Who's for President 2025? Any takers?

Maria Steen
In that case I agree with you. There's a significant minority of the country who are Mass going Catholics and they are completely disenfranchised in the media and almost completely disenfranchised the political arena. They have accepted the democratic will of the people in the liberalisation of the country and it is not good that they are so voiceless.
 
Last edited:
In that case I agree with you. There's a significant minority of the country who are Mass going Catholics and they are completely disenfranchised in the media and almost completely disenfranchised the political arena. They have accepted the democratic will of the people in the liberalisation of the country and it is not good that they are so voiceless.
I don't agree with you
I would say if you did a survey of most Mass going Catholics in every parish in the republic of Ireland you would find support for all political parties and non party,spread across parishes,
What you will find and it has nothing to do with Mass going there is a chunk of people who feel we no longer have a centre-right/left party the can vote for,
Possibly the best Government we ever had was made up of FG John Bruton leader Lab Dick Spring Leader and The Democratic Left Proinsias DeRossa, made up of a center-right FG and center- left Lab and Democratic left, 1994 to 1997
We no longer have this choice,
 
There's a significant minority of the country who are Mass going Catholics
Ah yes, the old argument thrown out that anyone who disagrees with the over liberalisation of the country is a Catholic and must be sneered upon. For very many this has nothing to do with religious beliefs, but all too easy to lump it in there.
 
Sf won't like it if Steen gets a nomination as she'll pick up a large part of the anti establishment vote that they were hoping Connolly would get and ride on those coat tails.
 
I'd see Connolly as hard left.

I don't support her but it's just not accurate to say she is hard left.

Economically, she is more of a social democrat. Unlike the hard left, she is not advocating dismantling capitalism, nationalising industries, etc.

She is critical of Europe and voted against Nice/Lisbon over fears of militarisation, but she is pro-EU, unlike the hard left who would want to leave the union. She is against NATO membership but usually talks about it from a sovereignty/republican angle rather than the hard left borderline conspiracy theory approach.

She is basically a Soc Dem with strong republican and anti-military beliefs. That's why she got the Greens on board, sure they are often called "Fine Gael on bikes", hardly Marxists. She did a very good job as leas ceann comhairle, can we imagine Solidarity/PBP being so professional and impartial?

While CC has certainly been down some strange roads with Daly and Wallace

I have seen this mentioned a few times but with no examples given so I struggle to see what she has done with them? She is pro-neutrality and anti-militarisation but other than that what is the overlap?

There's a large untapped vote out there, as was demonstrated during the so called "Woman in The Home" Referendum which Steen was heavily involved with.

If Steen gets it, she has my no 1, intuitively (as already referenced) theres a huge conservative cohort in Ireland

What is the basis for claiming there is a big untapped conservative vote? In the last 10 years the public has overwhelmingly approved same sex marriage, legalised abortion, liberalised divorce, removed blasphemy from the Constitution, and re-elected the most left-wing President we have ever had.

Steen was on the winning sides of the Family and Care referendums ("durable relationships" and woman in the home) but they were also opposed by many liberal groups for various reasons. The analysis afterwards emphasised issues with the wording and lack of trust in the government rather than any underlying conservatism.

On the other hand, Steen was on the losing sides of the Marriage and Abortion referendums which are much core liberal issues, so that surely undermines the idea that there is a shy conservative vote being suppressed that she can unlock. Aontu, Renua, and the various smaller right wing/conservative offerings at local and national elections have all failed to capture support.

And what is this recurring, paranoid-sounding claim about conservatives being denied a voice? The Iona Institute seemed to have a dedicated parking spot in Belfield at one stage. David Quinn and Breda O'Brien are in the national newspapers on a regular basis, often alluding to this trope that they are being "silenced". There are several members of the Oireachtas, like Ronan Mullen and Mattie McGrath, who are very socially conservative, and they get plenty of attention, often disproportionate to their mandates or the content of their contributions.

It has never been easier to start a TikTok channel, podcast, or other free medium to spread ideas. The Irish Catholic and Gript.ie are widely accessible. I just don't see how those of us who are right-wing or conservative can complain that we are somehow being suppressed. When you look at the evidence, it is not that the country is being denied the opportunity to support conservatism, it is just a lack of interest on the part of the voter.

I agree that the nomination process is too restrictive and favours the left/centre/establishment, so Steen should absolutely have a shot at running, but expecting some sort of conservative resurgence is not realistic.
 
Ah yes, the old argument thrown out that anyone who disagrees with the over liberalisation of the country is a Catholic and must be sneered upon.
Where did I say that?

For very many this has nothing to do with religious beliefs, but all too easy to lump it in there.
I agree. I have some conservative beliefs, particularly around issues such as abortion, and I'm a fiscal conservative, and I'm an atheist.
 
What a motley crew we may get to choose from...
  • Mary-Lou ('her day will come?')
  • Gerry Adams ('his day will come?')
  • Mairead McGuinness
  • Ryan Tubridy
  • Bertie 'no bank account' Ahern
  • Peter 'Dragon' Casey - again
  • Mary Hanafin
  • Declan Ganley - again
  • Someone as a unified left candidate (not Mary-Lou as she's a nationalist not a socialist)
  • Joe Duffy - from the 'good afternoon to you' party
  • Conor McGregor - wants to punch above his weight..
Or even a rank outsider....
  • B
I hope Mairead is recovering well
none on the list since the 8 of July made it to the contest ( I suppose you could include CC in the above list)
Brendan Burgess - power to the people party
next time maybe,
 
If steen is not able to get on the ballot it will reflect very badly on the political system here and especially on FG and FF . Then whoever wins the presidency will lack credibility because it will be perceived as lacking democratic credentials. Yes the rules maybe that she needs 20 dail and seanad signatures but the political parties are not allowing an open nomination process and the seanad is stacked in favour of the government given that the taoiseach alone gets to select 11 seanad seats himself so non of those are likely to bite the hand that put them on the seanad. The whole thing has slight reflections of putins elections with the system denying candidates on the ballot that might take votes away from establishment
 
The nomination process favours candidates backed by the largest parties, which skews the choices available to the electorate. Candidates trying to challenge the largest parties don't get a chance to even be presented as alternatives.

I wouldn't vote for Maria Steen for many reasons but others would. They need to feel they've had their say otherwise there's a risk of alienating a substantial block of voters, and that's not good for democracy.

Alienation breeds disillusionment and leaves a vacuum open for exploitation by extremists. This happened in the US and we got Trump. It happened in the UK and we got Brexit.
 
Alienation breeds disillusionment and leaves a vacuum open for exploitation by extremists. This happened in the US and we got Trump. It happened in the UK and we got Brexit.
Making people believe that they are victims can lead to the most appalling outcomes.; wars, genocide, ethnic cleansing, terrorism, exploitation, etc.

In a representative democracy it is very important that everyone not only is represented but also feels represented.
 
Last edited:
I'm almost tempted to vote for Connolly....

FF/FG stacked the deck against Steen and those who would have welcomed her inclusion..

They need to be taught a lesson.
 
If steen is not able to get on the ballot it will reflect very badly on the political system here and especially on FG and FF . Then whoever wins the presidency will lack credibility because it will be perceived as lacking democratic credentials.
I really don't understand this.

Steen has a history that would prevent many people giving her a nomination especially her strong links with the Iona Institute her stance on same sex marriage and her fervent anti abortion, anti choice stance.

That's not a fault of FF FG or any other party. I for one was very surprised and disappointed that Aubrey McCarthy gave her a nomination.

Her politics are not what the vast majority of Irish citizens want to represent the country on a world stage. There are over 100 non government supporting TD's & Senators and she was unable to get 20 of these. There are 31 local authorities and she was unable to get 4 of these.

Councils, senators & TD's are elected by the public to represent them and people would understand that party policies are part of that.

I think the democratic process has played out very well here

as for those saying it is FF FG who stacked against her - just look at the numbers, she had little support from anyone other than tobin and his right wing comrades
 
Unfortunately we will never know if this is true. But you are missing the bigger issue of a govt preventing an open election.
Where has the government prevent this?

As for Maria Steen presenting as someone who would give people "choice" - hmmm.... A bit like saying Trump is the person to promote free speech. (hopefully US immigration don't read this as I'd probably be prevented from entering the US for such a view)
 
Back
Top