is that not news worthy?

Absolutely it is!

But...the tenant involved used his position in the media to keep the matter out of the media. After all, who wants their personal affairs detailed splatted across the headlines?

Then, subsequently, said landlord runs for Presidency as candidate for FF (endorsed by Mícheál Martin) and lo-and behold, 16yrs after the initial event, the tenant decides that his position in the media may now be used to make the matter public.

This has nothing to do with a €3,300 debt from 16yrs ago for a deputy editor of a national newspaper. It has nothing to do with Jim Gavin.

It has all to do with damaging Fianna Fáil campaign. A campaign that was split from the start by isolating the Ahern, Kelliher and even Hannifan camps. Míchaél Martin, has used the public perception of Jim Gavin - loyal, diligent, hard-working, community based...and most of all, totally clean!
 
the tenant involved used his position in the media to keep the matter out of the media.

Whoever the tenant was, they would have to co-operate with the newspaper in order for the story to go ahead. Otherwise there are no details to fill the story, no evidence to corroborate, no legal eagle sign-off, and no editorial support.

This has nothing to do with a €3,300 debt from 16yrs ago for a deputy editor of a national newspaper. It has nothing to do with Jim Gavin.

It has all to do with damaging Fianna Fáil campaign. A campaign that was split from the start by isolating the Ahern, Kelliher and even Hannifan camps. Míchaél Martin, has used the public perception of Jim Gavin - loyal, diligent, hard-working, community based...and most of all, totally clean!

What is this based on? I have been listening to Niall Donald for years on Crime World and I don't think he has ever expressed any sort of political opinion one way or another. I don't know if Fionnán Sheehan has any particular affiliation either.

Surely if they were out to get Gavin and FF (and if Donald wanted the money so badly) then they would have been straight out of the traps and run the story on week 1 of the campaign.

I suspect that whichever candidate/party had been involved it would have been the same result.
 
Last edited:
Míchaél Martin, has used the public perception of Jim Gavin - loyal, diligent, hard-working, community based...and most of all, totally clean!
Yes but it was an inaccurate perception as it turned out.

That’s the real story. It didn’t matter when he was Dublin manager but it flipping well matters now that he’s running for public office.

If he was running for FG or SF the reporting would be no different.
 
It didn’t matter when he was Dublin manager

It absolutely did matter!

As a supporter of GAA I have nothing but the highest respect for JG for what he achieved as manager. Incredible.
Not just 6 All-Ireland titles but he effectively binned Jim McGuinness's puke football and has been at the heart at rejuvenating the game as an entertaining spectacle.

Throughout doing so, he was always extremely humble, diligent, precise, and never gloating in what he was doing or achieving.

That is not to say he was infallible it either would have, or would have not been sorted at the time. And the rest of us would have been spared this debacle if the media reporters were as humble, diligent and precise at their own jobs as Gavin was as Dublin manager.

Donald, in his capacity as an employee of a national media organisation chose not to bring this 16yr affair to the public forum when Gavin was a high public profile figure winning All-Irelands - because he was directly involved and it didn't suit his own interests and nothing to do with 'public interest'. It was all to do with his own interest.

What else is he hiding in the "public his interest?"

He only chose to make this public when there would be political fallout, and as it turns out FF are reeling.

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

JG - you are better off without and better off into the arms of your family. You were enticed into swap of poison, thankfully, your reputation and achievements will stand forever and overwhelm this grubby, deceptive and utterly self-serving effort of reporting news "in the public interest".

Gutter media.
 
It absolutely did matter!
It didn’t matter to the general electorate. Now it does.

Prior to this election campaign, he was perceived as a quiet-spoken, cool-hand-luke character whose actions spoke louder than words.

Now he’s revealed as a man who disregards his responsibilities and leaves creditors high and dry.

No one really cares what impact he had on Jim McGuinness’s style of winning Gaa matches.
 
Last edited:
I've a funny felling Mrs Steen isn't going to go quietly into the night just yet...

David Quinn has come out with a strange article essentially fanboying over Steen: Frustrated conservative voters like me are waiting for Ireland’s answer to Nigel Farage or Giorgia Meloni

He says Steen could be Ireland's version of Farage or Meloni. I find this strange as these two are mainly known for their anti-immigration policies which I don't think Steen has ever mentioned? As anyone who pays attention at Mass will tell you, Catholic social teaching is very clear about immigration in general and refugees in particular, so I would be surprised if Steen would contradict the Church. Unlike Meloni.

Steen's focus is the traditional, nuclear family. Farage and Meloni are not poster children for this. Meloni had a child outside of marriage and has since split with the father. Farage is on his 2nd marriage but currently living with his girlfriend. Again, I can't see the parallel with Steen?

But Quinn is friends with Steen, so maybe he knows something we don't.

This part was pretty funny:
Almost nobody likes to be called a “conservative”. The word has become associated with backwardness and resistance to change.
The poor guy needs to read the dictionary and take a nap.
 
@Sister Sara you must really really hate the media to be trying to spin this as an issue with the media. You're portraying the greedy landlord as the victim and the poor tenant as the bad player in this story which can't be easy for you to swallow. I really think your anti-media bias has blinkered you in this one as I don't see anyone else here or anywhere else putting forward such an argument or agreeing with your take on this.
This is a mess all of Jim's own making and even now he doesn't appear to accept that. It takes a certain character to fail to pay back money owed, despite repeated requests and even promising to do so, and despite receiving 3 solicitors letters. The very least that should be done now is a full apology and an offer to pay not just the money owed but the costs incurred and interest accrued after such a long period. Instead we get an offer to pay subject to 2 clarifications. Someone should take the shovel off him quick.
 
Catherine Conolly, IMO, would have done better in a 3 horse race - those middle voters would be split between Humphries and Gavin. Now that there's only 2 candidates left, a lot of the Gavin votes will probably go to Humphries so doesn't do Conolly any favours. So, less chance for the left-wing, socialist Conolly. Given what we know of trips to Syria, views on Russia, never mind the rapist answer, we might be better off. Sinn Fein have gone awfully quite too. A vote for Catherine Conolly is a vote for Sinn Fein...thanks, but no thanks!!
 
Back
Top